Jake Carlisle - would we?

[Carnthedockers]

Your numbers don't add up mate.

I didnt realise Greene went so early, maybe he was lamenting that he had been picked so high, and that Forster was too slow.
It was after that draft so a fair while ago. If you dont wanna buy it thats cool, I get that people make up BS, but I dont. Id love to say what I knew but no one on here would believe it anyway.

 

[slicedndiced]

I didnt realise Greene went so early, maybe he was lamenting that he had been picked so high, and that Forster was too slow.
It was after that draft so a fair while ago. If you dont wanna buy it thats cool, I get that people make up BS, but I dont. Id love to say what I knew but no one on here would believe it anyway.

We took Sheridan and Crozier before Forster.

Not disbelieving that you have a contact, a few of us here do to, but what you said made no sense.

Play on, chin up.

 

[DMan 11]

Back on topic - I've thrown carlisle's name into the BF freo trading pot a number of times, personally think he is a gun with a unique skill set/athletism. Imagine he, tall Pearce and tanner smith in years to come - wet pants material right there.
We'd be stupid to think the club, and particularly simon Lloyd with his essendon connection wouldn't be putting out the feelers. I can't remember what his contract status is ATM ??

 

[Taylor]

Essendon would drop Carlisle, play him in the 2nd for half the year and then demand Fyfe and pick #1 for him.

They are horrible to trade with.

 

[Freo88]

I didnt realise Greene went so early, maybe he was lamenting that he had been picked so high, and that Forster was too slow.
It was after that draft so a fair while ago. If you dont wanna buy it thats cool, I get that people make up BS, but I dont. Id love to say what I knew but no one on here would believe it anyway.

We picked Sheridan at 16. Maybe thats who you're thinking of.

 

[Stuart88]

Rd. 14 2013: Took notice of carlisle when he was swung fwd. and kicked 2 against the scum! Thought he was great in that game.

 

[slicedndiced]

Essendon would drop Carlisle, play him in the 2nd for half the year and then demand Fyfe and pick #1 for him.

They are horrible to trade with.

Not if ASADA ream them as hoped and expected.

They might not even be in the AFL for a year or two,

 

[Taylor]

It's all because of Hurley's five year contract, playing a potential AA-CHB out of position because a guy with more contract value than talent can't play forward.

Essendon will try and trade us Hurley before Carlisle.

 

[Rob]

I would rather Frawley but he will most likely cost too much

Only in salary. Carlisle would cost salary (albeit not as much as Frawley) and trade bait.

 

[Jimbos1]

Cool - pop down to the corner store and pick a couple up for us will you?

I dont think football works like that - taking 2 big name CHB's just because our key back's days are numbered.

Yeah I know right.

 

[slicedndiced]

Yeah I know right.

LOL, highly doubtful from your formline

 

[bone2468]

It's all because of Hurley's five year contract, playing a potential AA-CHB out of position because a guy with more contract value than talent can't play forward.

Essendon will try and trade us Hurley before Carlisle.

i wouldnt mind Hurley at the club

 

[DMan 11]

i wouldnt mind Hurley at the club

As a tackling dummy ...

 

[Taylor]

i wouldnt mind Hurley at the club

I don't think he is fast enough to read the play so poorly.

He is serviceable as a defender, Hooker is better and from WA

 

[Wigarus]

Back on topic - I've thrown carlisle's name into the BF freo trading pot a number of times, personally think he is a gun with a unique skill set/athletism. Imagine he, tall Pearce and tanner smith in years to come - wet pants material right there.
We'd be stupid to think the club, and particularly simon Lloyd with his essendon connection wouldn't be putting out the feelers. I can't remember what his contract status is ATM ??

I wonder if this actually exists.

We haven't had a good relationship with Essendon that I can remember. Plus I would have thought having Harvey as a senior coach would be worth more.

 

[slicedndiced]

i wouldnt mind Hurley at the club

 

[DMan 11]

I wonder if this actually exists.

We haven't had a good relationship with Essendon that I can remember. Plus I would have thought having Harvey as a senior coach would be worth more.

Yep- the BF freo trading pot definately exists.
Just add any player name from another team you want, halve their salary, provide a player from your own team 2 rounds later than what you should and wullah - you've made a trade in the BF trade pot

 

[Dockernut]

It's all because of Hurley's five year contract, playing a potential AA-CHB out of position because a guy with more contract value than talent can't play forward.

Essendon will try and trade us Hurley before Carlisle.

I'd take Hurley. Has keeeeled us as a forward in previous games.

 

[slicedndiced]

I'd take Hurley. Has keeeeled us as a forward in previous games.

Now you've got to lay off the coke.

 

[bone2468]

As a tackling dummy ...

Hurley i rate pretty highly for a player at the club... he could come play forward and with the likes of Barlow/Fyfe/Mundy delievering to him imagine the damage.

 

[Wigarus]

Yep- the BF freo trading pot definately exists.
Just add any player name from another team you want, halve their salary, provide a player from your own team 2 rounds later than what you should and wullah - you've made a trade in the BF trade pot

I was referring to Simon Lloyds Essendon connections.

 

[slicedndiced]

Hurley i rate pretty highly for a player at the club... he could come play forward and with the likes of Barlow/Fyfe/Mundy delievering to him imagine the damage.

 

[bone2468]

Everyone has their opinion mate. but RTB knows how to turn a players career around Look at walters hes a Jet now.

 

[slicedndiced]

Everyone has their opinion mate. but RTB knows how to turn a players career around Look at walters hes a Jet now.

Spud's don't come any more clearly defined than with Hurley.

 

[DMan 11]

I was referring to Simon Lloyds Essendon connections.

Ha ha - yeh I figured as much, was just being a smart a$$