List Mgmt. 2015 LIST Discussion - trades, free agency etc

[Michael Jezz]

No thanks terrible deal we get some reserves players and a guy who can't break into the Crows line up and they get Menzel? Are we stupid? Or are we taking drugs like the last few years?

That deal is a disaster. Think about it. We trade menzel and picks 19 20 21 for reserves players and then are willing to taken19 for yarran who had a bad 12 games and we are willing to accept late 20s picks in a draft that drops off badly.
Sos dont do the gws deal. Keep the picks. KEEP MENZEL and build a list
Tell Richmond we want pick 12. Let Yarran play reserves.

 

[Aphrodite]

Carlton have apparently already turned down pick 19 from Bitchmond.

So says Emma Quayle!

 

[viking12]

if blues are offloading menzel, why not do a separate trade with crows for him? cant understand why he would be involved in any trade with kerridge

 

[Ti22]

We have already knocked back pick 19 from bitchmond that's good to see we have balls.

 

[ImBlue]

Reputable GWS Supporter RL Griffin on Twitter mooting deal including Menz and GWS that would see us trade:

Menzel, 20, 21 and 59 for
Kerridge, Plowman, Lamb, Phillips, Sumner, PLUS picks 26, 27 & 28

Deal including Pies (Treloar) and Crows, too.

Too much going on - giving me a headache.

Getting sick of these picks in the twenties. Show us some creamier picks, especially for Menzel at least, gees!

 

[Ti22]

That deal is a disaster. Think about it. We trade menzel and picks 19 20 21 for reserves players and then are willing to taken19 for yarran who had a bad 12 games and we are willing to accept late 20s picks in a draft that drops off badly.
Sos dont do the gws deal. Keep the picks. KEEP MENZEL and build a list
Tell Richmond we want pick 12. Let Yarran play reserves.

It's a joke if we do that deal it's a disaster.

 

[BluesRule]

I can't understand how Lamb, Phillips and Sumner is worth anything more than a fourth or fifth round pick.

Should be able to pick all 3 up as delisted free agents soon enough. Zero trade value and GWS need to clear list space/salary cap.
We can use them for depth and have list space, but they are not improving the quality of our list (unless they improve & stay uninjured).

 

[Stiffler's Dad]

That is one hell of a great deal for GC. Well done. What did we get for Hendo? Can anyone refresh my memory?

To quote a once famous man......peanuts, peanuts...get yer peanuts!

 

[ImBlue]

We have already knocked back pick 19 from bitchmond that's good to see we have balls.

Good! If they want Yarran, first pick thank you kindly.

 

[AB_Blue]

Geez Louise what's going on. TRADING MENZ. WTF??

 

[Paulski19]

Geez Louise what's going on. TRADING MENZ. WTF??

They're saying pick 28 will be enough to get all those 4 from GWS

 

[ImBlue]

Geez Louise what's going on. TRADING MENZ. WTF??

Just speculation, but yeah your right, crazy sh*t

 

[TheCoach16]

Reputable GWS Supporter RL Griffin on Twitter mooting deal including Menz and GWS that would see us trade:

Menzel, 20, 21 and 59 for
Kerridge, Plowman, Lamb, Phillips, Sumner, PLUS picks 26, 27 & 28

Deal including Pies (Treloar) and Crows, too.

Too much going on - giving me a headache.

WITH Tomlinson, amazing result.
WITHOUT Tomlinson, this deal does nothing for me...

 

[Paulski19]

Would we offer 20, 21 and 28 to GWS for the 4 players and pick 8?

 

[bluebunz]

Pick 12 or GTFO.

Next year 2nd-round FA compensation better than this year's pick 19.

 

[I AM CARLTON]

We have already knocked back pick 19 from bitchmond that's good to see we have balls.

Awesome

 

[I AM CARLTON]

Would we offer 20, 21 and 28 to GWS for the 4 players and pick 8?

Pick 8 would be so so tasty

 

[2ndeffort]

Somebody call Lachy Henderson's Mum, there are some nervous nellies on here that need a back rub and a warm Bovril!! Calm down and let SOS do his work, I'm wagering he has a better eye for players than most of us!

 

[JohnnyFontane90]

We have already knocked back pick 19 from bitchmond that's good to see we have balls.

trade menzel for kerridge. this is what happens when you have balls but no brains

 

[bluebunz]

Pick 8 would be nice as long as we don't have any grand plans for the other picks.

And SOS's definition of grand plans.

Hope he's reading BF.

 

[JohnnyFontane90]

Somebody call Lachy Henderson's Mum, there are some nervous nellies on here that need a back rub and a warm Bovril!! Calm down and let SOS do his work, I'm wagering he has a better eye for players than most of us!

we said similar 'i'm sure he knows better than us' stuff with malthouse as well.

 

[TheCoach16]

Pick 8 would be so so tasty

Tastier than Tomlinson or not? What I'm asking is would prefer the 4 GWS kids and pick 8, OR 5 GWS kids, one of which is Tomlinson?

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

Sounds like Yarran is gonna stay at this rate. No way Richmond will give up pick 12 and we won't accept pick 19, Unless Yarran changes his mind and says he likes the Hawks.

 

[rampar]

Menz must have some recent skeletons in the closet if the trade goes through

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

Should be able to pick all 3 up as delisted free agents soon enough. Zero trade value and GWS need to clear list space/salary cap.
We can use them for depth and have list space, but they are not improving the quality of our list (unless they improve & stay uninjured).

Can only imagine it is because we are taking on their salaries that we would be getting Plowman on the cheap there's not really any other explanation.