Analysis AFC SANFL 2019 Thread

[TubbsFarquhar]

No alternative for Kelly and Hartigan? Butts and Sholl are staking their claims.

 

[deeztreez]

Score please?

 

[Bicks]

1/2 time

Dylan - 22 Disposals - 14 Kicks - 8 Handballs - 4 Goals - 6 Marks - 3 Tackles - 2 Clearances

 

[Bearded Clam]

Josh Jenkins still playing li

Selectors couldn't possibly pick Jenkins on the back of his game so far.

Will be interesting to see what happens

josh is still playing like Jane..

 

[Elite Crow]

Reckon we should try Pohokle as a tagger.

Reckon he’d stick to the task, is quick enough to keep with his player and will win enough of his own ball to do some damage.

Just needs a run of games.

 

[mcattack]

Sorry Josh you can stay in the 2s

Yep Josh ... reality check. Poholke killing it though working hard. Shame fog is down back watching the action.

 

[Scorpus]

Imagine the confidence Poholke would have if we brought him in and played him in the center square, not half forward or forward pocket

 

[Bicks]

Score please?

9.5 - 2.4

 

[Murray2503]

Poholke in for Knight or CEY
Gallucci in for Mackay
Stengle in for Murphy
Butts in for Hartigan
Sholl in for Kelly

Agree. Not really sold on Poholke. We need speed which he doesn't have. TBH i havent really seen Butts play but surely anyone on our list is better than hartigan. Poholke would likely be better in a quick team. Our problem is our midfield is pedestrianly slow.

 

[hey shorty]

No alternative for Kelly and Hartigan? Butts and Sholl are staking their claims.

Brown.

I don't think Sholl plays the Harto role, but he could play the Mackay one much better.

 

[brucetiki]

Score please?

Half time
South 2.4.16
Adelaide 9.5.59

 

[Bearded Clam]

1.2 time

Dylan - 22 Disposals - 14 Kicks - 8 Handballs - 4 Goals - 6 Marks - 3 Tackles - 2 Clearances

The question still remains... if he gets played in his natural position in our AFL team, and is given a few weeks to prove himself, can he do it at AFL level?..

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

1/2 time

Dylan - 22 Disposals - 14 Kicks - 8 Handballs - 4 Goals - 6 Marks - 3 Tackles - 2 Clearances

Which three South Adelaide players will get the Magarey votes?

 

[Crow_68]

The question still remains... if he gets played in his natural position in our AFL team, and is given a few weeks to prove himself, can he do it at AFL level?..

The sad thing is that under the current regime, we will never know

On HTC 2PS6200 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[hey shorty]

Agree. Not really sold on Poholke. We need speed which he doesn't have. TBH i havent really seen Butts play but surely anyone on our list is better than hartigan. Poholke would likely be better in a quick team. Our problem is our midfield is pedestrianally slow.

He's a clean centre square player, not a half forward, it could allow us to push Sloane outside if we used Myles in his strength

 

[Cap]

These four have been good all season. No surprise they are dominating again today

Yes, so 4 games or so? Hardly left in the twos to rot.

It's good to see Poholke respond to his AFL game, which is exactly what players should be doing.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

The question still remains... if he gets played in his natural position in our AFL team, and is given a few weeks to prove himself, can he do it at AFL level?..

It's a question that will never be answered

 

[Bicks]

Agree. Not really sold on Poholke. We need speed which he doesn't have. TBH i havent really seen Butts play but surely anyone on our list is better than hartigan. Poholke would likely be better in a quick team. Our problem is our midfield is pedestrianly slow.

Listen numpty you seriously don't have a clue, Poholke has excellent speed for an inside midfielder...get it.

 

[Tex200]

Can’t see the game today but happy everyone getting to see what talent we have in our 2’s

 

[crows dude]

Agree. Not really sold on Poholke. We need speed which he doesn't have. TBH i havent really seen Butts play but surely anyone on our list is better than hartigan. Poholke would likely be better in a quick team. Our problem is our midfield is pedestrianly slow.

Poholke is not slow

 

[CrowinNT]

If we swapped Gooch, Poholke, Stengle, Davis, Otten and Wilson for Murphy, Mackay, Hartigan, Kelly, CEY and Gibbs we’d be a better team


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Not Otten

 

[1990crow]

Poholke in for Knight or CEY
Gallucci in for Mackay
Stengle in for Murphy
Butts in for Hartigan
Sholl in for Kelly

Like it.
Maybe even Davis in for Lynch.
Hunter in for Obrien.
Jones in for Knight.
Poholke in for CEY

Sholl ~ Talia ~ Butts
Laird ~ Keath ~ Smith
Sloane ~ Gibbs ~ Milera
Hunter ~ Crouch ~ Crouch
Davis ~ Walker ~ Galluci
Betts ~ Himmelburg ~ Stengle
Greenwood ~ Poholke ~ Jones
Atkins

 

[MarcusP2]

Am I the only one confused.
Who is Dylan?

I think it was BT calling him Dylan Poholke repeatedly on his debut last year.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

If we swapped Gooch, Poholke, Stengle, Davis, Otten and Wilson for Murphy, Mackay, Hartigan, Kelly, CEY and Gibbs we’d be a better team


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Replace Otten with Sholl/Butts.

 

[Scorpus]

Like it.
Maybe even Davis in for Lynch.
Hunter in for Obrien.
Jones in for Knight.
Poholke in for CEY

Sholl ~ Talia ~ Butts
Laird ~ Keath ~ Smith
Sloane ~ Gibbs ~ Milera
Hunter ~ Crouch ~ Crouch
Davis ~ Walker ~ Galluci
Betts ~ Himmelburg ~ Stengle
Greenwood ~ Poholke ~ Jones
Atkins

Oh yeah Jones has to come back in as well.

There's pressure for spots. I mean that pressure is against an immovable meter thick concrete wall but the pressure is there