Opinion Your teams 21st century FAB FOUR?

[RUNVS]

Cos it's too hot to go outside, gonna run thru the afl


hawks
buddy
Hodge
Mitchell
Lewis

Mitchell Lewis is one guy, not two.

 

[Mr Meow]

1. Buddy
2. Goodes
3. Kennedy
4. Hall

If I had a 5th it would be Craig Bolton, almost included him over Hall.

I can't remember Hall and Franklin playing together but it must have been bloody exciting.

Seems everyone just ignored OP's rule 2.

 

[Colonial]

Cameron, Ward, Kelly, Cogs, Davis.

Yes ive edited out Tobes. Ward needs to be there.

 

[RUNVS]

I can't remember Hall and Franklin playing together but it must have been bloody exciting.

Seems everyone just ignored OP's rule 2.

Never did unfortunately, which is a pitty as they would have been a hell of a combination.

 

[caloschwaby]

John, Paul, George and Ringo

 

[Mr Meow]

Never did unfortunately, which is a pitty as they would have been a hell of a combination.

Don't worry I knew.

But I agree, a time machine where peak Hall is still around 2014-2016 alongside Franklin would've made that Sydney forward line dynamite.

 

[citizen-erased]

Mitchell Lewis is one guy, not two.

So good he gets two spots
Taking hawks to a flag next year

 

[citizen-erased]

I can't remember Hall and Franklin playing together but it must have been bloody exciting.

Seems everyone just ignored OP's rule 2.

Ergh now I have to do it again

 

[citizen-erased]

This time by the rules

Adelaide
danger
Betts
Talia
Thompson

Bris
black
Voss
Aker
Lappin

Carl
Cripps
Betts
Curnow
Docherty

coll
pendles
Buckley
Swan
Clement

ess
Merrett
Jobe
McDonald-Tipungwuti
Hurley

freo
Pavlich
Fyfe
Sandy
Mcpharlin

geel
ablett
Selwood
Scarlett
Enright

gcs
Miller
Ablett
Lynch
Swallow

gws
toby
Cameron
Whitfield
Kelly

hawks
buddy
Hodge
Mitchell
Lewis

kang
Goldy
Harvey
Petrie
Brown

melb
gawn
Oliver
Tracc
Jones

port
tredrea
K.cornes
Boak
Gray

rich
dusty
Rance
Cotchin
Riewoldt

swans
Jpk
Goodes
Bolton
RoK

saints
riewoldt
Hayes
Goddard
Milne

wb
johnson
Smith
West
Boyd

wce
Judd
Glass
Cousins
Kerr

 

[BluesFever]

To line up with the Lions Fab 4, isn’t it 4 best mids?

Ignoring the played together component:

Judd
Cripps
Walsh
Murphy

Very good. I wonder if we can clone Judd and Murph??

 

[OniAu]

Goddard quite stiff there.

yeah but so were montagna and dal santo

Didnt see Goddard . But Riewoldt wasnt stifff, Dal Santo was and still miles behind Nick. From the evidence i saw anyway

 

[citizen-erased]

To line up with the Lions Fab 4, isn’t it 4 best mids?

Ignoring the played together component:

Judd
Cripps
Walsh
Murphy

Very good. I wonder if we can clone Judd and Murph??

Limiting to pure mids who played together, i dont think you get many fab 4s

Bris' voss, black, aker, lappin
Geel with Selwood, ablett, chapman, corey.

Pies' pendles, bucks, swan and daisy or sidey ignoring the disparity in their peaks. I assume they all they got a game in together.

Judd, cousins, kerr, embley the closest I can think of

 

[Hoops]

Ablett
Selwood
Scarlett
Bartel

 

[Engimal v3]

Cameron, Ward, Kelly, Cogs, Davis.

Yes ive edited out Tobes. Ward needs to be there.

I would have though Greene makes it easily? He has a pretty strong case for being the best Giant ever.

 

[Piggy Smalls]

Limiting to pure mids who played together, i dont think you get many fab 4s

Bris' voss, black, aker, lappin
Geel with Selwood, ablett, chapman, corey.

Pies' pendles, bucks, swan and daisy or sidey ignoring the disparity in their peaks. I assume they all they got a game in together.

Judd, cousins, kerr, embley the closest I can think of

I reckon Fyfe, Mundy, Sandilands and Pavlich could have attended the same centre bounce at least once.

 

[JackOutback]

Judd, cousins, kerr, embley the closest I can think of

Cox, Judd, Cousins and Kerr is the answer... and they played a lot of games together. Slot them into any team and odds on you're winning a lot of games.

 

[citizen-erased]

Cox, Judd, Cousins and Kerr is the answer... and they played a lot of games together. Slot them into any team and odds on you're winning a lot of games.

Agreed
That midfield was the equal to the lions fab 4.
Cox more than just a ruck too.

 

[Reg Grundy35]

Pendles, Bucks, Swannie and Sidey. - Steak Knives Crisp not far away either.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

1. McLeod 1995-2010, 5x AA, 3x club champion
3. Goodwin 1997-2010, 5x AA, 3 times club champion
3. Walker 2009-current, 1x AA, 6x leading goal kicker
4. Betts 2914-2019, 3x AA, 4x leading goal kicker

Apologies to
Dangerfield 2008-2015, 3x AA, 1x club champion
Laird 2013-current, 2x AA, 3x club champion
Talia 2011-2020, 2x AA, 1x club champion
Thompson 2005-2017, 1x All Australian, 2x club champion

Ricciuto doesn't qualify as 1993-2007

 

[Thrawn]

4. Betts 2914-2019, 3x AA, 4x leading goal kicker

Betts is always going to be the best fab one with his time machine!

 

[eth-dog]

Fletcher
Watson
Hird
Lloyd

 

[Freomaniac]

1. McLeod 1995-2010, 5x AA, 3x club champion
3. Goodwin 1997-2010, 5x AA, 3 times club champion
3. Walker 2009-current, 1x AA, 6x leading goal kicker
4. Betts 2914-2019, 3x AA, 4x leading goal kicker

Apologies to
Dangerfield 2008-2015, 3x AA, 1x club champion
Laird 2013-current, 2x AA, 3x club champion
Talia 2011-2020, 2x AA, 1x club champion
Thompson 2005-2017, 1x All Australian, 2x club champion

Ricciuto doesn't qualify as 1993-2007

So No love for Sauce Jacobs? Shame on you then. lol

 

[Farang83150]

Cox
Cousins
Kerr
Judd

 

[Freomaniac]

Cox
Cousins
Kerr
Judd

Forward Press , your thoughts?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

So No love for Sauce Jacobs? Shame on you then. lol

Loved Sauce but never AA (though should have been) & never won a B&F.