Preview R8: Changes vs. Carlton - Nicks Sucks and Must be Sacked

[Samcro24]

Amputate + play

We’ll see how committed he is

 

[Doctor B]

Amputate + play

We’ll see how committed he is

Brett Backwell

 

[Cromulant]

Not many plusses in the SANFL. Berry maybe. McAndrew maybe.

Berry yes, Bond yes

Pedlar a maybe..... that's it

 

[Eagleboy2011]

Amputate + play

We’ll see how committed he is

Wasn't there a Glenelg player a few years back that done that.

 

[Samcro24]

Brett Backwell

It’s a useless finger anyway
It’s not the fu finger
It’s not the nose picker
Or the coke finger

You put a ring on it but you’d have to be demented to get married as an afl player anyway

 

[Burtonsgottago]

SANFL version?

He always rises for a Showdown

 

[Boundryump]

Amputate + play

We’ll see how committed he is

Daniel Chick had his finger amputated

 

[WetCrow1991]

Hackervis has had a shot and he hasn't taken it.

I was wrong about him. Isn't AFL level.

 

[madstar]

Carlton looked red hot against a very good Geelong team

 

[Burtonsgottago]

Almost certain to rest TT, no point risking him. Curtin to have a go playing the TT role for a few weeks.

Fog likely in.

ROB, Crouch, Keane, Milera should all be dropped but Nicks is gutless so wont happen. Peatling and Soligo to play 90% pure midfield time.

Rankine to play 90% forward, don't like him kick chasing up in midfield he's becoming ineffective and teams putting too much time into him at stoppages, its not a 'surprise' move now anymore Nicks you clown.

Whats the go with Edwards and Ryan? are they no good or have they been Nicksed by our awesome development?

As much as I love Sid, he might benefit from a spell in the 2's for a few weeks just to purely get some full game sinto him and some confidence/touch.

I also hate to admit but Jones even probably offers more than Milera at half back. If Hinge out surely we give Ryan a go?

If Jones plays ahead of Edwards or Ryan, I’ll hand in my membership

 

[Scorpus]

Carlton looked red hot against a very good Geelong team

Nicks is undefeated against Voss

 

[madstar]

If Jones plays ahead of Edwards or Ryan, I’ll hand in my membership

Very hard to justify that one. More likely to look to Murphy. Anyone who was at the SANFL, did he have a reasonable game? Anyway we are after talls surely

 

[spenze]

Nice to see a bit of Nicks mentality re inexperienced players , lets punt the guys after a bad game but give the experienced players games to bounce back

 

[steve9798]

If Jones plays ahead of Edwards or Ryan, I’ll hand in my membership

I'm more concerned that they will bring back Murphy. One of Nicks' go to players.

 

[BRL121]

Very hard to justify that one. More likely to look to Murphy. Anyone who was at the SANFL, did he have a reasonable game? Anyway we are after talls surely

He was awful, but reasonable in the last when moved onto ball.

 

[King Elvis]

Waste of space. Seagull receiver that damages our rebound from half back when the ball is given to him.

Averages 24m gained per touch.

Said it weeks ago, Laird and Milera on the HBF are a waste of time, and actually hurt the side.

Hinge has to do too much - sit on him and our drive from defense is non existent.

 

[Cromulant]

I'm more concerned that they will bring back Murphy. One of Nicks' go to players.

I wouldn't think so

 

[crows dude]

After today’s game nobody other than Draper and Berry deserve to come in.


So Draper from Sub to the 22.

Fogarty in for Keane

Butts in and Crouch out

Taylor sub

F. Fogarty Walker Rachele
Hf. Neale Bullen Thilthorpe Rankine
C. Cumming. Soligo. Peatling
Hb. Dawson. Murray Worrell
B. Laird. Butts Hinge
R. O’Brien Michalanney . Draper
I. Nankervis Keays Milera Curtin
S Taylor

 

[cleanhands]

Averages 24m gained per touch.

Said it weeks ago, Laird and Milera on the HBF are a waste of time, and actually hurt the side.

Hinge has to do too much - sit on him and our drive from defense is non existent.

Laird should be measured by cubic metres

 

[Cromulant]

After today’s game nobody other than Draper and Berry deserve to come in.


So Draper from Sub to the 22.

Fogarty in for Keane

Taylor sub

F. Fogarty Walker Rachele
Hf. Neale Bullen Thilthorpe Rankine
C. Cumming. Soligo. Peatling
Hb. Dawson. Worrell. Nankervis
B. Laird. Murray Hinge
R. O’Brien Michalanney . Draper
I. Crouch Keays Milera Curtin
S Taylor

We aren't going in with 1 KPD against Curnow and Mackay.

 

[Crow till I die]

Carlton looked red hot against a very good Geelong team

We are witnessing a carlton dynasty, rounds 5-7 2025

 

[maxlilly]

Hackervis has had a shot and he hasn't taken it.

I was wrong about him. Isn't AFL level.

I'm surprised by the amount of people who are jumping off Nankervis after just two games, wow

His kicking was poor on Friday but he does lots of good.
It looked like we tried to use him early in the game for his marking, but didn't quite pay off

He's a lot better than Sholl

 

[Cromulant]

I'm surprised by the amount of people who are jumping off Nankervis after just two games, wow

His kicking was poor on Friday but he does lots of good.
It looked like we tried to use him early in the game for his marking, but didn't quite pay off

He's a lot better than Sholl

I don't think he's a winger TBH

 

[hippyhippy]

Hackervis has had a shot and he hasn't taken it.

I was wrong about him. Isn't AFL level.

He hasn't played that many games and he's played wing which isn't he's normal position. Although his goal kicking needs lots of work. He could have scored 3 or 4 in 2 weeks.

 

[Cromulant]

He hasn't played that many games and he's played wing which isn't he's normal position. Although his goal kicking needs lots of work. He could have scored 3 or 4 in 2 weeks.

Very strange call on Nank really, people need to chill on the kid.

He's one of about 8 blokes playing out of position