Resource 2024 AFL Draft discussion thread (Wed Nov 20 to Fri Nov 22)

[TryAnHit]

We can't even play all our kids now. With anb cumming and peatling into our side + melira.

Am fine with us only taking pick 4 + welsh. Just no room to blood youngsters atm.

 

[1970crow]

We can't even play all our kids now. With anb cumming and peatling into our side + melira.

Am fine with us only taking pick 4 + welsh. Just no room to blood youngsters atm.

Yeh, we're stacked.

 

[1990crow]

We can't even play all our kids now. With anb cumming and peatling into our side + melira.

Am fine with us only taking pick 4 + welsh. Just no room to blood youngsters atm.

I wouldn't say that. We could choose to not pick Crouch, Laird, Murphy, Berry.

 

[Trigger13]

this club is stacked with morons.

 

[George CantStandYa]

Kuwarna to nominate Welsh

His father Scott played 129 games and kicked 270 goals for the Club from 2000 to 2007

www.afc.com.au

Officially nominated Tyler.

Why Kuwarna?

 

[Mostyn]

What a load of crap so the coach is meant to know the contract status of every player on the list Gtfoh thats the list managers job fmd i read some crap on here but that takes the cake .Simple fact is should smith still be there probably not but he is end of story

On SM-G996B using BigFooty.com mobile app

I imagine the policy is that Reid doesn't come to the coaching team with opinions on who should be getting played.

It's probably up for Nicks and the panel to decide who to play every week. I don't think anyone comes and tells them to not play someone thst they want to play, because we need to be managing contract situations.

Of course, they probably should ...

 

[George CantStandYa]

We can't even play all our kids now. With anb cumming and peatling into our side + melira.

Am fine with us only taking pick 4 + welsh. Just no room to blood youngsters atm.

Do you draft for years 1-3? Or years 3-10?

 

[Mostyn]

Bold sides would come up with a remedy to this. I am not knocking our trade period, we have brought in 3 players that add to our list in areas of need - big tick. BUT, the obvious thing was to not resign certain players so early and we would have had that coveted list spot for another crack at this draft...

Yeah, it's thrown a shadow on the great success of the trade period.

We didn't really have any good picks, but I guess we could have solved that with future picks.

 

[1990crow]

Why Kuwarna?

AFLW indigenous round I think

 

[Mostyn]

I mean, we’re both clearly making assumptions here. You have no idea either way if it was or wasn’t Nicks’ intentions to get Smith to his trigger

If anything, Nicks saying the ‘big part of our future’ stuff showed that he clearly did (stupidly) rate what he brought, up to a point

I’m just believing what I see is the most plausible scenario. Agree to disagree

I think Nicks saying "he's a big part of our future" is the same as a chairman saying "the coach has our complete support."

 

[jenny61_99]

Why Kuwarna?

Probably to do with it being indigenous round in the AFLW?

 

[Mostyn]

And we don’t have the pick because there’s no point because we haven’t got a list spot

If Dodson was there we could easily trade picks in to draft him but we’ve cut off all options

Could we?

What would we trade?

 

[George CantStandYa]

AFLW indigenous round I think

Probably to do with it being indigenous round in the AFLW?

Fair enough if it’s the women’s team, we are talking men’s

 

[1990crow]

Fair enough if it’s the women’s team, we are talking men’s

Unlike our little brother we are one club

 

[George CantStandYa]

Could we?

What would we trade?

Well we pushed 45 into next year, we didn’t need to do that. Plus a future third could have been enough depending how far he slid. Issue is we don’t even have that option.

 

[jenny61_99]

I know he said that - but I don't for one second think he believed it.

What coaches say to the general public, and what they say to the team behind closed doors, are two VERY different things. Anyone who watched that Netflix documentary on the AFL COVID season knows just how diametrically opposed some statements are.

That statement was about Nicks showing public support for one of his players - nothing more, nothing less.

Nicks' actions, in dropping Smith back to the SANFL very shortly thereafter, show how he really felt about Smith's performances. As with all AFL coaches - look at his actions, not his words.

I honestly don't understand why people keep quoting this statement, as if it actually meant anything, or was honestly believed by Nicks at the time. The fact that it's quoted so often speaks volumes about the stupidity of some supporters, and says nothing whatsoever about Nicks' thought processes.

To an extent. You can support your players publicly, but you don't say a 30+ year something player is a "big part of our future". That's just a nonsense. Now if he were to say "helping us to develop our juniors in the two's" nobody would have a problem with that. It really was a stupid decision by them to keep him on the list, IMO.

 

[Coopers]

Why Kuwarna?

Because he's our father son selection

 

[NTRabbit]

Fair enough if it’s the women’s team, we are talking men’s

It'll be a sitewide scripted rule that automatically replaces all instances referring to the football club by "Adelaide" with "Kuwarna", set to last until the end of the week

 

[1970crow]

Why Kuwarna?

Part of our RAP, we're making a difference.

 

[TryAnHit]

I wouldn't say that. We could choose to not pick Crouch, Laird, Murphy, Berry.

Berry won't play. Peatling takes his spot
Murphy won't play. ANB takes his spot
Crouch is well in our best side.
Would love to see laird out. Hopefully in favour of draper

 

[Vader]

It'll be a sitewide scripted rule that automatically replaces all instances referring to the football club by "Adelaide" with "Kuwarna", set to last until the end of the week

You're probably right... which doesn't make it any less ****ing stupid!

 

[George CantStandYa]

To an extent. You can support your players publicly, but you don't say a 30+ year something player is a "big part of our future". That's just a nonsense. Now if he were to say "helping us to develop our juniors in the two's" nobody would have a problem with that. It really was a stupid decision by them to keep him on the list, IMO.

You go girl!!!!

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Could we?

What would we trade?

Whatever we thought he was worth

But we haven’t got the option

 

[Cromulant]

We can't even play all our kids now. With anb cumming and peatling into our side + melira.

Am fine with us only taking pick 4 + welsh. Just no room to blood youngsters atm.

Milera wont be in the AFL side.

 

[Mutineer]

There's zero doubt that the list management group are happy with where the list is at. Added some missing pieces and we are contending. We saw us as contending before adding the 3 walk up starters to half forward, half back and midfield.

Aren't you?

Other than ruck stocks into the future I don't think there's too many holes in our list and some pretty reasonable depth. Peatling, Cumming and ANB certainly strengthens our list. Other than a developing ruck and perhaps another decent young small forward for the future allowing Rankine and Rachele more to concentrate on midfield where else do you see us needing to strengthen through this draft with the picks we originally held?

We really just need to get the best out of what we already have, that's down to the coach and his assistants.

I think we have a Finals contending list with our additions already plus pick 4 and Welsh?