List Mgmt. 2016 Trade/Free Agency Part 2

[Morro]

From an outsiders perspective what about Prestia and pick 27 for Pick 6. Pick 27 for Lobbe from Port who apparently wants to be traded.

We would probably keep 27

 

[sherrif]

From an outsiders perspective what about Prestia and pick 27 for Pick 6. Pick 27 for Lobbe from Port who apparently wants to be traded.

Same deal (Pick 27) but for Billy Longer from Saints.

 

[CoggaRules]

far out..the Lids thing wont go away...the latest suggests it not actually Lids pushing the envelope..latest is pick 35 and Kersten from the cats

 

[Hank Heavenly]

far out..the Lids thing wont go away...the latest suggests it not actually Lids pushing the envelope..latest is pick 35 and Kersten from the cats

where is the latest coming from

 

[Punt rd end]

Balme......Here's definitive for you, in my opinion they (Jack, Lids, Dusty) will stay starts at 5min mark

 

[docko911]

far out..the Lids thing wont go away...the latest suggests it not actually Lids pushing the envelope..latest is pick 35 and Kersten from the cats

I just vomitted in my mouth and then my vomit vomitted in its mouth

Kersten is a ****ing dud.

How about Conca and pick 40 for Selwood.

 

[CoggaRules]

Balme......Here's definitive for you, in my opinion they (Jack, Lids, Dusty) will stay starts at 5min mark

oh ok...pheeew.

 

[RobsJourney]

As mentioned a few times.A no brainer for me would be:
Lids>>Motlop>>Prestia.

It's a great way to get the trade done, but still not sure I want just Prestia. Geelong getting Lids for Motlop is a steal.
I'd want Geelong's second rounder too.
Prestia and pick 35ish is fair for Lids.

I think GC getting Motlop for Prestia is very fair, both are young, Prestia gets more touches but Motlop kicks more goals and plays more games.

I'd acually want a better 2nd rounder than 35... Maybe the pick Geelong inevitably get for Smedts if they're trading him?

EDIT: Geelong and GC may scoff at this but let's be fair and look at it.

- Prestia wants out and is injury prone. Not a match winner but a very good player.

- Motlop can sometimes be a match winner and is possibly on the way out.

- On the contrary, Lids may (recently ONLY) have had some injury troubles and be a few years older, but we are talking about quality here and not about time left in the game. Quality is what determines worth given he still likely has at least 2 years left, and he is a damaging, elite player.
Opposite to the other two, he is borderline our best/most important player and doesn't even really want to leave.

So yeah, he's worth a pretty penny and Motlop and Prestia aren't in his league by a ways.

 

[Groupie_]

Balme......Here's definitive for you, in my opinion they (Jack, Lids, Dusty) will stay starts at 5min mark

can listen to balmy talk all day just gives em nothing

 

[TheDyerLegacy]

Would love to get Will Hoskin-Elliot.. would mind trading pick 6 to GWS for a couple of their players and a late first rounder in return.. need to capitalise on them having to cut their list back along with cap space

 

[NUFC Tiger]

He's copping an absolute pasting.

Never heard of the bloke until today - checked out his twitter. Laughable.

Thanks for the chuckle mate. Dude is a clown available for children's parties.

 

[Calcium Man]

where is the latest coming from

Considering who posted it I would say the bunny rabbit of the prep kid in Benny Gale' Neighbours kid's class.

 

[docko911]

Would love to get Will Hoskin-Elliot.. would mind trading pick 6 to GWS for a couple of their players and a late first rounder in return.. need to capitalise on them having to cut their list back along with cap space

Hoskin-Elliot, Steele and Stewart + pick 15-18 for pick 6.

Then next years first + Lennon to Sydney for Mitchell + pick 15-18

Pick 15-18 + Pick 15-18 + Vickery for Prestia + Pick 8

Vickery to be on-traded as part of O'Mears to Hawthorn deal.

Conca + our third to WC for their second

Batchelor + our 4th to Brisbane for their 3rd

Pick 8, WC second, Brisbane 3rd

Zac Clarke FA

Upgrade Short

6 recruits
1 upgrade
3 draft picks

Out: Vickery, Lennon, Conca, Batchelor, Maric, Chaplin, McKenzie, McBean, Butler, A.Moore

We win trade period

 

[Groupie_]

Never heard of the bloke until today - checked out his twitter. Laughable.

Thanks for the chuckle mate. Dude is a clown available for children's parties.

he speaks, he writes, he hosts

 

[Mr Magic]

far out..the Lids thing wont go away...the latest suggests it not actually Lids pushing the envelope..latest is pick 35 and Kersten from the cats

Lol, the only currency Geelong has is Cockatoo and picks.

Kersten is garbage

 

[CoggaRules]

Latest whisper doing the rounds is that Fyfe was seen boarding a train at Flinders and as he did, looked around to see sign to check where it was going to and the sign next to it was flashing Frankston and the next stop was Richmond. I think thats enough to say he will be playing for the tigers next year.

 

[Mr Magic]

It's a great way to get the trade done, but still not sure I want just Prestia. Geelong getting Lids for Motlop is a steal.
I'd want Geelong's second rounder too.
Prestia and pick 35ish is fair for Lids.

I think GC getting Motlop for Prestia is very fair, both are young, Prestia gets more touches but Motlop kicks more goals and plays more games.

I'd acually want a better 2nd rounder than 35... Maybe the pick Geelong inevitably get for Smedts if they're trading him?

Lids is worth more than Prestia and Motlop!!

 

[docko911]

S.Edwards + next years first
For
Mitchell + their first

Lennon + for Carltons second

Vickery + Sydney's first to GC for Prestia + their 3rd

Our third + Conca to West Coast for their 2nd

Batchelor + our 4th to Brisbane for their 3rd

Mayne FA
Clarke FA

5 draft picks inside top 45
Upgrade Short

 

[harimal12]

anyone heard anything bout Lids today?

 

[bigstyletiger]

Hes not worth more than prestia. Age and his achilles make him a risk. Hes worth 15 to 25 to a club smack bang in their window i would guess.

 

[docko911]

Hes not worth more than prestia. Age and his achilles make him a risk. Hes worth 15 to 25 to a club smack bang in their window i would guess.

He would only be worth more to Geelong because they won't have a hope in hell of winning a flag in about 2 years.

 

[CoggaRules]

He would only be worth more to Geelong because they won't have a hope in hell of winning a flag in about 2 years.

here's thing dude. I read this post, i then re-read it, then read it slowly, then real slowly, even got down to word by word, and I still sprained my brain trying to work out WTF you are trying to say.

 

[prodigy]

here's thing dude. I read this post, i then re-read it, then read it slowly, then real slowly, even got down to word by word, and I still sprained my brain trying to work out WTF you are trying to say.

He is saying Geelong will be essentially out of the flag race by 2019.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[ScallyWag1]

here's thing dude. I read this post, i then re-read it, then read it slowly, then real slowly, even got down to word by word, and I still sprained my brain trying to work out WTF you are trying to say.

I think he's referring to how once Geelong pulled off their recruiting master stroke of 'being geographically closest to Moggs Creek' they well and truly sold the farm for the here and now.

So they may as well take a punt on a player that only has a few years left. Because in a few years when their starting midfield is along the lines of Guthrie, Cockatoo, and Bews they will be in roughly the same predicament Norf are in right now.

 

[THE_GUN]

If Geelong want Lids & Lids wants them the only deal i would accept is Cockatoo for Lids

Nothing els