Remove this Banner Ad

Draft Review 21st Century draft game - full 22 edition

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

ArdentEagle said:
Are you using AI and editing from there mate?
Click to expand...
No, completely 100% my own writing

Episode 17 Laughing GIF by The Simpsons
 
also asked Chatgpt why West Coast is worse than my team

While this team has several standout players, there are a few factors that might contribute to it being seen as less formidable compared to your team:

  1. Defensive Weakness: The team includes some strong defenders like Tom Barrass, Heath Shaw, and Harry Taylor, but lacks a bit of defensive depth and versatility. Compared to your team, which features a mix of defensive and offensive players, this team might struggle with adaptability in defense.
  2. Midfield Balance: Although Patrick Dangerfield is an elite midfielder, the overall midfield mix could be considered less balanced. Tom Liberatore and Dayne Zorko are solid players, but they don’t necessarily provide the same level of ball-winning and distribution as Clayton Oliver and Nathan Jones in your team. This could lead to a less effective midfield unit.
  3. Forward Line Depth: The forward line, with Josh J. Kennedy and Mark LeCras, is strong, but it lacks the dynamic versatility that your team has with players like Cyril Rioli and Bayley Fritsch. The team could benefit from more flexibility and goal-scoring variety in the forward positions.
  4. Experience vs. Youth: While the team has experienced players like Aaron Sandilands and Leigh Montagna, it might lack the balance between veteran leadership and emerging talent. Your team benefits from a mix of both, which could contribute to better on-field cohesion and long-term potential.
  5. Overall Team Balance: The team’s overall balance might not be as strong as yours. For example, while it has notable players, there could be concerns about depth and versatility in various positions compared to the well-rounded nature of your squad.
In summary, while this team features some outstanding individual talents, it might be lacking in overall balance, versatility, and depth compared to your team, which could make it less formidable in a competitive setting.
 
I actually asked ChatGPT to create a best 22 from players who debuted between 1995 and 2024 and while there were some obvious mistakes its overall attempt was not bad

B: Dustin Fletcher, Alex Rance, Brian Lake
HB: Cameron Ling, Luke Hodge, James Sicily
C: Nick Dal Santo, Patrick Dangerfield, Chris Judd
HF: Jonathan Brown, Wayne Carey, Lance Franklin
F: Tony Shaw, Matthew Lloyd, Gary Ablett Jr.
Foll: Max Gawn, Simon Black, Dane Swan
I/C: James Hird, Scott Pendlebury, Jared Roughead, Robert Harvey
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I think perhaps his recent form in the twilight of his career may have meant he has been undersold somewhat, but my next selection was the best winger in the game for at least 7 years (and so good that he actually forced his way into the All Australian team when wingers have mostly been shunned).

He won a best and fairest in a Grand Final side and was All Australian the same year. He earnt another All Australian and was instrumental in a premiership year. He made the squad 3 more times when no genuine wingmen were selected. He finished top 5 in the Brownlow (and top 12 two more times) - unheard of for a winger. He was also top 5 in the Coaches award. A genuine gut running beast that averaged 30+ disposals for 5 years running whilst being completely on the outside...

With pick 212, Hawthorn selects...Andrew Gaff.

RedmanWasHere
 
Last edited:
RUNVS said:
also asked Chatgpt why West Coast is worse than my team

While this team has several standout players, there are a few factors that might contribute to it being seen as less formidable compared to your team:

  1. Defensive Weakness: The team includes some strong defenders like Tom Barrass, Heath Shaw, and Harry Taylor, but lacks a bit of defensive depth and versatility. Compared to your team, which features a mix of defensive and offensive players, this team might struggle with adaptability in defense.
  2. Midfield Balance: Although Patrick Dangerfield is an elite midfielder, the overall midfield mix could be considered less balanced. Tom Liberatore and Dayne Zorko are solid players, but they don’t necessarily provide the same level of ball-winning and distribution as Clayton Oliver and Nathan Jones in your team. This could lead to a less effective midfield unit.
  3. Forward Line Depth: The forward line, with Josh J. Kennedy and Mark LeCras, is strong, but it lacks the dynamic versatility that your team has with players like Cyril Rioli and Bayley Fritsch. The team could benefit from more flexibility and goal-scoring variety in the forward positions.
  4. Experience vs. Youth: While the team has experienced players like Aaron Sandilands and Leigh Montagna, it might lack the balance between veteran leadership and emerging talent. Your team benefits from a mix of both, which could contribute to better on-field cohesion and long-term potential.
  5. Overall Team Balance: The team’s overall balance might not be as strong as yours. For example, while it has notable players, there could be concerns about depth and versatility in various positions compared to the well-rounded nature of your squad.
In summary, while this team features some outstanding individual talents, it might be lacking in overall balance, versatility, and depth compared to your team, which could make it less formidable in a competitive setting.
Click to expand...
**** you chatgpt 🤣
I haven't even finished yet.

Now ask why mine is better 😁
 
Guardian Hawk said:
I think perhaps his recent form in the twilight of his career may have meant he has been undersold somewhat, but my next selection was the best winger in the game for at least 7 years (and so good that he actually forced his way into the All Australian team when wingers have mostly been shunned).

He won a best and fairest in a Grand Final side and was All Australian the same year. He earnt another All Australian and was instrumental in a premiership year. He made the squad 3 more times when no genuine wingmen were selected. He finished top 5 in the Brownlow (and top 12 two more times) - unheard of for a winger. He was also top 5 in the Coaches award. A genuine gut running beast that averaged 30+ disposals for 5 years running whilst being completely on the outside...

With pick 212, Hawthorn selects...Andrew Gaff.
Click to expand...

I knew it. I could get Rory Sloane, but knew Gaff would be long gone. I really wanted him too
Sad Oh No GIF by BrownSugarApp
 
RUNVS said:
I actually asked ChatGPT to create a best 22 from players who debuted between 1995 and 2024 and while there were some obvious mistakes its overall attempt was not bad

B: Dustin Fletcher, Alex Rance, Brian Lake
HB: Cameron Ling, Luke Hodge, James Sicily
C: Nick Dal Santo, Patrick Dangerfield, Chris Judd
HF: Jonathan Brown, Wayne Carey, Lance Franklin
F: Tony Shaw, Matthew Lloyd, Gary Ablett Jr.
Foll: Max Gawn, Simon Black, Dane Swan
I/C: James Hird, Scott Pendlebury, Jared Roughead, Robert Harvey
Click to expand...
Chatgpt has Tony Shaw as ruck. 😆😆

You're going to need the rest of that team just to offset
 
reggie said:
Matthew Primus played for Fitzroy but not Brisbane
Click to expand...
Yeah, I was joking. I'll redo it at the end. I'm going to have to either find a new formula to use which seems complicated, or I just change all Port Adelaide entries to Port, and Greater Western Sydney and North Melbourne to North although that's undesirable.
 
ArdentEagle said:
Chatgpt has Tony Shaw as ruck. 😆😆

You're going to need the rest of that team just to offset
Click to expand...
ChatGPT, and Copilot are the same. I think it struggles with complex situations

I don't think it can do number guessing game for example.

It struggles when you ask it for a song and gives you fake songs.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

ArdentEagle said:
**** you chatgpt 🤣
I haven't even finished yet.

Now ask why mine is better 😁
Click to expand...
I think my mids and forward line are really strong. I've got players to address the holes.

My defence is not as strong as some of the other defences but I think my KPD's can hold Franklin with Birchall as 3rd man up, but I've got a few gems to fill the gaps if they last.

Really happy to add Sloane to Simpson, Butters, and Serong

I'm trying to find a way to draft in some of the clubs I'm missing

Brisbane, Geelong, Bulldogs, GWS, Gold Coast, Richmond, Collingwood, and Melbounre
 
Guardian Hawk said:
I think perhaps his recent form in the twilight of his career may have meant he has been undersold somewhat, but my next selection was the best winger in the game for at least 7 years (and so good that he actually forced his way into the All Australian team when wingers have mostly been shunned).

He won a best and fairest in a Grand Final side and was All Australian the same year. He earnt another All Australian and was instrumental in a premiership year. He made the squad 3 more times when no genuine wingmen were selected. He finished top 5 in the Brownlow (and top 12 two more times) - unheard of for a winger. He was also top 5 in the Coaches award. A genuine gut running beast that averaged 30+ disposals for 5 years running whilst being completely on the outside...

With pick 212, Hawthorn selects...Andrew Gaff.

RedmanWasHere
Click to expand...
Nice pick, was thinking I might get Gaff and McCluggage on the wings 😅

RedmanWasHere you’re up
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Pick 215 - Windrunners - Jack Darling

Thought he would not make it here but luckily the grabbing of KPFs cooled off. Thought someone might have grabbed even as a third forward.

All Australian KPF with 7 seasons of 40+ goals and pushing the top 50 of all time most goals kicked.
Led WCE goal kicking tally during their premiership year.
Also a tenacious defender inside forward 50 and underrated in his forward pressure.
Has dropped off in recent times but he has been an extremely consistent performer.
Very nice foil for Walker up forward.

FB: Enright - Weitering - Maxwell
HB: Sinclair - Talia - Goddard
C: ? - Parker - McCluggage
HF: ? - Darling - ?
FF ? - Walker - ?
R: Gawn - Pendlebury - Merrett
B: ? - ? - ? - ?

boncer34 you're up.
 
Time to take a bloke who's career was seriously decimated by injuries, if it wasn't for his dickey knee and terrible media work once he retired this bloke would be remembered as an all time great.

Adam Cooney

FB - Prestigiacomo Smith
HB - Lake Houli
C Cooney Priddis -
HF - Lucas Robertson
F - Fevola Pickett
R Goodes Francou Bell
Int - - - -
Sub -
 
boncer34 said:
Time to take a bloke who's career was seriously decimated by injuries, if it wasn't for his dickey knee and terrible media work once he retired this bloke would be remembered as an all time great.

Adam Cooney

FB - Prestigiacomo Smith
HB - Lake Houli
C Cooney Priddis -
HF - Lucas Robertson
F - Fevola Pickett
R Goodes Francou Bell
Int - - - -
Sub -
Click to expand...

You need to do a trade to get Cotchin and then you can have a complete line of "WTF how did they get a brownlow" players.
 
RUNVS said:
You need to do a trade to get Cotchin and then you can have a complete line of "WTF how did they get a brownlow" players.
Click to expand...
Cooney was phenomenal in 2008.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Lore
Traded Pick swap: Hawthorn trade #9, #31, #42 and #43 to Carlton for #Pick 10 and #22
Replies
5
Views
466
Vindicater
Vindicater
RedmanWasHere
Draft Review 2023 - Revisit the 2023 AFL Draft
Replies
10
Views
1K
RedmanWasHere
RedmanWasHere
Cleric
Draft Review Prediction - From the 2024 AFL draft, which player will move up the highest amount of spots in the draft redo threads?
2
Replies
35
Views
4K
LeeCarvallo
LeeCarvallo
RUNVS
Live Event 2024 AFL Draft LIVE Thread
29 30 31 32 33
Replies
816
Views
48K
streetspirit
streetspirit
RedmanWasHere
Draft Review Redo the 1993 AFL Draft
Replies
0
Views
696
RedmanWasHere
RedmanWasHere
danster168
Draft Review 2023 - Re-do the draft
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
145
Views
16K
KissKiss
KissKiss

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top