You guys need to do more research... found this resource for Caulfield ages ago.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/caulfieldbears/page3/
They have a pic of various Caulfield jumpers side by side.
So... anyone going to try the Brighton Penguins jumper?
We do our research. How did I find the Caulfield v Coburg game? The first two jumpers are what they wore in the match in the online clip.