Trades 2025 Round 11 Trades

[Scythe]

I did tell you I wanted Dawson last week because of his remaining fixture. He was excellent against the pies, I back him in.

I did warn you that I was giving that opinion with a heavy dose of bias, haha. Still like Dunkley as a pick, but yeah, didn't realise quite how good their run home was.

 

[SC fish]

Am leaning towards holding Macrae but turfing JHF for "value pick" Shai Bolton

10

Shai Bolton

Age

27

Ht

176cm

Wt

77kg

Pos.

M/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D

12.3

3star

K

6.9

3star

HB

5.4

4star

M

2.8

3star

T

2.9

4star

CL

1.4

4star

D

12.7

3star

K

9.2

4star

HB

3.5

2star

M

3.0

3star

T

2.7

4star

CL

1.8

4star

D

9.2

3star

K

4.6

2star

HB

4.6

4star

M

2.0

3star

T

2.6

4star

CL

0.0

1star

, leaving me loads of cash to get Bont in R13

 

[Scythe]

This is fantastic info and I love spreadsheets

Have you already got Bolton or is he not in consideration for you?

Cheers – I'm a researcher by trade, so I live in Excel haha.

I see the logic for some, but Bolton's not a consideration for me for a few reasons:

• I don't need another forward (unless Macrae becomes a LTI)
• He scored five in a full game of footy only 2-3 weeks ago and is generally too up and down for my liking
• Can't get another R13 bye player
• He cost me a shot at the $50k in 2021 and is even more of a 'never again' than Fraudson

 

[mochacinolatte]

Cheers – I'm a researcher by trade, so I live in Excel haha.

I see the logic for some, but Bolton's not a consideration for me for a few reasons:

• I don't need another forward (unless Macrae becomes a LTI)
• He scored five in a full game of footy only 2-3 weeks ago and is generally too up and down for my liking
• Can't get another R13 bye player
• He cost me a shot at the $50k in 2021 and is even more of a 'never again' than Fraudson

I could not stop laughing when my H2H matchup had Bolton that week.

 

[Northernsoul74]

No closer to deciding on a replacement for Finn (have a bunch of cash ITB so can afford literally anybody, but value is probably the best play with how bad cash gen is). Excuse my decision making table lol.

View attachment 2319986

I hate that Jordan ******* Fraudson is shaping up as potentially the best option for my team. Other main considerations are Heeney, Green and Dunkley. Opinions always welcome.

Thank you for doing all the work for me. My initial feeling was Tom Green so this helps my thinking.
LDU was my other consideration but can’t trade into a bye next week.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

No closer to deciding on a replacement for Finn (have a bunch of cash ITB so can afford literally anybody, but value is probably the best play with how bad cash gen is). Excuse my decision making table lol.

View attachment 2319986

I hate that Jordan ******* Fraudson is shaping up as potentially the best option for my team. Other main considerations are Heeney, Green and Dunkley. Opinions always welcome.

On Dawson he has eagles this week but could have 3 tags straight after with swans lions and hawks potentially

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Why would you bring in Merrett this week has a 200 breakeven and will lose 40k.

Will probably skip Zerrett if Macrae is only 1-2 weeker.

Yes he has a high breakeven but the 130+ points vs Tigs this weekend would be handy!

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Callaghan to Rowell is the moneyball move. Rowell is under priced, but I'm not sure I want to ride that rollercoaster again.

The cash he free's up would turn Carroll into Kiddy next week though

Wonder if Leake is in for Callaghan this week, would be a good downgrade target to play through the byes.

 

[54Dogs]

Callaghan to Rowell is the moneyball move. Rowell is under priced, but I'm not sure I want to ride that rollercoaster again.

The cash he free's up would turn Carroll into Kiddy next week though

Wonder if Leake is in for Callaghan this week, would be a good downgrade target to play through the byes.

yeah don't think I'd be going there with Rowell looking at who he has scored well against

 

[mochacinolatte]

On Dawson he has eagles this week but could have 3 tags straight after with swans lions and hawks potentially

He can do 180 against wce and plod along scoring 105 for the following 3 weeks then.

 

[54Dogs]

Doesnt Dawson have his 150 dropping off this week?

 

[Falchoon]

yeah don't think I'd be going there with Rowell looking at who he has scored well against

View attachment 2320024

Supercoach should have a floater where you can bring a player in for 1 round at a time, no trade penalty.

Target Rowell for round 21 and round 21 only.

 

[YeoGabbaGabba]

Doesnt Dawson have his 150 dropping off this week?

He does but he’s adding another 150 this week so don’t worry about that 115 BE

 

[LuvtheKangas]

In general, I'm not a very good forward planner in SC. I haven't really considered bye planning until recently (it will now impact my trade decisions this and next week).

I still have 21 trades and 3 boosts. One reason for this relative conservatism is that I want to be able to do 3 trades (including boost) in Round 24, i.e. SC Grand Final week. I plan to get extra GC and Essendon players, as they have two games that round. Does this strategy make sense?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

In general, I'm not a very good forward planner in SC. I haven't really considered bye planning until recently (it will now impact my trade decisions this and next week).

I still have 21 trades and 3 boosts. One reason for this relative conservatism is that I want to be able to do 3 trades (including boost) in Round 24, i.e. SC Grand Final week. I plan to get extra GC and Essendon players, as they have two games that round. Does this strategy make sense?

The Suns/Bombers extra game in round 24 won't count for SC scoring.

 

[mochacinolatte]

In general, I'm not a very good forward planner in SC. I haven't really considered bye planning until recently (it will now impact my trade decisions this and next week).

I still have 21 trades and 3 boosts. One reason for this relative conservatism is that I want to be able to do 3 trades (including boost) in Round 24, i.e. SC Grand Final week. I plan to get extra GC and Essendon players, as they have two games that round. Does this strategy make sense?

If you are purely playing for leagues. It is fine to tank a bye week to get the players you want than being stuck on an average pick.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

The Suns/Bombers extra game in round 24 won't count for SC scoring.

Thanks. I probably should have realised that given it's a Round 0 replacement.

 

[mochacinolatte]

The Suns/Bombers extra game in round 24 won't count for SC scoring.

Well **** me then, this is the first time I heard of this. Is there an article.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

If you are purely playing for leagues. It is fine to tank a bye week to get the players you want than being stuck on an average pick.

I see a lot of people say "I'm playing for leagues" and I always think, bugger that, I'm playing for the 50K. And I'm looking good for it this year, less than 20,000 places to make up at this point.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Well **** me then, this is the first time I heard of this. Is there an article.

TBH I haven't seen an article, I'm sure they said this on the official podcast though.

 

[Changa10]

Newcombe rolled his ankle then proceeded to have his most impactful period of game time after it.

Moon boot likely just precautionary. Fox Sports article even says 'not considered in doubt for this weekend'.

No moon boot at training yesterday, looking at the one photo of Newcombe on Insta from yesterday's training session.

 

[mochacinolatte]

No moon boot at training yesterday, looking at the one photo of Newcombe on Insta from yesterday's training session.

Did he wear a bullet proof vest?

 

[Pocket Aces]

No closer to deciding on a replacement for Finn (have a bunch of cash ITB so can afford literally anybody, but value is probably the best play with how bad cash gen is). Excuse my decision making table lol.

View attachment 2320039

I hate that Jordan ******* Fraudson is shaping up as potentially the best option for my team. Other main considerations are Heeney, Green and Dunkley. Opinions always welcome.

Great analysis, there is a mid averaging 118 under priced you could include too. Unless you have him already but he has a terrible bye for you.

Im grabbing Dawson, this is good confirmation.

 

[Bennellongtime]

Hewett to Simpson currently. Think that's all I'll do I should have cover for JHF and Macrae. Take 200k into next week and probably just grab kiddy and then focus on getting Zerrett and Bont after his bye. Then butters. All coming down in price so it's worked out perfectly.

 

[Pocket Aces]

Kosi Pickett is averaging 96 priced at 458K, much better pick than High-Five Bolton IMO. Bolton has an awful floor.

Not grabbing either but Pickett easily if I had to choose one.