2010 - Worst trades of the season

[Mink]

Re: Worst trades of the season

That Goodes score had me scratching my head. At the game I had him pegged for a 90+, almost definitely a 100+ because every time we started getting close he'd ping another goal or behind. But a 3.3 performance gets a 60-odd? Buggers me how, save for the three frees against and that'd only be a 18 point drop.

I'm with you on that one. I was at the game too - and while I missed the first minutes where Brown kicked 2 goals, I thought Goodes was more influential and effective over the remainder of the game. Then I get home and find that Brown scores and extra 80 odd points with only a couple more possessions...

 

[Ed_Gein]

Re: Worst trades of the season

Brown and Goodes efficency were pretty much the same but Goodes had 5 clangers to 2. How many frees did Brown give away?

Still caNt see an 80 point difference though.

ThoughT Goodes would have been a great upgrade target. Now I'm not so sure. May try for Didak instead.

 

[dlanod]

Re: Worst trades of the season

Brown and Goodes efficency were pretty much the same but Goodes had 5 clangers to 2. How many frees did Brown give away?

Still caNt see an 80 point difference though.

ThoughT Goodes would have been a great upgrade target. Now I'm not so sure. May try for Didak instead.

I've had him since the beginning and he just doesn't seem to be SuperCoaching it up this year, regardless of the impact he has on the field. I'm not going to get rid of him but if you're looking to bring someone in, look elsewhere.

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Re: Worst trades of the season

I think I am leading this by a long way. After the conclusion of round 2, I was averaging 2324.5, at this stage I saw only 2 or 3 week links in my side. Hille was averaging 52 and Hall 51.5, I thought, 'aw yeah why dont I be smart and do a trade before the price changes'. The 2 guys I brought in are now injured and have been scoring poorly since. Seaby avg 39.5 since I brought him in, and Dangerfield avg 45.3 now out with a broken hand/wrist (he was traded last week for buddy). During this time Hall's avg is 88.5 and Hille 77.

Now my avg is down to 2170.33 and add to this the 4 trades I have burnt, I think most ppl would agree I win this award... If would like to mail out the trophy I will send you my address via PM

 

[dplggr47]

Re: Worst trades of the season

Seaby after round 2...nuff said with his score of 3. net $200.

 

[remedi]

Re: Worst trades of the season

wow LOL, I dont have seaby cause I knew he was going to be average but............



to only net 200 is just.....WOW

 

[Hu$tler]

Re: Worst trades of the season

In a rush a few Fridays ago, I accidently went JB to Goodes, instead of Riewoldt.

...

 

[Bombersfan81]

Re: Worst trades of the season

like many i went clark to seaby after round 2..... since then

1. Seaby has averaged 39.5
2. scored a total of 158 points
3. has been as high as 339200
4. with that 3 in his price, has made me a MASSIVE $200
5. with a massive b/e & the target i had in mind for him starting to hit his straps (cox) will need to be traded this week weather he plays or not.

In the meantime clark has...

1. lost 107,100
2. missed 1 game (warnock would have covered with 76)
3. averaged 72 in the other 3 games
4. for a total of 292 points

consoling me is the fact I used the $$ to bring in JB for Medhurst......but doing the maths seaby/ brown is up a grand total of 1 LOUSY POINT vs clark/ medhurst up till end of round 6..... so it has cost me 2 trades to gain 1 point & keep 106,900

May not be the worst trade in this thread, & I'm sure I have company with me on this trade, but its got to be a contender right?

SOMETIMES I REALLY HATE SUPERCOACH!!!!

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Re: Worst trades of the season

In a rush a few Fridays ago, I accidently went JB to Goodes, instead of Riewoldt.

...

Hmm... Do you mean Riewoldt to Goodes instead of JB? And I'm sure you 'accidently' did it. SuperCoach... pfft, more like SuperFlop

 

[Hu$tler]

Re: Worst trades of the season

Hmm... Do you mean Riewoldt to Goodes instead of JB? And I'm sure you 'accidently' did it. SuperCoach... pfft, more like SuperFlop

Yes that's what I mean, and i'm serious. Brown had just scored a ton so why would I have traded him out. They were a similar price tag so I probably wasn't even looking. I did the Roo for Goodes trade in DT correctly lol.

So do I get JB back?

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Re: Worst trades of the season

Nah mate to late, just stick with Goodes or you wasting 2 trades for no reason. They can bot score similar.

 

[Hu$tler]

Re: Worst trades of the season

Nah mate to late, just stick with Goodes or you wasting 2 trades for no reason. They can bot score similar.

I still have Riewoldt though.

Trade I meant to do a few weeks ago was Riewoldt to Goodes, but I did Brown to Goodes instead.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Re: Worst trades of the season

I still have Riewoldt though.

Trade I meant to do a few weeks ago was Riewoldt to Goodes, but I did Brown to Goodes instead.

I think you need to invest in a pair of glasses.

 

[thedaz47]

Re: Worst trades of the season

In a rush a few Fridays ago, I accidently went JB to Goodes, instead of Riewoldt.

...

i think what he means is when Riewoldt was injured he went Brown>Goodes instead of Riewoldt>Goodes

poor fulla

 

[lemon chicken]

Re: Worst trades of the season

Seaby after round 2...nuff said with his score of 3. net $200.

Im in this club. Got rid of Jolly who is stinking it up pretty bad but still a waste of a trade.

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Re: Worst trades of the season

I think you need to invest in a pair of glasses.

You haven't done a Walker/Hentschel yet, maybe he can borrow yours.

 

[bestin]

Re: Worst trades of the season

I traded jono brown to colin sylvia last week

 

[Ed_Gein]

Re: Worst trades of the season

I traded jono brown to colin sylvia last week

Reminds me of the case of people trading out Harvey after his 11 only to respond with a 176 lol.

Silly trade made. J.Brown is quality.

 

[bestin]

Re: Worst trades of the season

Reminds me of the case of people trading out Harvey after his 11 only to respond with a 176 lol.

Silly trade made. J.Brown is quality.

ive been reminded a fair bit at school about how shit that trade was

i thought sylvia would dominate and brown was playing with injury so would do shit

 

[Judd_Magic]

Re: Worst trades of the season

You haven't done a Walker/Hentschel yet, maybe he can borrow yours.

I had a hangover and had about 3 hours sleep the night before when I did that trade at work on a Friday.

Sounds like you don't have a very good memory there champ as I've told the story quite a few times since.


At the end of the day drunken trades aside, my team still did a hell of a lot better than yours and will do so again this season.

Now run along now.....

 

[Spudregus_87]

Re: Worst trades of the season

I had a hangover and had about 3 hours sleep the night before when I did that trade at work on a Friday.

Sounds like you don't have a very good memory there champ as I've told the story quite a few times since.


At the end of the day drunken trades aside, my team still did a hell of a lot better than yours and will do so again this season.

Now run along now.....

Don't undermine it by calling it a mere 'story,' it's bigfooty folklore for crying out loud...

Whats with the double spaced paragraphing this season Juddy? Been watching too much Un_OC I think.

 

[Hu$tler]

Re: Worst trades of the season

i think what he means is when Riewoldt was injured he went Brown>Goodes instead of Riewoldt>Goodes

poor fulla

That's it!

Yeh some glasses would be good haha, can't believe I actually did that still!

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Re: Worst trades of the season

I've told the story quite a few times since.

Really? That doesn't sound like you.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Re: Worst trades of the season

Really? That doesn't sound like you.

 

[Parasite]

Re: Worst trades of the season

I have some sage advice that applies in this situation.

Whenever my 2.5 year old daughter makes a face or whines, I tell her that if she is frustrated or wants something she should use her words to tell me what's wrong.