Starting 22 dilemmas

[swans4eva]

This thread is for those who dont know who will score higher and who they should play as a reserve and who they should play in their starting 22.

Ill start us off

Robinson vs Otten

Brown vs Ballantyne (will he play) vs Walker vs Hentschell (two to play)

 

[Big_Tazz]

easy, id kill myself before id pick one of either

 

[AjsGuns]

Id go Otten + Bally (he wont be back for round 2 though) + Hentschell

my Turn

Suban vs Petrenko
Otten vs Rich
Ziebell vs M Brown vs Walker

 

[scotty4]

id go robinson brown and walker personally.

 

[swans4eva]

Id go Otten + Bally (he wont be back for round 2 though) + Hentschell

my Turn

Suban vs Petrenko
Otten vs Rich
Ziebell vs M Brown vs Walker

Petrenko, Otten and with the last one i hav the same problem because Ballanyne is injured but i dont hav ziebell. I would easily go ziebell for yours but with mine walker or brown?

 

[AjsGuns]

If brown plays up forward then Brown but i doubt he will so id go with Walker

 

[Jimhouse]

Will Ziebell keep his spot though?

 

[Benno_900]

Yes, not every debutant has to amass 20+ touches and kick 9 goals to keep their spot.

 

[dylan123]

k.tippett v jacobs v spencer

hill v suban v broughton(if he plays)

 

[ToroHombre]

k.tippett v jacobs v spencer

hill v suban v broughton(if he plays)

That ruck one could have been saved by picking Kreuzer like you said you were thinking of doing. Or even better, McIntosh. Sorry mate just had to say that.

 

[Brazen]

butler vs robinson

 

[Dunn - Well Done]

Well my backline is a disaster (6,7,8,9 backs) are Hill, Suban, Broughton and Raines (Injured).

Cheney looks a good option especially for Rainesy.

Suban shows great scoring potential.

 

[sossy19]

Well my backline is a disaster (6,7,8,9 backs) are Hill, Suban, Broughton and Raines (Injured).

Cheney looks a good option especially for Rainesy.

Suban shows great scoring potential.

haha im in same predicament, i dont feel like using a trade this early, so given that neither hodge nor mackie got dealt any games, ill just plug in suban/broughton, on the assumption that 2 of the 3 freo rooks play

 

[chrisknights]

butler vs robinson

i dunno, i stuck with robinson v haselby

im leaning towards butler for u, and haselby for me

 

[AjsGuns]

k.tippett v jacobs v spencer

hill v suban v broughton(if he plays)

If you paid 200k for Tippet u should be starting him ......

i would take Hill then Suban then Broughton
Hill had a bad game and Suban only had 50% TOG

 

[Wilso]

Otten V Robinson for me. I'm leaning towards Otten because in situations like this, whenever you switch the players around. The player you put on the bench always seems to score more.

Quality reasoning right there

 

[swans4eva]

Otten V Robinson for me. I'm leaning towards Otten because in situations like this, whenever you switch the players around. The player you put on the bench always seems to score more.

Quality reasoning right there

Exact same problem, with exact same reasoning

 

[FromDaics2Dids]

Exact same problem, with exact same reasoning

Its stupid reasoning in theory, but i have to admit your spot on with it. The amount of times its happened has convinced me that this way of thinking is correct.

 

[swans4eva]

Does anyone know when Ballantyne will be back coz i think he will be a very quality player and i have him as one of my forward line reserves...

 

[Virgil]

Does anyone know when Ballantyne will be back coz i think he will be a very quality player and i have him as one of my forward line reserves...

4 weeks, according to the Freo website.

 

[premiers06]

my two dilemmas this week is the common one of raines, should i bring suban on or trade raines.

The other one is Ziebell v Beams v if beams gets picked who would you start?

edit: also does anyone know if Swift will play any time soon?

 

[swans4eva]

my two dilemmas this week is the common one of raines, should i bring suban on or trade raines.

The other one is Ziebell v Beams v if beams gets picked who would you start?

edit: also does anyone know if Swift will play any time soon?

Not sure about Swift but i would go ziebell with your one...lots of people have been turned off by one game! but then again they were playing melbounre

 

[Juddy88]

edit: also does anyone know if Swift will play any time soon?

Most likely no chance.

 

[swans4eva]

4 weeks, according to the Freo website.

That probably means about 6 or 7 after playing in wafl he actually would be a very good player to buy wen cashing in a cash cow