Ins & Outs for Round 13 v Brisbane

[Richm0ndrule]

Edwards was pretty ordinary with his disposal today, lots of hospital balls. I'd get rid of him and bring in Foley. Webberley should come in too, but I'm not sure who for. Griff for Polak maybe, or Griff for Webberley.

King, White and Farmer were all outstanding today, no way one of them will be dropped. White has grown on me so much, he's got a role to play now.

Edwards was bloody excellent. gave us the most Inside 50's i believe, inside 50's = Riewoldt goals.

 

[Roar Metre]

Whilst sometimes Edwards might side step one too many players or sky a ball forward when he's under pressure, sending him to the 2's isn't going to help his game or strengthen the side.

After a 50 point win the only changes we should see are structural or players returning from injury.

I thought Farmer was really good today and agreed that the coaching staff are a fan of his so I can't see him being dropped either.

 

[CoZi36]

Just to let you guys know, Brown is out for a month with his groin injury.
Source: http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/96265/default.aspx

 

[tugga]

Just to let you guys know, Brown is out for a month with his groin injury.
Source: http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/96265/default.aspx

I know I won't sound sincere, but I am disappointed. I am a massive Brown fan and was looking forward to seeing him play next weekend as I am heading up to the Gabba. Can't wait.

 

[coke_zero]

If Moore is out i would give the Goo a shot.

 

[bigricho12]

Can't believe Tambling is not copping some heat. Sometimes running the ball 70 metres sideways while your forwards are picked up and covered is as good as turnover

Bling out for Foley
Farmer out for Webberley
Moore out for Thursty or Goo

 

[Madtiger2006]

It's exciting that Post and Gourdis aren't far from playing. Some much needed height in defence

 

[Wacky Tiger]

Edwards was fantastic today. Led us early on with a couple of one percenters (smothers and shepards) which set the tone for the match.

 

[Bazzar]

Unchanged.

Was said (somewhere) a few days back Foley was having an extra week over the break. No one from this game has to be dropped. All played a great team game.

The only change i can see is Tambo if the shoulder is rooted, and Webs comes in to replace him.

Forgot, Moore`s foot, then Thursty in, if that is suspect.

 

[nugget_12]

If Tambling and Moore are injured i'd only change them two for Foley and either Thursty or Goo.

Webberly needs to come in too but me personally would give him till after the break to freshen up for the last half of the year in the 1's.....I watched him at craigieburn on saturday and dead set the kid didnt even break into a sweat playing for the burgers and still managed to be in the bests.

Give him another week IMO, we need him for the back end of the year and leave the rest of the squad unchanged and we could surprise a few in Brissy with brown being out leaves them quite vulnerable in my eyes!

 

[Dr Awkward]

OUTS:

Riewoldt: Not working hard enough defensively
Deledio: Needs some confidence in the magoos
Martin: Doesn't earn his own ball
Cotchin: VFL standard player

INS:
Roberts
Polak
Dea
Rance

 

[HBK619]

Can't believe Tambling is not copping some heat. Sometimes running the ball 70 metres sideways while your forwards are picked up and covered is as good as turnover

Jeez took enough posts and I'm REALLY surprised nobody mentioned it. But Tambling was terrible today. Horrible disposal, doesn't make the right decisions and only goes hard half the time.

Tambling out for Webberley if Foley isn't fit.

Moore looks to be out for at least a week, so either Goo or Thursty to come in.

 

[Richo is God]

Can't believe Tambling is not copping some heat. Sometimes running the ball 70 metres sideways while your forwards are picked up and covered is as good as turnover

Bling out for Foley
Farmer out for Webberley
Moore out for Thursty or Goo

Why do you want farmer out? i thought he was pretty good today

 

[win1soon]

Anyone else see relton roberts at nandos? lol thought he should stay away from there. changes foley in for tambling inj

 

[peejay]

Anyone else see relton roberts at nandos? lol thought he should stay away from there. changes foley in for tambling inj

I saw him, along with gilligan and the goo. Half time at the nandos van outside the ground.

But in fairness i did not see if any of then ordered anything.

 

[1980GFVideo]

It's exciting that Post and Gourdis aren't far from playing. Some much needed height in defence

Where was your thread "Can we make the finals this year?"

I was expecting it.

 

[Madtiger2006]

Where was your thread "Can we make the finals this year?"

I was expecting it.

10 wins a row will probaby get us 9th again. We'll stick with 4

 

[coke_zero]

OUTS:

Riewoldt: Not working hard enough defensively
Deledio: Needs some confidence in the magoos
Martin: Doesn't earn his own ball
Cotchin: VFL standard player

INS:
Roberts
Polak
Dea
Rance

Dea is a good in.

 

[CoggaRules]

Thurst is a shoe in to be in the 22 next week. Apart from that, Webberley or Nahas might get a gig, if the team balance warrants it.

 

[santa claws]

for me white king mcguane and tambling all in the gun. the first 3 continue to murder the ball make poor decisions even though they give 110%. tambling well i reckon he has to be hardwicks pet .

oh and finally while i want us to put as many games as possible into him i reckon astbury like vickery before him is just not getting much of the ball if this continues it cant be good for confidence or touch let him go back to coburg for a short stint to get a bit of the ball.

 

[Spluff]

Out: Moore (inj), Tambling (inj)
In: Thursfield, Webberley

 

[Bazzar]

for me white king mcguane and tambling all in the gun. the first 3 continue to murder the ball make poor decisions even though they give 110%. tambling well i reckon he has to be hardwicks pet

Some things never cease to amaze.

 

[Big Bad Buddy]

I thought Polo had a good game at Coburg, and if anyone has to come in Nahas and Polo would be the first options. They both played fine games.

 

[Tomnat Tigers]

Outs:
King
moore(of inj)
INs:
Webberly
Post

 

[DeViouS]

I'd bring in Foley and Nahas. And drop Griffiths/Astbury?