Mega Thread 2016 Trade/Free Agency Discussion

[Capitano_Cotch]

Yep , completely changes our dynamic with those 2 in & fit & firing

It's a bit (a lot) of class that we are ultimately currently lacking.
We'd be a much better side with those 2 in plus if we can get Deledio right from the start of the season it would give us a massive boost.
Only concern I have is a partner for Jack in the forward line.
We literally have nothing up top.

 

[wegetpumped]

Add Prestia and a fit Yarran into the mix next season as well as another solid KPD and we may start to look alright again.

Yes and than an injury or two and again we will see our depth in action. We need more then 3 players

 

[French Tiger]

It's a bit (a lot) of class that we are ultimately currently lacking.
We'd be a much better side with those 2 in plus if we can get Deledio right from the start of the season it would give us a massive boost.
Only concern I have is a partner for Jack in the forward line.
We literally have nothing up top.

Not only class but some pace. Yep Jack needs a hand, We need to Griffiths to be more consistent but also a more mobile Gunstan/Darling type as the 3rd tall target would be ideal.

 

[Cevap_Roll]

The question is, how do we land him and potentially prestia? Or can it only be one or the other.

Tom is a free agent?

 

[Mr Magic]

Not only class but some pace. Yep Jack needs a hand, We need to Griffiths to be more consistent but also a more mobile Gunstan/Darling type as the 3rd tall target would be ideal.

Hello, Jack is the third tall!

 

[Mr Magic]

Behind our big 5 of Rance Martin Cotch Jack & Deledio , Presita would be our next most talented & most likely to push ahead of a couple on that list

BS not even close!!

 

[French Tiger]

BS not even close!!

You don't think he would be next after those 5 ? Who would you have in front of him ?

 

[French Tiger]

Hello, Jack is the third tall!

Jack won 2 coleman medals playing full forward. That's where he should still be imo

 

[Mr Magic]

Is Dion Prestia really worth our first draft pick?
I don't think so. Even though we aren't very good at picking up talent from the draft I still think we should keep our first draft pick.

Not even close to worth our first.

GC are laughing. Our trade team if this is the result are working for other clubs and are traitors!!

 

[Mr Magic]

You don't think he would be next after those 5 ? Who would you have in front of him ?

Vlastuin, Grimes, Miles, Grigg to name a few

 

[Mr Magic]

Jack won 2 coleman medals playing full forward. That's where he should still be imo

Look JR are is a great player but he is a third tall or at least 2nd tall. Nothing wrong with being a third tall. Gunston is Hawks third tall and he is arguably their best player!!

 

[French Tiger]

Vlastuin, Grimes, Miles, Grigg to name a few

Hasn't Prestia finished 3rd twice in their B & F behind Ablett & Swallow ?

 

[_DBF_]

Jack Steele, Dion Prestia and a fully recover Chris Yarran... Things are not so bad...

Trade Vickery and Conca for some decent picks and we are top 4 next year..

see. its easy, even i can sort it...

Vlaustin, Rance, Grimes
Yarran, Astbury, Houli
Steele, Martin, B Ellis
Hampson, Cotchin, Prestia
Rioli, Griffith, Delidio
Edwards, Reiwoltd, Llyod

Markov, C Ellis, Lennon, Miles, McIntosh

Pasquali almighty has spoken!!!!! End thread.

 

[wegetpumped]

Vlastuin, Grimes, Miles, Grigg to name a few

I think you came undone mentioning them Magic.

 

[Capitano_Cotch]

Yes and than an injury or two and again we will see our depth in action. We need more then 3 players

Providing Markov, Menadue, Rioli, Short and Castagna continue to improve and develop then I think they can be pretty handy depth.
They've all shown promising signs this year and another pre-season will do them wonders.

 

[wegetpumped]

Pasquali almighty has spoken!!!!! End thread.

I'm glad his spoken as he wont be able to say much. He will be too busy playing for melbourne victory this year .

 

[wegetpumped]

Providing Markov, Menadue, Rioli, Short and Castagna continue to improve and develop then I think they can be pretty handy depth.
They've all shown promising signs this year and another pre-season will do them wonders.

I agree but why did they drop menadue and george for? Surelly the way we are travelling they need to be kept at it along with some others.

 

[Mr Magic]

I think you came undone mentioning them Magic.

I think Prestia is overrated.

If he gets 500K may as well given Treloar 1million.

I seriously rate Treloar twice a Prestia

 

[_DBF_]

I'm glad his spoken as he wont be able to say much. He will be too busy playing for melbourne victory this year .

Is there anything he can't do????

 

[Mr Magic]

Hasn't Prestia finished 3rd twice in their B & F behind Ablett & Swallow ?

Means nothing with all the injuries they have and a lot of their talent was flankers, rucks and KPP's.
Hard for the likes of May to get up there has a KPP like the brownlow

I would rather we picked up Steele than Prestia, at least he is younger and as size!!

The reason we are getting Prestia is obviously because we are reaching and overpaying again from idiots we have running the club!!

 

[poppa pump]

vlas, grimes,grigg, miles,edwards better than prestia, NO ****ING WAY,
GRIMES STATS 11
VLAS 15
MILES 22.5
GRIGG 21

PRESTIA 23.6, AND ALL EARNED HARD AND BRINGS OTHERS INTO A GAME.

 

[Capitano_Cotch]

I agree but why did they drop menadue and george for? Surelly the way we are travelling they need to be kept at it along with some others.

Mate I have no idea.
Menadue should be playing every game.
Keep in mind we still have Mcintosh to come back in to the side, he's another youngster who's shown promise.

 

[tunksy]

Tom is a free agent?

Im not sure if he is. Just thought he was out of contract. If hes a fa awesome

 

[Mr Magic]

vlas, grimes,grigg, miles,edwards better than prestia, NO ******* WAY,
GRIMES STATS 11
VLAS 15
MILES 22.5
GRIGG 21

PRESTIA 23.6, AND ALL EARNED HARD AND BRINGS OTHERS INTO A GAME.

Its not about stats it is about effectiveness on the field. Look at Cyril!!


Our club hides behind stats because they can't win finals!!!


How does Prestia go as a wingman, or backman?

Prestia is older than Treloar too!!

 

[captain cotch 9]

Im not sure if he is. Just thought he was out of contract. If hes a fa awesome

He isnt a FA