2015 Draft, Trades and Free Agency rumours.

[Red Bull]

Good starting point.

Possible sweetener?

If Treloar nominated Carlton , that would get it done .
I'm divided on it , at some point Carlton have to pull the trigger on a genuine blue chip KPF in the draft .
Schache is there this year , but imagining Treloar working in tandem with Cripps is bloody tempting ...

 

[inamedthegiants]

If Treloar nominated Carlton , that would get it done .
I'm divided on it , at some point Carlton have to pull the trigger on a genuine blue chip KPF in the draft .
Schache is there this year , but imagining Treloar working in tandem with Cripps is bloody tempting ...

He'd have to nominate you though for just your first rounder.

A Cripps/Treloar 1-2 punch is pretty bloody good...

Nothing else to sweeten the deal for us?

 

[Red Bull]

He'd have to nominate you though for just your first rounder.

A Cripps/Treloar 1-2 punch is pretty bloody good...

Nothing else to sweeten the deal for us?

That pick could land you Weitering and i reckon you could live with that .

No real need for a sweetener , you already have shitloads of talent on your list that can't get a game ...

 

[inamedthegiants]

That pick could land you Weitering and i reckon you could live with that .

No real need for a sweetener , you already have shitloads of talent on your list that can't get a game ...

I'm greedy like that though.

Is Treloar the "franchise player" you guys need though?

He racks them up like a stripper with an expensive Coke habit, but I don't think he hurts the opposition enough.

 

[gym4life]

That pick could land you Weitering and i reckon you could live with that .

No real need for a sweetener , you already have shitloads of talent on your list that can't get a game ...

the pick alone won't get you trealoar. I'd offer eagles first, selwood compo and Lycett.

 

[Red Bull]

I'm greedy like that though.

Is Treloar the "franchise player" you guys need though?

He racks them up like a stripper with an expensive Coke habit, but I don't think he hurts the opposition enough.

That would be the offer ... and personally I'm still divided on it .

I guess nobody would be better placed than Silvagni to make the call though ...

 

[inamedthegiants]

That would be the offer ... and personally I'm still divided on it .

I guess nobody would be better placed than Silvagni to make the call though ...

Won't happen overnight, but with Silvagni at the helm your list will be cleaned up/out sooner rather than later.

 

[inamedthegiants]

the pick alone won't get you trealoar. I'd offer eagles first, selwood compo and Lycett.

We've got to shrink our list.

Just give us Nic Nat.

 

[Red Bull]

the pick alone won't get you trealoar. I'd offer eagles first, selwood compo and Lycett.

If Treloar nominated Carlton it would get it done .
The picks you have put forward would be of little interest to GWS , have you seen the talent they have already stockpiled ...

 

[Go Woods]

If Treloar nominated Carlton , that would get it done .
I'm divided on it , at some point Carlton have to pull the trigger on a genuine blue chip KPF in the draft .
Schache is there this year , but imagining Treloar working in tandem with Cripps is bloody tempting ...

Headed to Pies

 

[Red Bull]

Headed to Pies

Could very well be .
What will you put up for him ?

 

[Go Woods]

Could very well be .
What will you put up for him ?

Yeah that's the challenge, what is he going to cost us if it is true, our 1st & 2nd picks?? Can't see any players being swapped.

 

[Red Bull]

Yeah that's the challenge, what is he going to cost us if it is true, our 1st & 2nd picks?? Can't see any players being swapped.

Can't see GWS being interested in those picks for Treloar .
They are already loaded with talent and would only be interested in the absolute top picks or equivalent player talent .

 

[Red Bull]

Yeah that's the challenge, what is he going to cost us if it is true, our 1st & 2nd picks?? Can't see any players being swapped.

Your first round pick might be more in line with Aish .
Treloar is on another level ... the top shelf !!

 

[Keystone agony]

Not AFL Standard - Decision-making is horrendous.

Id take him for chips then

 

[Keystone agony]

So Syndey would have like a 1/3 of their salary sewn up on pretty much just 3 players. Maybe slightly less than a 3rd with Buddy, Tippett and Hanneberry. Doesnt Mitchell get 500k a year aswell?

Not even including guys like Parker, Kennedy, Captain Jack, Mcveigh, Richards, Grundy, Mcglynn ect

 

[FlowersByIrene]

So Syndey would have like a 1/3 of their salary sewn up on pretty much just 3 players. Maybe slightly less than a 3rd with Buddy, Tippett and Hanneberry. Doesnt Mitchell get 500k a year aswell?

Not even including guys like Parker, Kennedy, Captain Jack, Mcveigh, Richards, Grundy, Mcglynn ect

Sydney dont have a salary cap silly

They have a "we're so hard done by in sydney" pity kitty

 

[Keystone agony]

2 weeks until Round 15...

Anyone got anything good to swap me for Treloar?

KPD's and Ruckman will be good starting points...

Hooker or Hurley.

Quality KPPs dont grown on trees

 

[Colonial]

the pick alone won't get you trealoar. I'd offer eagles first, selwood compo and Lycett.

Your to generous. Just give us Nic Nat

 

[yaco55]

If you believe you can get more back in a trade than the compo pick. Though the more likely scenario would be an associated sweetheart deal on the side to not match.

And in the worst case scenario the PSD is an option - At the end of the day, its the height of stupidity to match an offer if the player wants to leave.

 

[inamedthegiants]

Yeah that's the challenge, what is he going to cost us if it is true, our 1st & 2nd picks?? Can't see any players being swapped.

Witts and your first?

 

[Red Bull]

Witts and your first?

Reckon Collingwood jump at that as quick as a flash

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Reckon Collingwood jump at that as quick as a flash

Spot on. Deal of the century. Collingwood supporters surely don't overrate Witts that much? They need to start thinking Sidebottom and better plus pick one.

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Witts is highly regarded by the Pies and has a lot of potential. In the open market he'd be worth pick 10-15 IMO. Pies 1st draft pick will be around 10-15. Treloar would be worth a pick around 1-3 IMO. Based on those evaluations it's 2 top 15 picks for 1 top 3 pick. Pies might need to add a little something to sweetener it but not a whole lot more.

I'd suggest something like this:
Witts, 1st rounder and 2nd rounder for Treloar and 3rd rounder.

 

[Boristown]

Won't happen overnight, but with Silvagni at the helm your list will be cleaned up/out sooner rather than later.

Yep, all he needs is 3 years worth of 5+ first round picks and they'll be well on their way to following the GWS set up.