Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[Milanista28]

People are so stupid.

Bloody Essendon lol.

 

[TerryWallet]

We wanted more. Didn't get it in the end and gave away Crameri for unders. The nerve. Bloody Essendon giving away players for under their worth.

So difficult to deal with.

The thing that Dodoro will NEVER get and understand, is that:

It is not what they are worth, it is what you can get for them.

 

[Roughies Boys]

Were we difficult to trade with when we helped you land Shaun Burgoyne?

No because we did up the trade (after Burgoyne nominated us over you guys) you guys just had to evaluate & accept.

 

[Milanista28]

Saints seem pretty bloody keen to land him, Billings keen I reckon.

 

[BRWB]

We wanted more. Didn't get it in the end and gave away Crameri for unders. The nerve. Bloody Essendon giving away players for under their worth.

So difficult to deal with.

And there it is - the constant over valuing of players by Dodoro and Ess fans leading to unrealistic offers and time wasting. You don't see it because you can't see it.

The Crameri deal was fair value for an uncontracted player in most people's eyes. (Dodoro and a few fans such as you excepted.)

 

[DapperDon]

The thing that Dodoro will NEVER get and understand, is that:

It is not what they are worth, it is what you can get for them.

Yes and he tries to get maximum.

Bloody Dodoro doing his job. The nerve, the outrage THE HORROR

 

[Red Bull]

The thing that Dodoro will NEVER get and understand, is that:

It is not what they are worth, it is what you can get for them.

And should Carlisle nominate Carlton , let's hope Dodo's don't change thier spots ...

 

[TerryWallet]

Yes and he tries to get maximum.

Bloody Dodoro doing his job. The nerve, the outrage THE HORROR

Bloody Dodoro, trying to squeeze every ounce of blood out of every bloody stone, every bloody year.....has got Dodoro and EFC the reputation of being trade week dicks and something to avoid.

Oh the outrage, OH THE HORROR.

 

[BRWB]

Just out of interest and comparing looking how JC and Danger have conducted themselves this year. Does anyone else think JC's petulance and questionable maturity and attitude decreases his value??

 

[DapperDon]

And there it is - the constant over valuing of players by Dodoro and Ess fans leading to unrealistic offers and time wasting. You don't see it because you can't see it.

The Crameri deal was fair value for an uncontracted player in most people's eyes. (Dodoro and a few fans such as you excepted.)

Why does a players worth diminish if he's uncontracted? Does it make him a lessor player?

Dodoro was trying to work a 3 way deal. Didn't come off. You got Crameri with a mid 20's pick. Still you sit here and complain how hard done by you were. We never asked for outrageous deals like your 1st. Jusr tried to work something better.

There are no rules that say trafes must be done on day 1 so people on big footy don't get all teary.

 

[DapperDon]

Bloody Dodoro, trying to squeeze every ounce of blood out of every bloody stone, every bloody year.....has got Dodoro and EFC the reputation of being trade week dicks and something to avoid.

Oh the outrage, OH THE HORROR.

I look forward to Carlton and Yarran asking price.

 

[DapperDon]

Bloody Dodoro, trying to squeeze every ounce of blood out of every bloody stone, every bloody year.....has got Dodoro and EFC the reputation of being trade week dicks and something to avoid.

Oh the outrage, OH THE HORROR.

We offered our 1st and Hooker for Caddy.

So hard to deal with. Always asking too much.

 

[TerryWallet]

I look forward to Carlton and Yarran asking price.

That's just it. You haven't heard much at all.

If Yarran was an EFC player, Dodoro would have already splashed over the media that he wants Dustin Martin or Alex Rance or Trent Cotchin.....ah hang on...scratch Trent.....has anyone found Trent yet?

 

[TerryWallet]

We offered our 1st and Hooker for Caddy.

So hard to deal with. Always asking too much.

At the time, Hooker was a shit truck.

 

[DapperDon]

That's just it. You haven't heard much at all.

If Yarran was an EFC player, Dodoro would have already splashed over the media that he wants Dustin Martin or Alex Rance or Trent Cotchin.....ah hang on...scratch Trent.....has anyone found Trent yet?

Yep. He sure would. So difficult to deal with.

Gave a better player in Monfries to Port for a 3rd rounder.

Much difficult So Dodoro

 

[DapperDon]

At the time, Hooker was a shit truck.

Except for the fact he wasn't.

 

[BRWB]

Why does a players worth diminish if he's uncontracted? Does it make him a lessor player?

Dodoro was trying to work a 3 way deal. Didn't come off. You got Crameri with a mid 20's pick. Still you sit here and complain how hard done by you were. We never asked for outrageous deals like your 1st. Jusr tried to work something better.

There are no rules that say trafes must be done on day 1 so people on big footy don't get all teary.

Mate you can't and don't want to acknowledge some basics. Being uncontracted doesn't make someone a lesser player. But it can and often does reduce the losing club's negotiating leverage and as a consequence reduces that players value.

And the view on Dodoro wasting time is just about universal in club land it ain't a BF thing.

And by the way, continuing to throw up Ryder as an example of Ess' willingness to trade reasonably is total BS. Ryder's manager publicly threatened to sue Ess for breach of contract in not providing a safe workplace in order to make Ryder a DFA. Another court threat which included the possibility of losing Ryder for nix plus AFL pressure was the only reason Dodoro traded Ryder. And even then he typically and petulantly dragged it out.

 

[Bunk Moreland]

No, you wanted more than that.

"ESSENDON wants any of Hamish Hartlett, Ollie Wines or Chad Wingard as a “fair-trade” return from Port Adelaide for ruckman-forward Paddy Ryder.
The Bombers’ first preference is midfielder Hartlett who, as a contracted player, can block any trade.

The Bombers delivered this super list to the Power at the opening of AFL trade talks at Etihad Stadium with Essendon list manager Adrian Dodoro telling The Advertiser: “Paddy finished seventh in our best-and-fairest count. So we will take Port Adelaide’s seventh, eighth or ninth best ... we’ll take Hamish Hartlett."

Now come on boncer, if you're going to argue points about what your club supposedly never did, you should at least have some fact to base it on.

Lawl

Look up ambit claim

All those blokes were contracted, do you think we actually asked for any of them?

The density is staggering in these parts.

 

[DapperDon]

Mate you can't and don't want to acknowledge some basics. Being uncontracted doesn't make someone a lesser player. But it can and often does reduce the losing club's negotiating leverage and as a consequence reduces that players value.

And the view on Dodoro wasting time is just about universal in club land it ain't a BF thing.

And by the way, continuing to throw up Ryder as an example of Ess' willingness to trade reasonably is total BS. Ryder's manager publicly threatened to sue Ess for breach of contract in not providing a safe workplace in order to make Ryder a DFA. Another court threat which included the possibility of losing Ryder for nix plus AFL pressure was the only reason Dodoro traded Ryder. And even then he typically and petulantly dragged it out.

Yes. A threat that had zero grounds much to people's dismay.

Oogga Booga!!

 

[TerryWallet]

Mate you can't and don't want to acknowledge some basics. Being uncontracted doesn't make someone a lesser player. But it can and often does reduce the losing club's negotiating leverage and as a consequence reduces that players value.

And the view on Dodoro wasting time is just about universal in club land it ain't a BF thing.

And by the way, continuing to throw up Ryder as an example of Ess' willingness to trade reasonably is total BS. Ryder's manager publicly threatened to sue Ess for breach of contract in not providing a safe workplace in order to make Ryder a DFA. Another court threat which included the possibility of losing Ryder for nix plus AFL pressure was the only reason Dodoro traded Ryder. And even then he typically and petulantly dragged it out.

They. will. not. listen. to. you.

They have perfected the art of selective, wilful deafness.

 

[aussierulesrules]

Saints seem pretty bloody keen to land him, Billings keen I reckon.

Perhaps reckoning isn't your strong suit then?

 

[Steven Tyler]

Why hasn't Carlisle nominated his preferred club?


Oh yeah, Hawks are still playing!

Actually, has Bennell and Aish nominated a club yet?

 

[Red Bull]

I look forward to Carlton and Yarran asking price.

Yarran is contracted .
Carlisle is not .
Carlton have first pick in the PSD .
If Carlisle nominates Carlton , best Dodoro accepts the offer or he will be unbuckling his belt and efc will be hurt badly ...

 

[BRWB]

Yes. A threat that had zero grounds much to people's dismay.

Oogga Booga!!

Oogga Booga???

Ok you win...

 

[coryne]

Lawl

Look up ambit claim

All those blokes were contracted, do you think we actually asked for any of them?

The density is staggering in these parts.

Of cause not. Dodoro wouldn't know what Essendon was asking for Ryder right ...............