List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 part 2 - see Mod Warning p 281

[Seedsfan]

Find it odd how Witts plays against Minson and Campbell and holds his own yet gets bagged out

 

[adammania9]

Oh dear!
Found this in the Hawks trade hypotheticals thread.

Out of interest... What would bruest get us from GWS in a straight swap. Is it deluded to say that it could be a straight swap for Shiels or Lobb or Kelly or Greene if all the players were in agreement?

Why did we give up two firsts for Treloar when we could have just traded Fasolo?

 

[Matt_352]

Can't define someone's trade worth from 1 game. Especially when dominating the comp previous 2 months have elected to ignore certain person on this board who isn't smart enough tp realise that.

 

[TheSierBear]

Can't define someone's trade worth from 1 game. Especially when dominating the comp previous 2 months have elected to ignore certain person on this board who isn't smart enough tp realise that.

Yep agreed and agreed champ. I think Witts played like he didin't want to get hurt for his next contract at his next club. Oxley's trade value might have gone up though, admittedly not by much, hope we can package him and Witts in a 3 way trade with GCS and Omeara...

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Find it odd how Witts plays against Minson and Campbell and holds his own yet gets bagged out

Witts didn't hold his own. He got smashed.

 

[Anzacday]

Having seen Webb & Dale in action today my preference is Webb if it's out of those two for Cloke.

 

[Seedsfan]

Witts didn't hold his own. He got smashed.

Lol, he had 30+ hit outs breaking even with Minson and Campbell and he did it on his own. You can't blame him for the goals kicked by Minson when he was playing forward

 

[Leviathan Pie]

Agree. Letting Hine would be a Massive Mistake.

He is 1 of the best at his job in the AFL

And thats based on what?

 

[Maggie5]

Lol, he had 30+ hit outs breaking even with Minson and Campbell and he did it on his own. You can't blame him for the goals kicked by Minson when he was playing forward

I wonder who will be the whipping boy next year? Maybe according to this board Blair will have it all to himself.
Read somewhere that one player does not make a team.
For mine, poor team effort and surprisingly Williams and Oxley didn't stop trying.

 

[Ducce35]

Lol, he had 30+ hit outs breaking even with Minson and Campbell and he did it on his own. You can't blame him for the goals kicked by Minson when he was playing forward

Did u watch the game???

 

[PicaBoo]

With VFL finals out of the way, when will the delistings be announced?

 

[legendstatus]

Todays pathetic effort today showed exactly why Witts isn't worth anything. Pea hearted spud.

Can you re read this and edit please ?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[JollyBallsUp]

That pretty much ensures he goes to Swans or GC. If you are Bruest you say Swans, plus he is a NSW kid. Makes sense, straight swap Mitchell for Bruest is about right

Mitchell has more market value then Bruest

 

[DinoSoar]

With VFL finals out of the way, when will the delistings be announced?

Early next week most likely to start, Tuesday/Wednesday at a guess.

 

[No SPIN]

I don't think it was ridiculous. It's a different opinion and different perspective, whether you agree with that or not. I don't believe it shows contempt for the club. It's a pretty ordinary claim to level at fellow passionate Pies supporter actually. I wish more posters could show some basic respect for one and other in this thread. It isn't that difficult.

I think if you re-read my comment you will see I called the post ridiculous. There was nothing personal in my comment.
We can disagree on whether the post in question showed contempt for the club.

Why is there a problem with forcefully pointing out a an unfair post with the same vehemence in which it was written?

 

[Stoods]

Can't define someone's trade worth from 1 game. Especially when dominating the comp previous 2 months have elected to ignore certain person on this board who isn't smart enough tp realise that.

This

 

[DaVe86]

Which doggies players caught the eye today from the vfl as steak knives in a deal with cloke?

I was keen to watch hrovat so dissapointed he didnt play. Ive always liked bailey dale, while mitch go honeychurch and webb caught my eye

 

[Go Woods]

Todays pathetic effort today showed exactly why Witts isn't worth anything. Pea hearted spud.

I'd say he had already checked out mentally from the Pies and thinking about next year.

 

[Matt_352]

Which doggies players caught the eye today from the vfl as steak knives in a deal with cloke?

I was keen to watch hrovat so dissapointed he didnt play. Ive always liked bailey dale, while mitch go honeychurch and webb caught my eye

Always been a fan of Honeychurch. All 3 seemed to do reasonable.

 

[MagpieBat]

 

[Matt_352]

Ooooooohh surely he comes to us

 

[Apex36]

Noooooooooooo......

 

[MagpieBat]

Ooooooohh surely he comes to us

Happy to have him aboard if it means the end of Corey Gault...

 

[Matt_352]

Happy to have him aboard if it means the end of Corey Gault...

An inanimate carbon rod would offer more than Gault

 

[Matt_352]

Noooooooooooo......

Cant be any worse than Gault