Traded Chris Yarran [to Richmond for Pick 19]

[HBF]

Sam Docherty left Brisbane for the same reason everyone else left Brisbane, ...it's Brisbane.

I'd consider Lennon + 2nd rounder for Yarran + 3rd rounder, but Lennon and our first rounder is effectively 2 first rounders, and since Bolton said Yarran on his 'best day' (which isn't often) is worth a first rounder, you'd be batshit crazy to suggest TWO first rounders. Lennon's going to be a very good player, maybe even a star.

Docherty had a number of clubs chasing him and he chose Carlton, and part of this reason was because he barracked for them as a kid and always dreamed of running out in the Navy Blue.

I'd be happy just to swap Lennon for Yarran. Both first round picks, Yarran has more runs on the board but also has issues that need to be sorted out.

 

[HBF]

Lennon on his own is worth more than Yarran. He's just as talented and doesn't have the baggage.

That's complete BS.
If Lennon was as talented as Yarran he wouldn't have bee dropped for the elimination final.

 

[dlanod]

Sam Docherty came to Carlton for that exact reason after spending 2 years at Brisbane.

To think all the Carlton supporters were telling us to suck up the crappy trade at the time because he had a sick father...

 

[Cevap_Roll]

That's complete BS.
If Lennon was as talented as Yarran he wouldn't have bee dropped for the elimination final.

He was dropped because Dimma wanted to play 3 talls in the forward line and it back fired.
Also with Newman retiring he is now a lock in our best 22.
Everyone knows if Newman wasn't playing his last season Lennon is picked every day of the week ahead of Newman.

 

[blaisee]

If the Blues want lennon they need to give us cripps.

They can then keep Yarran and pay him 450k a year to play in the reserves.

If they want Lennon we want Cripps, plain and simple

 

[Cevap_Roll]

Also Lennon is worth more than Yarran because you will get more years out of him.
Yarran has 5-7 years left of good service while Lennon has 12-15 years left of good service.

 

[HBF]

If the Blues want lennon they need to give us cripps.

They can then keep Yarran and pay him 450k a year to play in the reserves.

If they want Lennon we want Cripps, plain and simple

OMG are you bloody serious.
Cripps will be our next captain, he's not going anywhere.

All you Richmond supporters are the bloody same.

 

[HBF]

To think all the Carlton supporters were telling us to suck up the crappy trade at the time because he had a sick father...

He did want to come back to Melbourne because of his dad, but he still chose Carlton nonetheless.

 

[blaisee]

OMG are you bloody serious.
Cripps will be our next captain, he's not going anywhere.

All you Richmond supporters are the bloody same.

its just as ridiculous as us giving Lennon for Yarran.

It is not going to happen

 

[Cevap_Roll]

OMG are you bloody serious.
Cripps will be our next captain, he's not going anywhere.

All you Richmond supporters are the bloody same.

Going by simple Carlton logic Lennon is worth more than Cripps because Lennon is a higher draft pick.

Carlton will need to throw something else in that deal.

 

[HBF]

its just as ridiculous as us giving Lennon for Yarran.

It is not going to happen

Fine, then we'll look elsewhere.
Pretty sure Sydney would be keen on Yarran with Shaw retiring and Jetta looking to go back to WA.

 

[Bostonian]

If the Blues want lennon they need to give us cripps.

You need to stop doing the football.

 

[Cevap_Roll]

Fine, then we'll look elsewhere.
Pretty sure Sydney would be keen on Yarran with Shaw retiring and Jetta looking to go back to WA.

Our 2nd rounder is higher than Sydney's 2nd rounder.

Edit: Its also higher than both WA clubs 2nd rounders

 

[HBF]

Going by simple Carlton logic Lennon is worth more than Cripps because Lennon is a higher draft pick.

Carlton will need to throw something else in that deal.

I think you're making stuff up and stating it as fact. Not the first time a Richmond supporter has done this.

 

[HBF]

Our 2nd rounder is higher than Sydney's 2nd rounder.

Who says we can't get their first rounder out of them.

 

[Cevap_Roll]

Who says we can't get their first rounder out of them.

Me.

Sydney won't give up their 1st or their 2nd to be honest they need it for their academy kids.
Freo will need their 1st for McArthy
Eagles will need their 1st for Redden

 

[TIGER FOREVER]

There are people wanting a second round pick and lennon, which is ridiculous and wont happen, you Carlton fans are just as bad expecting overs for yarran

Carlton are dreaming Richmond will only give second round pick otherwise he will be playing out his contract period. Its in Carlton hands if they want to have disgrunted player playing his season out or move him on . Richmond has other players to chase Yarran has been told its in Carlton hands.

 

[HBF]

Me.

Sydney won't give up their 1st or their 2nd to be honest they need it for their academy kids.
Freo will need their 1st for McArthy
Eagles will need their 1st for Redden

Yep fair call about Sydney. Forgot about their academy kids.

 

[Bostonian]

Richmond has other players to chase Yarran has been told its in Carlton hands.

Who?

Seems the only player linked to Richmond that seems to actually have an interest in joining you is Yarran.

 

[cdcanman]

I think you're making stuff up and stating it as fact. Not the first time a Richmond supporter has done this.

Fine, then we'll look elsewhere.
Pretty sure Sydney would be keen on Yarran with Shaw retiring and Jetta looking to go back to WA.

 

[HBF]

I've heard a whisper from someone who claims to have a source at the club that Sydney have made enquiries about Yarran. And Yarran hasn't ruled out the possibility of moving to Sydney.

 

[Nostradumbass]

I think you're making stuff up and stating it as fact. Not the first time a Richmond supporter has done this.

Give the Richmond supporters this Richmond supporters that crap a rest.

 

[Nostradumbass]

I've heard a whisper from someone who claims to have a source at the club that Sydney have made enquiries about Yarran. And Yarran hasn't ruled out the possibility of moving to Sydney.

If they're willing to give up a first round pick for him good luck to them.

 

[HBF]

Give the Richmond supporters this Richmond supporters that crap a rest.

Truth hurts huh...

 

[Taylor]

Every club sees the value of a fast, agile, kicking line breaker off half back.