List Mgmt. 2017 - Trading and Free Agency

[Quokka]

Perth now reporting that a deal for Wilson would cost us a second rounder. About right?
Next years probably then.

Happy with that unless we can jag one in a trade. Not ideal to keep trading away our future 2nds but at least it keeps our first pick safe.

 

[nurries]

Happy with that unless we can jag one in a trade. Not ideal to keep trading away our future 2nds but at least it keeps our first pick safe.

Happy to get a player of Wilsons caliber for a pick around 25

 

[Wally Walpamur]

Happy with that unless we can jag one in a trade. Not ideal to keep trading away our future 2nds but at least it keeps our first pick safe.

I'm hoping it's similar to what happened last season. A Vic club offer Suban/Zarke an offer that nets us a 2nd round compo that we on trade to GWS for Wilson. As unbelievable as that may sound, it happened 12 months ago.

 

[Wizard]

I don't want Paddy McCartin. Would prefer to target Bruce or Membrey but none of them are world beaters.

We already got knocked back by Bruce once.

 

[Wally Walpamur]

We already got knocked back by Bruce once.

F#@k him then.

 

[theGav56]

Is pure ruckmen, can not really play forward so doubt he would come over cheaply just to play WAFL.

Secondly we already have Darcy, Sandi and Luke Strnadica so we have enough depth should we have injuries.

I don't think he will ever be in front of Darcy (won't be best 22) and I don't think we should bring in players that will never be best 22 while we are rebuilding.

By drafting him, it means we won't bring in a player like Kelly, Ryan or Garlett who could be best 22.

Fully agree. In another 2 to 3 years things may be different especially if Strnadica doesn't come on.

 

[Eski3]

McCartin is one or two concussions away from retirement isn't he?

 

[IAMJUNGLEMUFFIN]

Hopefully just rumours.. just hurry up and sign Tabs, Freo.
Disappointed we signed Ballas tbh. He's 30+, past his prime yet guaranteed due to being a loyal and Ross' favourite. De Boer, Mzungu, Silvagni etc will be peeved. And they are a lot younger. I know we don't have depth in that position. But still don't get the reasoning. Meh

You are perpetually delusional about players. DeBoer, Mzungu, Silvagni were all average at best and never as good as Ballas.

 

[clivenator26]

I'm hoping it's similar to what happened last season. A Vic club offer Suban/Zarke an offer that nets us a 2nd round compo that we on trade to GWS for Wilson. As unbelievable as that may sound, it happened 12 months ago.

Clarke was out of contract a year ago and got no offers, we got him on a 1 yr deal and he spent the year injured. To get the same band of compo someone will need to give Suban a 3-4 yr deal at $5-600k a season. I can't see it happening.

 

[mike91]

We already got knocked back by Bruce once.

When was this?

 

[Dirty_banchez]

https://thewest.com.au/sport/afl/du...-fremantle-secure-nathan-wilson-ng-b88599491z

“The other one who is interesting is Hayden Crozier.

“He hasn’t been signed yet. That tells me that either he’s having second thoughts about staying or the club is thinking maybe Hayden Crozier goes on the table and we try and get ourselves back in the second round.

“Or it’s a combination of both those things... both club and player are weighing up their future.”

What do you all think? Is Duff correct? Should we trade Crozier?

I am putting this on the agenda.

 

[DaveLister]

https://thewest.com.au/sport/afl/du...-fremantle-secure-nathan-wilson-ng-b88599491z

“The other one who is interesting is Hayden Crozier.

“He hasn’t been signed yet. That tells me that either he’s having second thoughts about staying or the club is thinking maybe Hayden Crozier goes on the table and we try and get ourselves back in the second round.

“Or it’s a combination of both those things... both club and player are weighing up their future.”

What do you all think? Is Duff correct? Should we trade Crozier?

I am putting this on the agenda.

his reasoning is logical, depends on what we get from him
I have visions of him turning into Howe mark 2 intercept marking defender playing for a different team.
It'd be odd to get Wilson and lose Croz without giving Croz a proper opportunity in defense this year.

 

[FreoBraddles]

https://thewest.com.au/sport/afl/du...-fremantle-secure-nathan-wilson-ng-b88599491z

“The other one who is interesting is Hayden Crozier.

“He hasn’t been signed yet. That tells me that either he’s having second thoughts about staying or the club is thinking maybe Hayden Crozier goes on the table and we try and get ourselves back in the second round.

According to Mitch, Dogs are interested for what it's worth. Plus Matera medical upcoming soon.

 

[Hazelsnuts]

https://thewest.com.au/sport/afl/du...-fremantle-secure-nathan-wilson-ng-b88599491z

“The other one who is interesting is Hayden Crozier.

“He hasn’t been signed yet. That tells me that either he’s having second thoughts about staying or the club is thinking maybe Hayden Crozier goes on the table and we try and get ourselves back in the second round.

“Or it’s a combination of both those things... both club and player are weighing up their future.”

What do you all think? Is Duff correct? Should we trade Crozier?

I am putting this on the agenda.

Must be a bit going on behind the scenes with Adelaide coming out today saying they want 2 first rounders for Lever.
Maybe with our first going to Melbourne with Taberner or Crozier as a package??
Makes me think there may be something in the Hogan talk.
Depends if Melbourne think they can take the next step without Hogan.
Helps Melbourne get the deal done and we get our 10 year KPF without hoping that a young allrounder like Brander turns into the KPF we need on speculation.

 

[Dirty_banchez]

According to Mitch, Dogs are interested for what it's worth. Plus Matera medical upcoming soon.

Dogs have picks 26 and 39 after their first.

Would pick 26 satisfy GWS?

 

[Dirty_banchez]

Must be a bit going on behind the scenes with Adelaide coming out today saying they want 2 first rounders for Lever.
Maybe with our first going to Melbourne with Taberner or Crozier as a package??
Makes me think there may be something in the Hogan talk.
Depends if Melbourne think they can take the next step without Hogan.
Helps Melbourne get the deal done and we get our 10 year KPF without hoping that a young allrounder like Brander turns into the KPF we need on speculation.

Hogan won't be traded.

 

[Superkoops]

According to Mitch, Dogs are interested for what it's worth. Plus Matera medical upcoming soon.

Possibly
Crozier + 58 for Pick 26
Pick 26 for Nathan Wilson

Can't see us giving up much at all for Matera. Pick 77 or we give them back 55 and get 74 in return.
A pick between 35-45 for Balic

 

[Righteo]

Happy to get a player of Wilsons caliber for a pick around 25

Would be a ****ing massive steal. Will be a perennial AA contender if he stays fit. Sounds too good to be true tbh

 

[Purpellian Anchor]

https://thewest.com.au/sport/afl/du...-fremantle-secure-nathan-wilson-ng-b88599491z

“The other one who is interesting is Hayden Crozier.

“He hasn’t been signed yet. That tells me that either he’s having second thoughts about staying or the club is thinking maybe Hayden Crozier goes on the table and we try and get ourselves back in the second round.

“Or it’s a combination of both those things... both club and player are weighing up their future.”

What do you all think? Is Duff correct? Should we trade Crozier?

I am putting this on the agenda.

yep i think crozer will go....a good fit for GWS. and we gain Wilson .... but i wont be sad if Croz stays with us

 

[Wizard]

When was this?

This time last year, or the year before.

I don't recall which.

 

[electricfeel]

Can we trade Sheridan first....ugh

 

[Purpellian Anchor]

Sharing my player board that i look at to get an idea of what our weakness is now, could be through the year once we have a few injuries and planning ahead for 2019 as some players may not overcome their injuries satisfactorily to remain on the list.

By doubling up with two teams it gives an indication of our depth or lack of for each position...while acknowledging players could cover for two or more other positions.
Apeness, Bennell, and Pearce are three key players in the equation. The layout tells me that Naughton will probably be our priority ahead of another forward depending on what is going on behind the scenes with the likes of apeness and pearce and a likely incoming trade 2018 draft


followers Sandilands Darcy Fyfe Mundy Tucker Langdon

forwards Ballantyne , Crozier Taberner Mc Carthy Apeness?? Strnadica

half forward Bennell ?? D Pearce Cox Uebergang ?? Walters Kersten

centreline B Hill N Suban Neill Weller Duman Sheridan

half back S Hill Sutcliffe Johnson A Pearce?? Blakely Logue

full back Ryan Spurr Collins Hamling Nyhuis Hughes

Griffin Clarke?? Balic? (ret Dawson, Ibbotson, del. Yarran) at start 2017 38 on main list plus 6 rookies
de Luca Cardillo, B Gray

 

[purplerunsdeep]

Ahh I love the silly season. Ricky Nixon on twitter eluding to the one and only Chris Masten looking at a trade to freo


It's going to be a long off season


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[LeftFootBanana]

Ahh I love the silly season. Ricky Nixon on twitter eluding to the one and only Chris Masten looking at a trade to freo


It's going to be a long off season


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo - anyone but The Bator!!!!

 

[Dirty_banchez]

Ahh I love the silly season. Ricky Nixon on twitter eluding to the one and only Chris Masten looking at a trade to freo


It's going to be a long off season


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk