Game Day 2024 Trade Period - Lian Yu - that liminal space between trade and draft.

[Joao]

until they are signed it’s pretty much same talk? It’s all talk until they sign

I'm guessing you haven't paid a lot of attention in the past with player movement? Some are impossibly to tell, but some are REALLY obvious from a long way out.

Andy is really obviously staying.
Chad is a 50/50 at best.

i can tell you for a fact Warner met with Naughton when Sydney offered him 10 years?

What is your end game here? Are you really trying to say that literally every players gets reported the same and there is exactly 0 information in the that reporting regarding player movement? Because I think that is completely ludicrous and I can't imagine why you'd ever bother arguing that.

 

[mike91]

i can tell you for a fact Warner met with Naughton when Sydney offered him 10 years?

Honestly man, come on......

Like, come on....

On SM-G781B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Cobbler]

i can tell you for a fact Warner met with Naughton when Sydney offered him 10 years?

Warner ‘Hey mate’
Naughton ‘What’s it like?’
Warner ‘Bro… It’s alright, but I’ll be heading home soon’
Naughton ‘Cool’

Awkward silence

Naughton ‘I might just resign with Dogs’
Warner ‘Yep’
Naughton ‘Cool cool’

 

[Swiggy]

I'm guessing you haven't paid a lot of attention in the past with player movement? Some are impossibly to tell, but some are REALLY obvious from a long way out.

Andy is really obviously staying.
Chad is a 50/50 at best.




What is your end game here? Are you really trying to say that literally every players gets reported the same and there is exactly 0 information in the that reporting regarding player movement? Because I think that is completely ludicrous and I can't imagine why you'd ever bother arguing that.

If you actually read from the start my hole point was on why would they trade him in contract. Then said ‘it like’ Brayshaw.

If you actually read my posts I agree Brayshaw will 90% stay & Warner is 50/50.

But you are jumping to conclusions I they are similar because.

They are both out of contact new year?
They both have big money offers from rival clubs?

And lastly they both live away from there home state?

That’s pretty similar to me

 

[Joao]

If you actually read from the start my hole point was on why would they trade him in contract. Then said ‘it like’ Brayshaw.

If you actually read my posts I agree Brayshaw will 90% stay & Warner is 50/50.

But you are jumping to conclusions I they are similar because.

They are both out of contact new year?
They both have big money offers from rival clubs?

And lastly they both live away from there home stat?

That’s pretty similar to me

Agree to disagree.

 

[FreoBulldog]

Wow. This makes me wonder how many people observe BF without ever actually positing.

That'd be me. I am definitely a lurker. I just enjoy reading other people's opinions.

 

[Docker82]

I'm guessing you haven't paid a lot of attention in the past with player movement? Some are impossibly to tell, but some are REALLY obvious from a long way out.

Andy is really obviously staying.
Chad is a 50/50 at best.

50/50 is very generous for Warner.

I’ve been wrong quite a bit in the past but this feels like Dangerfield at Adelaide, Jackson at Melbourne, Cerra at Fremantle etc. where it was a matter of which club 12 months out.

Brayshaw seems more loyal than Pavlich was - There I said it.

 

[Swiggy]

Agree to disagree.

Basically all I’m getting at is unfortunately sydney & Melbourne won’t trade Warner or Pickett and they both are to loyal to ask for trade.
So freo are better off worrying about the trade & draft this year and see what pops up next year.

If they worry to much about Warner could miss Bolton & a good kid in this years draft and Warner could re-sigh in that time

 

[Wray27]

Ok, time to liven this place up and potentially get myself banned.

How about Warner for Amiss - straight swap.

Do your worst, I don’t care.



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

At least it’s interesting and better than the yawn fest of speculation and drivel currently being posted by most in here.

 

[Sewell21]

We need to consider that we have more currency than just picks. The following players will have some interest, some value, and just as importantly we could cover the loss of one on each line;

Mids: Johnson, Ras
Fwds: Switta,
Backs: Ryan, Cox
Ruck: Darcy

Most other remaining players we cant cover, or have little trade value.

Maybe its time we need to get a little ruthless.

 

[Docker82]

We need to consider that we have more currency than just picks. The following players will have some interest, some value, and just as importantly we could cover the loss of one on each line;

Mids: Johnson, Ras
Fwds: Switta,
Backs: Ryan, Cox
Ruck: Darcy

Most other remaining players we cant cover, or have little trade value.

Maybe its time we need to get a little ruthless.

Some would argue it’s time to start a season where we’re not replacing an A or B Grader with either an inferior player or someone drafted in the last 24 months…

 

[Sewell21]

Some would argue it’s time to start a season where we’re not replacing an A or B Grader with either an inferior player or someone drafted in the last 24 months…

Agree but the purpose would be to bring in AA graders in Bolton, Warner, or an A grader in Kozzie.

Edit: Spelling

 

[King Huskii]

At least it’s interesting and better than the yawn fest of speculation and drivel currently being posted by most in here.

Hey I don't drivel!

 

[Docker82]

Agree but the purpose would be to bring in AA graders in Bolton, Warner, or an A grader in Kozzie.

Edit: Spelling

No need to do this if we wait until next year for Warner. We’d get an extra top 20 draft pick in the door too.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Yep & also Has been reports in last 2 weeks Brayshaw is leaving too? Was a rumour last week he met with Ross Lyon?

Who actually knows?

I just think you’d be crazy to trade someone so important like Warner when he is a key player in your premiership tilt. No draft picks replace him next year

I know your quite good / keen on being the grounded force but even you would admit there is a gigantic difference im the reporting between Brayshaw and Warner. To pretend otherwise is silly.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

12 months is a long time. Anything can happen. Warner could have a new girlfriend from NSW who tells him there's no way I'm moving to WA. Game over.

Warner is so in love with his cureent GF he's leaving the Swans for her

 

[Madas]

12 months is a long time. Anything can happen. Warner could have a new girlfriend from NSW who tells him there's no way I'm moving to WA. Game over.

Hope he doesn’t get a new GF, she’s hot

 

[Taylor]

The question is whether that girlfriend was on the mocktails at Nobu..

 

[Midnite65]

Would you trade brayshaw now if was talk he might leave? AFL is a business of winning flags swans don't get better losing warner short term. he's worth 2 firsts next year still, & who knows you might talk him into staying in Sydney.

There is no talk he might leave, he bleeds Freo and was one of our three captains this year so no.

 

[Wray27]

The question is whether that girlfriend was on the mocktails at Nobu..

The girlfriends name is Alice Hughes and no she wasn’t on the mocktails.

 

[guidodp15]

Warner is so in love with his cureent GF he's leaving the Swans for her

After having the unfortunate pleasure of seeing those leaked pics of him having a GF surprises me

 

[Purpletown]

I saw Suma at Tony Ale's this morning. I should have asked him what was happening at Freo.

Just a bit of tinkering at Freo (according to Suma)

 

[Fred Ziffel]

Gonna be funny if the club goes all in on next years draft just for Warner to sign with Sydney again or ask to go to the eagles

You think our list manager is a completely naive fool ?

 

[Cobbler]

One of the better comments!

 

[King Huskii]

View attachment 2134728
One of the better comments!