Recommitted Tom Papley [wanted to return to Victoria, nominated Carlton - didn't get there]

[THE_GUN]

Swans need two top 10 picks to secure Daniher.

No chance Daniher will be worth 2 x 1st rounders , Specially with swans already holding pick #4

 

[Benaly28]

No chance Daniher will be worth 2 x 1st rounders , Specially with swans already holding pick #4

They’ll need to overpay and when on and free from injury is worth two first rounders IMO.

 

[THE_GUN]

They’ll need to overpay and when on and free from injury is worth two first rounders IMO.

Joe Daniher is no way worth 2 x 1st rounders

2018 -7 games
2019 - 4 games

averaging 12/13 touches for 1.5 goal average last 2 years
DE% in 2019 64%
De % in 2018 50%

He will be 26 year old by the time he pays his 1st game for the new club if he moves
Career stats
12.7 disposala
1.8 goals
63.8% DE

Pick #10-#15 would be about his value at this point and declining as years go on

Sydney still have Ried , Franklin and also Blakey coming through not sure they are so desperate to pay up 2 x1st rounders

 

[Bonz]

They’ll need to overpay and when on and free from injury is worth two first rounders IMO.

No need to overpay, if needed we target next year as a free agent.


Also he has been injured for a while now which reduces his value, if he was injury free (big if) then he is easily worth two first rounders.

 

[Tedeski]

They’ll need to overpay and when on and free from injury is worth two first rounders IMO.

Your opinion isn't reality.

 

[Tedeski]

Joe Daniher is no way worth 2 x 1st rounders

2018 -7 games
2019 - 4 games

averaging 12/13 touches for 1.5 goal average last 2 years
DE% in 2019 64%
De % in 2018 50%

He will be 26 year old by the time he pays his 1st game for the new club if he moves
Career stats
12.7 disposala
1.8 goals
63.8% DE

Pick #10-#15 would be about his value at this point and declining as years go on

Sydney still have Ried , Franklin and also Blakey coming through not sure they are so desperate to pay up 2 x1st rounders

We are not talking to him to take him now. We will get him as a FA next year or cheap now.

 

[MITSUHIRATO]

More likely the Swans get Cripps, having played all his careeer for a bottom 2 team, though he finally had an achievement in season 2019 & turned his team into a destination club by finishing 3rd bottom.
The over inflation of where Carlton are at is mind boggling & Carlton would be the last club Papley would go to should he ever want to come to Melbourne.

I work with Pap’s girlfriend since she’s come back from Sydney full time - he will nominate Carlton.

 

[THE_GUN]

I work with Pap’s girlfriend since she’s come back from Sydney full time - he will nominate Carlton.

Thats as good as info you could get imo.

 

[Tedeski]

I work with Pap’s girlfriend since she’s come back from Sydney full time - he will nominate Carlton.

You only nominate when you are a FA.
He's contracted.

 

[Punts]

You only nominate when you are a FA.
He's contracted.

Sadly you are wrong mate

Contracted players nominate teams every year

You know this ted

 

[Unfazed]

I work with Pap’s girlfriend since she’s come back from Sydney full time - he will nominate Carlton.

That's as reliable as North posters last year saying they'd seen Gaff's partner's cv at Melbourne schools.

 

[Tedeski]

Sadly you are wrong mate

Contracted players nominate teams every year

You know this ted

Yes they do Punts but these nuffs talking like we hold no cards.
There''s 10 teams in Victoria.

 

[MITSUHIRATO]

That's as reliable as North posters last year saying they'd seen Gaff's partner's cv at Melbourne schools.

I don’t care if you think it’s reliable or not.

Bookmark it.

 

[Red Bull]

Yes they do Punts but these nuffs talking like we hold no cards.
There''s 10 teams in Victoria.

Wouldn’t matter if there were 100 teams in Victoria Ted.
If Papley nominates Carlton the 2 clubs will talk and pick 8 is a very fair price.
We’d be happy to assist the Swans take Daniher to Sydney.

 

[giantsully]

Yes they do Punts but these nuffs talking like we hold no cards.
There''s 10 teams in Victoria.

How many of them bid on Mitchell?

 

[Drewie11]

Heard a Carlton supporter call up SEN and say 8 is too much for Papley so Sydney should throw in Jones also... delusional

 

[THE_GUN]

Pick #8 will become pick #10
GC suns are almost assured of getting a PP & GWS will certainly have to use a top 5 pick for Tom Green

 

[Punts]

Blues giving up now they are getting that gun Martin

 

[Tedeski]

Blues giving up now they are getting that gun Martin

No! Maclure hasn't.
He just said on the Carlton FC show that they'll need to give up a first round pick to get Martin & that Papley WILL be playing for Carlton next year.

So Punts, will Cripps play 70% midfield & 30% forward for us in 2020 or 80 - 20?

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

No! Maclure hasn't.
He just said on the Carlton FC show that they'll need to give up a first round pick to get Martin & that Papley WILL be playing for Carlton next year.

So Punts, will Cripps play 70% midfield & 30% forward for us in 2020 or 80 - 20?

8 + future 2nd > Martin and 15

15 + future 1st > Papley, Cameron. Trimmings to make it fair either way.

Carlton find a future 2nd somewhere to beat the rules. Papley and Martin is hardly unachievable.

 

[THE_GUN]

8 + future 2nd > Martin and 15

15 + future 1st > Papley, Cameron. Trimmings to make it fair either way.

Carlton find a future 2nd somewhere to beat the rules. Papley and Martin is hardly unachievable.

Would Carlton do 2020 1st rounder for Martin ?

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Would Carlton do 2020 1st rounder for Martin ?

I’d hope not, unless we get something relatively heavy back in addition to Martin.

We could quite easily remain in the bottom few next year.

 

[THE_GUN]

I’d hope not, unless we get something relatively heavy back in addition to Martin.

We could quite easily remain in the bottom few next year.

Well with 4-5 decent to good afl players coming into the team Papley,Martin,Butler ++ you would believe that Carlton should be atleast around the 8 or not far away and a pick around 10 -12 would be around the range.

realistically a pick for Martin would be around the 16-25 range with 3 clubs chasing him and good dollars offered

 

[Bostonian]

Blues giving up now they are getting that gun Martin

Why would the two be in anyway related?

One is a need for a wing and the other is a need for a small forward.

 

[Punts]

Why would the two be in anyway related?

One is a need for a wing and the other is a need for a small forward.

Highly doubt we will take a future pick