MRP / Trib. Embley's hit on Pearce - how many weeks?

[Miguel Sanchez]

Craig O'Donohue suggests it'll be two weeks, or three weeks if it's deemed reckless rather than negligent.

http://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/sport/a/-/afl/17994595/the-whistleblower-heat-on-eagle-docker/

 

[Biggie]

3 for mine.

2 with early plea?

Might be 4, 3 with early plea, you just don't know.

Bastard wants to play into 2014 as he can't string together games to get to his milestone goddamnit! ha

 

[The Falcon Strike]

225 base points plus carry overs and loadings.

Will end up 3 down to 2 IMO

Negligent, High Impact, High Contact (Rough Conduct)

Reckon Pav's will be

Reckless, Low Impact, High Contact (Forceful Front on contact)- 250 base

Edit: Embley's will be 325 - got my activation poin ts wrong

 

[mulburnboong]

Embers will get 3. He's got carryover points and the MRP will want to claim that.

 

[groga]

3

 

[mulburnboong]

225 base points plus carry overs and loadings.

Will end up 3 down to 2 IMO

Negligent, High Impact, High Contact (Rough Conduct)

Reckon Pav's will be

Reckless, Low Impact, High Contact (Forceful Front on contact)- 250 base

MRP really needs to simplify this sillyness. Loading, carryover, head high, low impact, rough conduct...

Maybe they should go back to;
1. Is he hurt? Y or N, go to 1a
1a. Was the recipient a b*tch? Y or N, if Y go to 3, if N go to 2.
2. Was it on purpose? Y or N, if Y go to 4, if N go to 3
3. Play on
4. 2 weeks on the sideline

 

[Chris_6678]

Well Pav got 3 and Embers got 2....surprised Pav got 3 would have though 2.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Pav had a bad record as well. Though Brown played on and Pearce got subbed out with concussion, you'd think that would add to Embley's penalty.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Embley's was negligent, high impact, high contact rough conduct. 325 points, plus 68.75 carryover points, down to 295.31 points and (just) a two-week ban with an early plea.

Pavlich's was reckless, medium impact, high forceful front-on contact. 400 points, plus 93.75 carryover points, down to 370.31 points with an early plea.

 

[Marlin01]

Gold!!!

 

[Natho]

Ah well least pav got 3.

 

[bluengold89]

Pav hates Mitch Brown, was pretty lucky to have his last hit assessed as low impact, maybe it was an even upperer by the tribunal.

 

[QS]

3 weeks. After seeing it again, Embley takes his eye off the ball and did not need to go the bump although pearce did lunge in front of him.

 

[The Passenger]

2-3 sounds about right for both hits.

pav knew he was in trouble as soon as he hit him but it was too late.

 

[Nuke Fremantle]

2-3 sounds about right for both hits.

pav knew he was in trouble as soon as he hit him but it was too late.

Good to see the MRP ignored his lame "it was an accident" throwing the hands up in the air.

Pity about Embley, he's making real heavy weather of his 250 milestone.

 

[bodazoka]

At first glance agree with both calls.

Embley a little unlucky as it was more of a Hodge going for the ball but he did seem to take the eye off the ball a little.

 

[ziad]

all about right. pav is a cheap sniper, embers played his role

 

[StrappingTape]

I saw it for the first time then and I'm not sure what Embley was meant to do, he had to through the contest to me it was just a football incident.

 

[West Coast 06]

I saw it for the first time then and I'm not sure what Embley was meant to do, he had to through the contest to me it was just a football incident.

That's it. From the ground on Sat we could see what was going to happen at that stoppage like it was in slow motion. I was yelling don't stop Embers! If he had have pulled out of that contest I would have been filthy, but he didn't and that was the right thing to do.

 

[Keys]

I was yelling don't stop Embers!

Do that often?

 

[dajesmac]

Weird, I thought Pav was unlucky at the time.

 

[Dark Sharks]

God dammit, Embley is surely doing this so he gets to go around NEXT season and play his 250th

amirite!

 

[Dark Sharks]

all about right. pav is a cheap sniper, embers played his role

That's a bit harsh. Call me Luke Darcy, but Pav is a champ, he's not a sniper or a dirty player IMO. Hope he takes up commentary.

Embley dropped his knees into a player on the ground 2 weeks ago, and is now getting suspended again..
I think saying "Pav is a cheap sniper, Embers played his role" is a bit one eyed.

 

[larrikin]

That's it. From the ground on Sat we could see what was going to happen at that stoppage like it was in slow motion. I was yelling don't stop Embers! If he had have pulled out of that contest I would have been filthy, but he didn't and that was the right thing to do.

I tend to agree. They both ran 20m to get to that contest and I honestly thought live that embley was goig to get there first. When he didn't he was always in trouble....

 

[swannies]

I tell you what this MRP is skewiff. I saw worse acts in a junior footy carnival on the weekend which didn't even have free kicks paid for.