Players that wont be on our list at the end of the year

[GoTheSwannies]

I have 3 players that I think won't he on our list come the wnd of the season.

Jared Moore - had his opportunities but was really nothing more than a solid link man who makes good decisions. Not overly attacking, not enough to survive in today's game.
Nathan Gordon & Brett Meredith - both have been on the list for a while, both are very vanilla and don't look likely to be anything more than serviceable. Neither has shown anything special and barely do the basics well.

I'd be surprised if any of the above players survived this year (provided they're out of contract).

One of either seaby or white are probably likely to be cut

Who are your picks?

 

[Onetonylockett]

Nathan Gordon just got elevated to the senior list last year didn't he?

 

[bedford]

Yes he did , i don't think too much thought went into the OP. Moore would have to be off as you can't carry a player who is only good in the wet.

 

[Riders of Rohan]

People getting only 1 year on the senior list isnt uncommon. If Nipper doesn't improve as much as we hope it's a very real possibility he could get cut this year.

 

[GoTheSwannies]

Whether it be at the end of the year, or next year, is beside the point really. My opinion is that, I don't think either Meredith or Gordon will be on our list in the future. Neither has shown anything special and barring a meteoric rise over the course of the season I don't think they will.

Others may disagree and I'm happy to hear their thoughts. Others might pick other players who are less valuable to our side and should be delisted first, I'm interested to hear others opinions.

 

[bedford]

Good thread, we haven't even started this season

 

[baja]

Good thread, we haven't even started this season

Yeah Im not a fan of threads like these, much rather support all our players even in the little ways but each to their own I guess. I wonder if some will be happy if they get it right?

 

[swansfan51]

Yeah Im not a fan of threads like these, much rather support all our players even in the little ways but each to their own I guess. I wonder if some will be happy if they get it right?

Even if all our players are superstars, which they aren't, at least 2 of them will not be on the list at the end of the year - that is AFL rules. It is far more likely to be more than that.

 

[baja]

Even if all our players are superstars, which they aren't, at least 2 of them will not be on the list at the end of the year - that is AFL rules. It is far more likely to be more than that.

fair enough, personally I dont like subjects that are negative towards anyone wearing red and white, especially at this time of the year.. I have no problems with anyone else discussing it like I said before, each to their own.

 

[Leapin Leo]

Wasn't Moore just included in the 9 man leadership group? They wouldn't have done this if they didn't have longer term plans.

Meredith, Heath, and Everitt would be the first 3 players culled IMO.

Moore, White, Dennis-Lane and Seaby would be in next group.

Depends on injuries throughout season and who gets gametime etc but can't see any of those 7 in our best 22.

 

[Swan4Life]

Way too early for a negative thread like this one.

 

[Leapin Leo]

I don't think it's necessarily a negative thread. It's always good to look back and see how different things pan out at end of year.

One of the players we think are a bit shaky could have a breakthrough season and become a good news story.

It's a cold hard fact and the list managers are already looking at who is available in the draft and for trade and which players on our list are expendable.

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Paul Bevan

 

[S120]

Paul Bevan

Rowan Warfe too.

 

[Bobbykirkkelly]

I think this thread is totally pointless. I'm sure everyone is aware of the trouble that a hero of our club, Brett kirk had in establishing himself in the side but once he did he bought a whole culture to our club. All players develop at different rates and some don't make it but if the club thinks they have potential they will keep them on the list. Lets leave it up to the club to make the call as they have done with many players who initally showed some potential.

 

[GoTheSwannies]

I have 3 players that I think won't he on our list come the end of the season.

Jared Moore - had his opportunities but was really nothing more than a solid link man who makes good decisions. Not overly attacking, not enough to survive in today's game.
Nathan Gordon & Brett Meredith - both have been on the list for a while, both are very vanilla and don't look likely to be anything more than serviceable. Neither has shown anything special and barely do the basics well.

I'd be surprised if any of the above players survived this year (provided they're out of contract).

One of either seaby or white are probably likely to be cut

Who are your picks?

Bump

 

[CAS79]

Bump

Im also claiming Moore, Seaby, Meredith and TDL from the thread done on new years day. I also claim White, we got him signed off.... Horribly wrong on one though.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2012-deliver-or-depart.900678/#post-23091865

 

[Gongswan]

Rowan Warfe too.

You forgot Wade Chapman