Easily the best key forward on the ground in two of his three premiership wins and was basically as good as any of the others in the third. He could have/should have filled his boots in two blow-out wins in the 2022 finals and ended with about 10 in that series... oh well, he kicked the game breakers, missed the junk times.
Unlike the others listed, Colemans were never really Hawkins' thing. I'd argue that unlike the others, Hawkins could have a great game and kick 0-1 goals.
Maybe the Coleman isn't an award that Hawkins really rates? Surprised he went on to win one I guess, I mean after all as you said "Coleman's were never really Hawkins thing"