Gillo's Phantom Update

[joop]

Parish looks very light frame

And your point being?

 

[gillo94]

And your point being?

Think Saints would prefer a competative beast, so would Demons and Bombers
You have to agree with me

 

[joop]

Think Saints would prefer a competative beast, so would Demons and Bombers
You have to agree with me

No I don't have to agree with you. Saints need outside polish with skills and people in the know say saints really want Parish. They won't pass on him.
Have no idea how you have Mills lasting to pick 14 either, there's 0 chance that happens.

 

[gillo94]

No I don't have to agree with you. Saints need outside polish with skills and people in the know say saints really want Parish. They won't pass on him.
Have no idea how you have Mills lasting to pick 14 either, there's 0 chance that happens.

Did it by academy selections

 

[joop]

Did it by academy selections

You don't know how they work so you?

 

[gillo94]

Gillo, you are the only person that I've seen have Ah Chee this high in the draft order. This includes rankings and mock drafts on bigfooty and from those draft watchers in the media. Either you are having a wild guess or trolling St Kilda posters. Seeing as you comment on anything St Kilda related on bigfooty, I suspect it's the latter.

Just for shites and giggles, I'll humour you for a second.

St Kilda require quality tall defenders and quality midfielders. Weitering is the only quality defender rated top 10 however he'll be gone before our pick so we can rule out a quality defender with our first pick. In regards to quality midfielders, Ah Chee is not rated top 6, therefore you can rule him out. There are also question marks on his ability to become a full time mid, there's another reason to rule him out.

Here's some higher rated midfielders for you to consider for St Kilda's pick: Parish, Mathieson's, Balic and Dunkley. That should start you off.

This is to the Saints supporters that thought I was trying to troll them

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2015-09-02/your-clubs-draft-needs

Even Cal Twomey believes Ah Chee is good fit for Saints

 

[gillo94]

1 Blues ' Weitering
2 Lions ' Schache
3 Swans ' Mills
4 MFC ' Weideman
5 GWS ' Hopper
6 Essendon ' Francis
7 Essendon ' Curnow
8 GWS ' Kennedy
9 Gold Coast ' Balic
10 MFC ' Parish
11 Blues ' Mathieson
12 Crows ' Milera
13 Lions ' Hipwood
14 Blues ' Oliver
15 Lions ' Keayes
16 Tigers ' Burton
17 Crows ' Ah Chee
18 StK ' Collins
19 Hawks ' McKay
20 Gold Coast '
21 NMFC ' Greaham
22 Hawks ' Hibberd

23 Blues ' Tucker

24 Dogs ' Bonner
25 Dogs ' Partington

 

[Banee]

1 Blues ' Weitering
2 Lions ' Schache
3 Swans ' Mills
4 MFC ' Weideman
5 GWS ' Hopper
6 Essendon ' Francis
7 Essendon ' Curnow
8 GWS ' Kennedy
9 Gold Coast ' Balic
10 MFC ' Parish
11 Blues ' Mathieson
12 Crows ' Milera
13 Lions ' Hipwood
14 Blues ' Oliver
15 Lions ' Keayes
16 Tigers ' Burton
17 Crows ' Ah Chee
18 StK ' Collins
19 Hawks ' McKay
20 Gold Coast '
21 NMFC ' Greaham
22 Hawks ' Hibberd

23 Blues ' Tucker

24 Dogs ' Bonner
25 Dogs ' Partington

If Melbourne don't take Parish with their first pick, then Essendon will definitely take him, so if the Dees want him they are going to need to use their pick 3

 

[dwoody15]

1 Blues ' Weitering
2 Lions ' Schache
3 Swans ' Mills
4 MFC ' Weideman
5 GWS ' Hopper
6 Essendon ' Francis
7 Essendon ' Curnow
8 GWS ' Kennedy
9 Gold Coast ' Balic
10 MFC ' Parish
11 Blues ' Mathieson
12 Crows ' Milera
13 Lions ' Hipwood
14 Blues ' Oliver
15 Lions ' Keayes
16 Tigers ' Burton
17 Crows ' Ah Chee
18 StK ' Collins
19 Hawks ' McKay
20 Gold Coast '
21 NMFC ' Greaham
22 Hawks ' Hibberd

23 Blues ' Tucker

24 Dogs ' Bonner
25 Dogs ' Partington

Crows do not need Milera or Ah Chee. The y need talk forwards and ruckmen such as Burton and McKay

 

[gillo94]

Crows do not need Milera or Ah Chee. The y need talk forwards and ruckmen such as Burton and McKay

Crows will go best available. I'd replace Ah Chee with McKay

 

[gillo94]

If Melbourne don't take Parish with their first pick, then Essendon will definitely take him, so if the Dees want him they are going to need to use their pick 3

Dedoro didn't look excited about Parish in one interview

 

[Balony_pony16]

Dedoro didn't look excited about Parish in one interview

mind games that wont bluff the demons

 

[gillo94]

mind games that wont bluff the demons

They could miss out on Weideman. Essendon or Suns will take him

 

[mattyc75]

Eagles have pick 23 I believe

Sent from my C6903 using Tapatalk

 

[gillo94]

Eagles have pick 23 I believe

Sent from my C6903 using Tapatalk

Academy selections will have teams down the draft order

 

[The Facepainter]

1 Blues ' Weitering
2 Lions ' Schache
3 Swans ' Mills
4 MFC ' Weideman
5 GWS ' Hopper
6 Essendon ' Francis
7 Essendon ' Curnow
8 GWS ' Kennedy
9 Gold Coast ' Balic
10 MFC ' Parish
11 Blues ' Mathieson
12 Crows ' Milera
13 Lions ' Hipwood
14 Blues ' Oliver
15 Lions ' Keayes
16 Tigers ' Burton
17 Crows ' Ah Chee
18 StK ' Collins
19 Hawks ' McKay
20 Gold Coast '
21 NMFC ' Greaham
22 Hawks ' Hibberd

23 Blues ' Tucker

24 Dogs ' Bonner
25 Dogs ' Partington

Hi Gillo,
Like you work buddy but I just can't see the blues leaving McKay at 14.

I think 2 talls and 2 mids is about right and Mathieson is a must.

 

[getgaff]

1 Blues ' Weitering
2 Lions ' Schache
3 Swans ' Mills
4 MFC ' Weideman
5 GWS ' Hopper
6 Essendon ' Francis
7 Essendon ' Curnow
8 GWS ' Kennedy
9 Gold Coast ' Balic
10 MFC ' Parish
11 Blues ' Mathieson
12 Crows ' Milera
13 Lions ' Hipwood
14 Blues ' Oliver
15 Lions ' Keayes
16 Tigers ' Burton
17 Crows ' Ah Chee
18 StK ' Collins
19 Hawks ' McKay
20 Gold Coast '
21 NMFC ' Greaham
22 Hawks ' Hibberd

23 Blues ' Tucker

24 Dogs ' Bonner
25 Dogs ' Partington

Love your work Gil. Couple of points to make 1) Your missing a pick 20 to the Suns, 2) Thoughts on why Tucker has slid?, 3) Also wondering what your thoughts on West Coast's first pick are?

 

[gillo94]

Hi Gillo,
Like you work buddy but I just can't see the blues leaving McKay at 14.

I think 2 talls and 2 mids is about right and Mathieson is a must.

Clayton Oliver has plenty good wraps. Think stands for the minute

 

[gillo94]

Love your work Gil. Couple of points to make 1) Your missing a pick 20 to the Suns, 2) Thoughts on why Tucker has slid?, 3) Also wondering what your thoughts on West Coast's first pick are?

Not sure about Gold Coast. Figure might take a tall. Eagles first pick coin flip between best available and defender. Last year was horror with big talls so might want draft there as failed get one through trade

 

[The Facepainter]

Clayton Oliver has plenty good wraps. Think stands for the minute

No probs, I think we are in for a he'll of a ride over the next 3 years.

 

[dwoody15]

Crows will go best available. I'd replace Ah Chee with McKay

Millera is certainly not best available. In fact I think he is bit overrated.

 

[mrb1]

Millera is certainly not best available. In fact I think he is bit overrated.

Milera is class.

 

[gillo94]

Millera is certainly not best available. In fact I think he is bit overrated.

Milera will be in range of 6-12

 

[dwoody15]

Milera will be in range of 6-12

As long as he isn't selected by Crows, I'll be happy!

 

[gillo94]

Next Update

1 Carlton Weitering

2 Brisbane Schache

3 Sydney Mills

4 Melbourne Parish

5 GWS Hopper

6 Essendon Curnow

7 GWS Kennedy

8 Essendon Oliver

9 Gold Coast Milera

10 Melbourne Weideman

11 Brisbane Hipwood

12 Carlton Mathieson

13 Adelaide Francis

14 Carlton Collins

15 Richmond Bonner

16 Adelaide Burton

17 St Kilda Tucker

18 Gold Coast Harry McKay

19 Kangaroos Gresham

20 Hawthorn Balic

21 Carlton Ryan Clarke

22 Bulldogs Partington

23 Bulldogs Ben McKay

24 St Kilda Rice

25 Essendon Hibberd