List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[PieMan!]

as someone else has said. when u go to the big dance and play like he did last year proves one thing u are not a shit player

Mitch Morton saids hi

 

[coolidge1000]

id honestly think of trading witts and bringing in lunberger but I think we should have a crack at an outside mid lets do what Hawthorne do its time to go out throw some money or getsome that no one will expect and land him

 

[TradeDraft]

id honestly think of trading witts and bringing in lunberger but I think we should have a crack at an outside mid lets do what Hawthorne do its time to go out throw some money or getsome that no one will expect and land him

IF the talks are Correct that Witts is off to the Dogs. Then Signing Luey might not be the Worse Idea

 

[Apex36]

id honestly think of trading witts and bringing in lunberger but I think we should have a crack at an outside mid lets do what Hawthorne do its time to go out throw some money or getsome that no one will expect and land him

IF the talks are Correct that Witts is off to the Dogs. Then Signing Luey might not be the Worse Idea

Luenberger is not going to go to a club as a free agent where he won't be the starting 22 ruckman. Get the idea out of your head that we'll get him, because we won't.

 

[pie time]

Lycett from eagles please

 

[danielnajdek]

What happens if Grundy gets injured? Play Cox? LOL.

 

[left at home]

Mitch Morton saids hi

so does sidney

 

[PieMan!]

Lycett from eagles please

Would love to get Max Gawn who is out of contract

 

[Apex36]

What happens if Grundy gets injured? Play Cox? LOL.

Cox has proven himself a competent ruckman against AFL standard ruckmen this year. Playing him in the seniors isn't as far fetched as you make it out to be. Particularly next year after he has another preseason and a VFL finals series under his belt.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Cox could very well play ahead of Grundy if his development continues at the rate it is.

His tap work is already better imo. (Don't tell Dave, dont want him going all Liam Neeson on me)

Grundy obviously better with ball in hand, contested marking.

I like Wittsy but if he he brings in some decent currency it should be entertained.

 

[coolidge1000]

other option is big will minson hes clearly not happy at the dogs

 

[coolidge1000]

Luenberger is not going to go to a club as a free agent where he won't be the starting 22 ruckman. Get the idea out of your head that we'll get him, because we won't.

can you name one side in the afl where he will be starting ruck except essendon because I'm strugloing to be honest

 

[pie time]

other option is big will minson hes clearly not happy at the dogs

I would puke if we even consider him

 

[TradeDraft]

Cox could very well play ahead of Grundy if his development continues at the rate it is.

His tap work is already better imo. (Don't tell Dave, dont want him going all Liam Neeson on me)

Grundy obviously better with ball in hand, contested marking.

I like Wittsy but if he he brings in some decent currency it should be entertained.

Cox is about another 2-3 Years away of Getting Ahead of Grundy and that is not Counting on Grundy’s Development that he still has to come

 

[TradeDraft]

I would puke if we even consider him

Not Even as a Ben Hudson type thru the Rookie List?

 

[Apex36]

can you name one side in the afl where he will be starting ruck except essendon because I'm strugloing to be honest

Essendon, Bulldogs come immediately to mind. Geelong reportedly has interest too with McIntosh retired.

 

[Apex36]

Cox is about another 2-3 Years away of Getting Ahead of Grundy and that is not Counting on Grundy’s Development that he still has to come

He's not as far off as you think Dave. I've never seen anything like Cox's development curve. Within the space of 12 months he's gone from never even picking up a footy to being capable of playing senior footy if neccessary. He will be best 22 within 12 months at this rate.

 

[TradeDraft]

He's not as far off as you think Dave. I've never seen anything like Cox's development curve. Within the space of 12 months he's gone from never even picking up a footy to being capable of playing senior footy if neccessary. He will be best 22 within 12 months at this rate.

That a Big Call. Are you saying then Grundy has no more Improvement in him then?

 

[Apex36]

That a Big Call. Are you saying then Grundy has no more Improvement in him then?

Stop jumping to conclusions. Of course Grundy has improvement in him, and given Cox's penchant for drifting forward and kicking goals I'd say there's a good chance they can co-exist in the same team.

It wouldn't surprise me at all though, if Cox ended up being superior to Grundy as a tap ruckman. That's not a knock on Grundy, it's just a testament to Cox's freakish physical traits and the ease with which he has been able to learn the game in such a short amount of time. In 12 months he's become better at a sport that hundreds of thousands of locals have played all their lives.

 

[ksardog]

IF the talks are Correct that Witts is off to the Dogs. Then Signing Luey might not be the Worse Idea

Great, lets get an injury prone ruckman.

 

[TradeDraft]

Stop jumping to conclusions. Of course Grundy has improvement in him, and given Cox's penchant for drifting forward and kicking goals I'd say there's a good chance they can co-exist in the same team.

It wouldn't surprise me at all though, if Cox ended up being superior to Grundy as a tap ruckman. That's not a knock on Grundy, it's just a testament to Cox's freakish physical traits and the ease with which he has been able to learn the game in such a short amount of time. In 12 months he's become better at a sport that hundreds of thousands of locals have played all their lives.

Unlike Witts and Grundy. I can actually see Grundy and Cox playing in the Same Side. Cox on Saturday looks quite Dangourse up Forward on the Lead.

So you can have Cox as 2nd Ruckman/Forward Option. Challenge for White’s Spot

 

[Kappa]

Unlike Witts and Grundy. I can actually see Grundy and Cox playing in the Same Side. Cox on Saturday looks quite Dangourse up Forward on the Lead.

So you can have Cox as 2nd Ruckman/Forward Option. Challenge for White’s Spot

But what if Witts takes Grundy spot?

 

[pugsville]

Cox has a long way to go. Shown great improvement of bits and pieces of doing stuff, rucking or kicking but had very little Idea about reading the play still. Being bloody tall with long arms he's good at getting his hand on the ball in the ruck.

But would give us almost nothing as second ruck forward. And it would hurt his development,

When are you guys going to mark White on a level playing field?

 

[PieBeast]

There's a reason he is can only get in their VFL side, he is a crap player and wouldn't add a thing to our side.

Played a couple of games in VFL while recovering from a calf injury half way through the year and suffered a medial ligament injury.
Will most likely miss the rest of the season. Highly regarded at Hawthorn and is a rich man's Levi Greenwood. Came fourth and was considered stiff not to finish higher in Norm Smith voting last year.
Do some research prior to spouting absolute tripe.

 

[Soaring Magpie]

Agree Pie Beast , but I'm sure in a 3 way trade we are entitled to trade MS for Motlop and then Cats on trade MS as long as he agrees.

I wouldn't want the club to do that deal even if possible, we are the worst off out of the three clubs. Long term I think Matt scharenberg is worth more than motlop