List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion

[ESPN8 The Ocho]

What if the manager is just trying to get the SA clubs to put up more money ?

Occam’s Razor: what if his manager answered truthfully?

 

[The Punter]

As reported, NWM didn't meet with Adelaide or Port Adelaide when in Adelaide and essentially given permission to do so by Ross Lyon.

Actions (or lack of action) speak louder than words.

 

[Sab22]

If Tom****witMoris was so sure about Nas leaving. If he had proper intel on the situation. We would have seen 10 tweets, headlines on whatever shows he is hosting and I think multiple journos would have reported it by now.

he’s a certified bullshitter, he does get some occasionally right sometimes though by luck

 

[Sab22]

What gives me a lot of confidence is how well he is paying (sure you can say good form rewards more) but it’s the passion and intensity he shows when we are down or when he kicks a goal.

He was the only one who was trying even when we were 40 points down against brissy.

If he was split between us and going, I don’t know if we would see the same efforts and engagement he’s shown so far.

Kid loves the club, he’s very close with some of the players including windy, and I think we can expect him in the leadership group very soon. He’s growing as a leader of our club infront of our eyes. Club has some plans for our younger players to get more media exposure, to be more marketable and potentially individual sponsorships.

 

[akaifu]

What gives me a lot of confidence is how well he is paying (sure you can say good form rewards more) but it’s the passion and intensity he shows when we are down or when he kicks a goal.

He was the only one who was trying even when we were 40 points down against brissy.

If he was split between us and going, I don’t know if we would see the same efforts and engagement he’s shown so far.

Kid loves the club, he’s very close with some of the players including windy, and I think we can expect him in the leadership group very soon. He’s growing as a leader of our club infront of our eyes. Club has some plans for our younger players to get more media exposure, to be more marketable and potentially individual sponsorships.

Would be nice if he stays and is part of the leadership group next year

On top of a massive pay day, All-Australian blazer, and a BnF win

 

[Sab22]

Would be nice if he stays and is part of the leadership group next year

On top of a massive pay day, All-Australian blazer, and a BnF win

Happy to become a pilot, so i can take him back to adelaide whenever he wants if it meant he would stay with us

If i had to build a mansion and he relocate his family to Bayside, I would do that too. Just need our president to fund it!!!

 

[Ads734]

There is only one trade I see as acceptable

Naz - for butters.

Nothing more , nothing less.

SOS I don’t rate any of your recruiting or drafting but I think you are a bit of a Cee You Next Tuesday

 

[jumperfan]

Slightly off-topic but it really pisses me off how some AFL fans outside Victoria seem act with regards to the go-home factor. The anti-Victorian attitude gets very annoying, especially when they have no issue with players coming back to their state. I understand footy fans are a parochial bunch but I dunno, it just rubs me the wrong way.

 

[akaifu]

There is only one trade I see as acceptable

Naz - for butters.

Nothing more , nothing less.

SOS I don’t rate any of your recruiting or drafting but I think you are a bit of a Cee You Next Tuesday

Honestly with this midfield move Nas could overtake Butters in value. Almost 3 years younger

Would rather not think about trading him tho

 

[Mystifly]

Honestly with this midfield move Nas could overtake Butters in value. Almost 3 years younger

Would rather not think about trading him tho

I agree that Nasiah has the potential to be the best player in the league, but for the right now, it would have to be Butters or nothing. No way we take Bergman and scraps - unless we are squeezed hard.

 

[Ads734]

Honestly with this midfield move Nas could overtake Butters in value. Almost 3 years younger

Would rather not think about trading him tho

Agreed completely, however only IF Naz leaves, I will cry. I love him.

 

[Minga]

Tom ‘liquor license’ Morris

He’s not ‘asian, black, a woman or gay’ so we should treat him with respect everyone!

 

[70s sainter]

Imagine what you’d get for him if he was contracted. He’s improving week on week before our eyes .

 

[botts]

Imagine what you’d get for him if he was contracted. He’s improving week on week before our eyes .

Should tell him to sign a contract and if he wants to leave we will trade him in 12 months. But atleast get a kings ransom

 

[Diehard Saint]

As long as fair value or fairer value is paid it's not a problem to me.

Well that’s the whole point.
It hasn’t been.
Hopefully Bassat has continued with those discussions. Academy picks too.

 

[Diehard Saint]

Only person worth listening too is his manager & he indicated that Nas is happy & most likely staying from "Gettable" during gather round week.

We all better get
Religious or not!

 

[HeavenlySources]

Leek Aleer (GWS): “I think Leek Aleer goes. St Kilda is the front-runner there. He goes because the Giants just can’t match what he’s being offered elsewhere.”
James Worpel (Hawthorn): “I might be looking silly here but the way it’s looking at the moment he’s more likely to go. There’s some good offers out there for him. Melbourne and St Kilda really like him. The Hawks are happy to keep him, but probably aren’t willing to offer him the long-term deal as a free agent that he wants.”
Tom De Koning (Carlton): “It’s so much money to pass up. I think he’ll end up going but I say that through gritted teeth. That’s got all the hallmarks of a player that’s looking to go. The sort of cash that’s being offered by the Saints is very hard to say no to.”
Jimmy Webster (St Kilda): “Stays on a short-term deal. They like him.”

Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera (St Kilda): “We’ll know by halfway through the year. I think the family pull is so strong that it’s more likely he heads back to South Australia. But I’m not sure he’s even made his mind up yet. He’s very close to Jason Horne-Francis at Port Adelaide. Adelaide are heavily in for him. I’d be guessing between those two.”

Fold the club if Nas leaves

Stay or go? The trio of key Hawks yet to sign new deals

A comprehensive contract guide.

www.sen.com.au

There is only one trade I see as acceptable

Naz - for butters.

Nothing more , nothing less.

SOS I don’t rate any of your recruiting or drafting but I think you are a bit of a Cee You Next Tuesday

Nas out of contract, Butters isn’t unfortunately. Butters also hasn’t expressed interest in St Kilda, only Hawks and Bulldogs far as I’m aware

 

[borderbarry]

I really hope Nas stays. I cant remember a more promising player. Perhaps make him Deputy Vice Captain next season. hell, why wait do it now.

 

[Strahany]

Where is your tomato sauce!?

_Maximus_12 has been repeatedly adamant that Nas is staying, and repeatedly coy with his sauce.

I like to ignorantly (and wishfully) think that this means he is far too close to a strong source to be able to even hint at it, which would mean Nas is staying. I have no inside knowledge on this myself.

 

[topbillings]

If Nas leaves, it won't set the club back 5 years. I'm sure they'll be adequately compensated and he is just one player.

In saying that, Nas leaving will destroy the morale of an already battered and bruised supporter base. After Billings (instead of Bontempelli), McCartin (instead of Petracca) and now the ongoing King saga - we have been at the bottom of the ladder for 10+ years and seen no benefit from it. Nas is the first truly ELITE player we've had come through, from our last 10 years of drafting.

If he leaves...man. I won't stop supporting the club, but there'll be a sense of "what's the point??". My heart won't be in it for awhile, that's for sure.

 

[SaintlyHymns]

Nas won't leave. He can't.

My father and grandfather wouldn't have put me through supporting this club, to get the greatest thing to walk through our doors for 20 years, to up and leave after four because he misses family in ADELAIDE.

It won't happen.

 

[Jade Buddha]

Right so there’s our strategy. If you want midfield permanently NAS you need to sign on. Simple as that.

 

[gringo2011]

_Maximus_12 has been repeatedly adamant that Nas is staying, and repeatedly coy with his sauce.

I like to ignorantly (and wishfully) think that this means he is far too close to a strong source to be able to even hint at it, which would mean Nas is staying. I have no inside knowledge on this myself.

He's had a few posts suggesting so. Hopefully he's on the money.

 

[Saintsydney]

Leek Aleer (GWS): “I think Leek Aleer goes. St Kilda is the front-runner there. He goes because the Giants just can’t match what he’s being offered elsewhere.”
James Worpel (Hawthorn): “I might be looking silly here but the way it’s looking at the moment he’s more likely to go. There’s some good offers out there for him. Melbourne and St Kilda really like him. The Hawks are happy to keep him, but probably aren’t willing to offer him the long-term deal as a free agent that he wants.”
Tom De Koning (Carlton): “It’s so much money to pass up. I think he’ll end up going but I say that through gritted teeth. That’s got all the hallmarks of a player that’s looking to go. The sort of cash that’s being offered by the Saints is very hard to say no to.”
Jimmy Webster (St Kilda): “Stays on a short-term deal. They like him.”

Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera (St Kilda): “We’ll know by halfway through the year. I think the family pull is so strong that it’s more likely he heads back to South Australia. But I’m not sure he’s even made his mind up yet. He’s very close to Jason Horne-Francis at Port Adelaide. Adelaide are heavily in for him. I’d be guessing between those two.”

Fold the club if Nas leaves

Stay or go? The trio of key Hawks yet to sign new deals

A comprehensive contract guide.

www.sen.com.au

Leek Aleer (GWS): “I think Leek Aleer goes. St Kilda is the front-runner there. He goes because the Giants just can’t match what he’s being offered elsewhere.”
James Worpel (Hawthorn): “I might be looking silly here but the way it’s looking at the moment he’s more likely to go. There’s some good offers out there for him. Melbourne and St Kilda really like him. The Hawks are happy to keep him, but probably aren’t willing to offer him the long-term deal as a free agent that he wants.”
Tom De Koning (Carlton): “It’s so much money to pass up. I think he’ll end up going but I say that through gritted teeth. That’s got all the hallmarks of a player that’s looking to go. The sort of cash that’s being offered by the Saints is very hard to say no to.”
Jimmy Webster (St Kilda): “Stays on a short-term deal. They like him.”

Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera (St Kilda): “We’ll know by halfway through the year. I think the family pull is so strong that it’s more likely he heads back to South Australia. But I’m not sure he’s even made his mind up yet. He’s very close to Jason Horne-Francis at Port Adelaide. Adelaide are heavily in for him. I’d be guessing between those two.”

Fold the club if Nas leaves

Stay or go? The trio of key Hawks yet to sign new deals

A comprehensive contract guide.

www.sen.com.au

He’s going out on a massive limb if he’s putting his money on either Adelaide or Port if Naz goes back to SA - what a genius

 

[gringo2011]

If Nas leaves, it won't set the club back 5 years. I'm sure they'll be adequately compensated and he is just one player.

In saying that, Nas leaving will destroy the morale of an already battered and bruised supporter base. After Billings (instead of Bontempelli), McCartin (instead of Petracca) and now the ongoing King saga - we have been at the bottom of the ladder for 10+ years and seen no benefit from it. Nas is the first truly ELITE player we've had come through, from our last 10 years of drafting.

If he leaves...man. I won't stop supporting the club, but there'll be a sense of "what's the point??". My heart won't be in it for awhile, that's for sure.

We've ****ed up 99.9% of drafts picks since 2000 or something. He's our first absolute elite level player in so long it will be hard to keep giving a shit and even if we draft another elite player it will take 4 years to get back to where we are now.