List Mgmt. 2015 LIST Discussion - trades, free agency etc

[Michaels]

Sorry for the intrusion.

This post may not reveal anything but I just left icon park and was sitting 3m away from SOS, Adrian Dodoro and another essendon official having trade discussions.

Unfortunately I didn't hear the players names as I was in a meeting of my own but the end result was a "no deal" from Dodoro.

 

[footyfan098]

Not bad................but only on the strength of the 2015 Yarran.

We'd have to take it but may watch Yarran's quality elsewhere......or maybe not.

yeah I don't love it, was hoping for a bit higher for both...

yarran value =15 to 20, so can live with 17. Even before 2015, i reckon his value is there. Jeez on 2015 alone his value would be 25+. so Id be happy with 17.

Bell however, i reckon his value is 25-32ish... i would have preferred slightly more for him, especially in this draft. although if we can trade 31 and 20 for the GWS boys no complaint.

 

[KnaveyBlue]

this was getting mooted on the radio before:

Carlton: 17 (bris) 31 (rich)
Bris: Astbury Tom Bell
Richmond: Yarran

17 and 31 is a poor return for Yaz and Bell, but it's not as putrid as other deals I've seen suggested.

 

[footyfan098]

12 for Yarran or bugger off

Honestly, how is Yarran worth 12 in a straight swap??

even before this year when he got dropped.

 

[AB_Blue]

If we did it if pass 17 and 31 to GWS for Tomlinson Plowman and lamb

 

[Dramoth]

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...pre-season-draft/story-fni5f9jc-1227567903518

I wouldnt be too unhappy with that option

 

[footyfan098]

If we did it if pass 17 and 31 to GWS for Tomlinson Plowman and lamb

Exactly:

essentially yarran and bell for tomlinson, plowman, lamb, phillips and sumner... Not bad

 

[Malifice]

Exactly:

essentially yarran and bell for tomlinson, plowman, lamb, phillips and sumner... Not bad

I'd take it.

Pray to god the Cats stink it up next year, and we get a PP (likely end of 1st round) and trade Gibbs to Adelaide or Port for a low 1st rounder.

Hit next years draft with 1, 10, 12, 19, 20 or thereabouts.

 

[1981]

Not concerned at all about Rice, means we can use the pick we had earmarked for him on someone as good if not better, and someone who fits a need as opposed to another HBF.

 

[Dramoth]

Computer says NO!

The computer actually started smoking a bit and then blew up leaving the word NO burnt into the walls.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Sorry for the intrusion.

This post may not reveal anything but I just left icon park and was sitting 3m away from SOS, Adrian Dodoro and another essendon official having trade discussions.

Unfortunately I didn't hear the players names as I was in a meeting of my own but the end result was a "no deal" from Dodoro.

It's a "No deal" from him everytime. Thanks for the update dude!

 

[footyfan098]

I'd take it.

Pray to god the Cats stink it up next year, and we get a PP (likely end of 1st round) and trade Gibbs to Adelaide or Port for a low 1st rounder.

Hit next years draft with 1, 10, 12, 19, 20 or thereabouts.

If we trade Gibbs next year for a late first,

we might as well trade him and 20 to adelaide for 9 and 13

 

[Matty411]

Can we please stop the Gibbs trade hypotheticals. I think the club's made it pretty clear he won't be traded.

 

[Malifice]

If we trade Gibbs next year for a late first,

we might as well trade him and 20 to adelaide for 9 and 13

Id probably do it.

 

[DollarsandSense]

Sorry for the intrusion.

This post may not reveal anything but I just left icon park and was sitting 3m away from SOS, Adrian Dodoro and another essendon official having trade discussions.

Unfortunately I didn't hear the players names as I was in a meeting of my own but the end result was a "no deal" from Dodoro.

SOS was just asking DDoo if they'd take Warnock for #4.....

 

[Michaels]

It's a "No deal" from him everytime. Thanks for the update dude!

No worries. SOS was in gym gear so I doubt he was at etihad at all today. To avoid media maybe ?

The only other bit of info is as Dodoro and the other official were leaving , Neil craig rocked up.

I'm not sure who yelled it out but someone said "give us carlisle " in a jovial manner.

 

[P_Crippy]

Sorry for the intrusion.

This post may not reveal anything but I just left icon park and was sitting 3m away from SOS, Adrian Dodoro and another essendon official having trade discussions.

Unfortunately I didn't hear the players names as I was in a meeting of my own but the end result was a "no deal" from Dodoro.

Dodoro just reading from his template.

 

[HARKER]

So what happened to Walker & Geelong's 2nd for Henderson?

Never mind..............best forgotten.

 

[dumb]

Trading future picks reminds me of first home buyer loans - the $7000 or so just getting added to the cost. It's raising the ceiling of what clubs can realistically ask for talent (see mooted treloar trade), now that every club has more currency in their pocket. How long until a club asks for 3 first rounders for a player?

 

[1981]

So what happened to Walker & Geelong's 2nd for Henderson?

Never mind..............best forgotten.

Apparently that changed once other parties showed interest in Walker.
The good thing is our deal was done quick today. Have to hand it to Cats, they don't muck around like some other clubs.

 

[GordonBlue]

Apparently that changed once other parties showed interest in Walker.
The good thing is our deal was done quick today. Have to hand it to Cats, they don't muck around like some other clubs.

I very much doubt that Carlton preferred 2nd rounder and Walker over next year's first rounder.

 

[Carl Tone]

Not concerned at all about Rice, means we can use the pick we had earmarked for him on someone as good if not better, and someone who fits a need as opposed to another HBF.

This HBF ?

 

[ferrisb]

This HBF ?

Yep, one is more than enough

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Why are we parting with pick 19 for Walker? Crazy!

 

[Keyza]

this was getting mooted on the radio before:

Carlton: 17 (bris) 31 (rich)
Bris: Astbury Tom Bell
Richmond: Yarran

So 17 for Yarran and 31 for Bell?
No thanks.