Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[reload141]

Clubs are willing to pay Jake 700-750,000. You are all trying to offer a second round pick or third or threat of the PSD to get him, yet your club is offering this kind of money.
You then go on to say WADA ban etc, yet YOUR clubs are offering him the money still.
He will not be traded for some 2nd or 3rd round pick, stop being delusional.

 

[Red Bull]

Clubs are willing to pay Jake 700-750,000. You are all trying to offer a second round pick or third or threat of the PSD to get him, yet your club is offering this kind of money.
You then go on to say WADA ban etc, yet YOUR clubs are offering him the money still.
He will not be traded for some 2nd or 3rd round pick, stop being delusional.

efc hold no cards here .
Whoever Carlisle nominates will shaft efc .
Save yourself some heartburn , accept this and move on ...

 

[Thewlis Dish]

In (Carlton supporter's) opinion, he owes the club nothing and Essendon should count themselves lucky if they get anything.

 

[bird_man]

Clubs are willing to pay Jake 700-750,000. You are all trying to offer a second round pick or third or threat of the PSD to get him, yet your club is offering this kind of money.
You then go on to say WADA ban etc, yet YOUR clubs are offering him the money still.
He will not be traded for some 2nd or 3rd round pick, stop being delusional.

He is also not going to be traded for a top 5 pick. I think there needs to be a happy medium. I think if a club in the top 8 gets his signature then a first round pick would do it e.g. Western Bulldogs pick 14.

 

[jimbler]

If he winds up going to the Blues in the PSD, I'm flying down to watch their first meeting.

 

[Seagrave_Holmes]

ITT: trying to get something for nothing.

 

[Wiz83]

I gotta say, it's a bit disturbing to see Essendon fans talking about Jakes character and their desire to get fair Value etc. Whatever the WADA outcome, we know for a fact that the club subjected him to a concerning injection regime, dragged him into a doping controversy and still can't tell him what substances he's had and what the side effects may be.

In my opinion, Jake (and every other player there) owes the club exactly zero. If the Bombers get ANYTHING for him, they should be thankful frankly...this is not the time For the club to be crying poor.

It is wrong how EFC fans have turned on Carlisle so quickly. I'm gutted that he's chosen to leave but after what he's been put through these past few years I can't blame him for or any other player that chooses to leave for that matter.
Also opposition fans that are writing EFC will get nothing for him or he's not worth anything is also wrong. 1 Jake told the club he wants out but he will ensure the club gets something decent for him & 2 He is a young talented tall that can play back & forward. He's worth it. Not top 5 first round draft pick but 8-10 is fair.

Smug Carlton fans that are writing they'll grab Carlisle in the PSD & give EFC nothing might be in for a shock if or when he doesn't even nominate your club as his preferred destination. Which I'd be more shocked if he does considering other teams interested in him. I'd personally go St Kilda before Carlton. They have a much brighter future & much sooner.

 

[ronnysnodgrass]

So in summary so far:

Essendon deserve nothing because *feels*
Essendon deserve lots because *feels*
He'll chose [insert club] because *feels*
Other clubs have no chance because *feels*

 

[reload141]

Carlisle not worth it? Do you people seem to forget GWS offered pick 4 for Ryder at the last hour last year?
Please give it a rest. And why would he nominate Carlton anyway? They are the juice at the bottom of a public bin.
He will get a first round pick, book it.

 

[captain cotch 9]

I gotta say, it's a bit disturbing to see Essendon fans talking about Jakes character and their desire to get fair Value etc. Whatever the WADA outcome, we know for a fact that the club subjected him to a concerning injection regime, dragged him into a doping controversy and still can't tell him what substances he's had and what the side effects may be.

In my opinion, Jake (and every other player there) owes the club exactly zero. If the Bombers get ANYTHING for him, they should be thankful frankly...this is not the time For the club to be crying poor.

YES!!

 

[BRWB]

Carlisle not worth it? Do you people seem to forget GWS offered pick 4 for Ryder at the last hour last year?
Please give it a rest. And why would he nominate Carlton anyway? They are the juice at the bottom of a public bin.
He will get a first round pick, book it.

Already bookmarked for the lol's

 

[The Farmer]

It is wrong how EFC fans have turned on Carlisle so quickly. I'm gutted that he's chosen to leave but after what he's been put through these past few years I can't blame him for or any other player that chooses to leave for that matter.
Also opposition fans that are writing EFC will get nothing for him or he's not worth anything is also wrong. 1 Jake told the club he wants out but he will ensure the club gets something decent for him & 2 He is a young talented tall that can play back & forward. He's worth it. Not top 5 first round draft pick but 8-10 is fair.

Smug Carlton fans that are writing they'll grab Carlisle in the PSD & give EFC nothing might be in for a shock if or when he doesn't even nominate your club as his preferred destination. Which I'd be more shocked if he does considering other teams interested in him. I'd personally go St Kilda before Carlton. They have a much brighter future & much sooner.

We won't care, he is going to be sitting out for the next 2 years anyway not worth giving up more then a side of chips for him and anyone that is dumb enough to offer more can have their sidelined player.

 

[iGNITER]

Think he will end up at the Saints or Dogs.

 

[boncer34]

We won't care, he is going to be sitting out for the next 2 years anyway not worth giving up more then a side of chips for him and anyone that is dumb enough to offer more can have their sidelined player.

It's why your club is offering 750k.

Coz they don't care.

 

[cdcanman]

Carlisle not worth it? Do you people seem to forget GWS offered pick 4 for Ryder at the last hour last year?
Please give it a rest. And why would he nominate Carlton anyway? They are the juice at the bottom of a public bin.
He will get a first round pick, book it.

He is likely worth a pick in the latter half of the first round, I don't dispute that. Borderline All-Australian when played in defence. But that doesn't mean EFC will get that return via trade. Unfortunately for you guys, you have little leverage. Best case scenario for you, Carlisle nominates several clubs that he would be willing to play for and you can at least accept the best offer. A 1st rd pick is not impossible, but don't go holding your breath. It could be considerable less than that depending how this plays out.

 

[cdcanman]

Think he will end up at the Saints or Dogs.

Would look great at the dogs. The way their defenders are playing this year, he would fit in and play really well there.

 

[Unknown Identity]

North bound last time i heard, about 3 weeks ago.

Will see if i can squeeze some info out of my source but North have finals to worry about and don't want to push my luck.

 

[iGNITER]

Would look great at the dogs. The way their defenders are playing this year, he would fit in and play really well there.

Yep would slot in nicely.
Dogs are very good already this year - throw in Carlisle and a fit un-injured Liberatore and they will be close to top 4.

 

[Yoda_]

Question to Carlton supporters

What do you value Henderson, Yarran, Tom Bell?

 

[Red Bull]

Question to Carlton supporters

What do you value Henderson, Yarran, Tom Bell?

Whatever we get for them ...

 

[The Farmer]

It's why your club is offering 750k.

Coz they don't care.

Have you seen our list? We need to get to 95% somehow (Kruezer 500k, Henderson 500k, Judd 500k, Carrots 250k, Menzel 200k, Yarran 300k) 2.25mil to spend to get near the cap again, 750k is a splash in the ocean buddy.

That doesn't mean trading away your future to achieve it

 

[The Farmer]

Question to Carlton supporters

What do you value Henderson, Yarran, Tom Bell?

Late first, Late first if we throw in a pick upgrade (14 for yarran + 30 ish), late 2nd/3rd rounder

 

[Roughies Boys]

Surely he'll be a Saint.

 

[The full package]

Late first, Late first if we throw in a pick upgrade (14 for yarran + 30 ish), late 2nd/3rd rounder

Problem is after 2015 season, Yarran is only suited to 4 or 5 clubs at best. He has done himself or Carlton no favors this season playing such inconstant football. His currency went right down.

 

[Oraaaaazio]

Unlikely North and Tigers will match $750k/5yr deal.

STOP MAKING SHIT UP. I can 100% guarantee as of yesterday, Jake had not been offered ANY contract by Carlton. Just an expression of interest. I don't know about other clubs.