Recommitted Miles Bergman [re-signed for 2 years]

[Juice030103]

Super reliable. Strong overhead. Strong tackler. Hard to tackle. Great breakaway speed. Can play multiple positions. Easily a top 10 pick.

I’d say more to be honest

guys a star

 

[boncer34]

Ed Richards vibes from this bloke.

Good comparison

 

[Scottish Bob]

Bergman to Victoria has all the hallmarks of the media going with ' Bulldogs in the hunt for Port young gun' but ending up 'Hawks secure Miles Bergman on multi year deal'

Put your house on it.

 

[Vindicater]

Bergman to Victoria has all the hallmarks of the media going with ' Bulldogs in the hunt for Port young gun' but ending up 'Hawks secure Miles Bergman on multi year deal'

Put your house on it.

He would fit that Hawthorn midfield perfectly.

 

[Vic_Vinegar]

If his kicking was better Port could absolutely command a top 10 pick, saw 4 kicks that, although hit targets, were horrendous. (3 were kicks over a defender that dribbled to a team mate)

Id offer up a pick in the teens for him but even then, Essendon have enough shit kicks

You are entitled to your opinions as we all are but he was pick 14 in his draft year and has only increased in value.

 

[Yoda_]

You are entitled to your opinions as we all are but he was pick 14 in his draft year and has only increased in value.

thats ok, thank you for a decent reply

 

[Milanista28]

Say we were interested, would something like pick 5 for Bergman and Ports F1st be ballpark?

 

[Vindicater]

Say we were interested, would something like pick 5 for Bergman and Ports F1st be ballpark?

Pick 5 would be the starting point from Port.

Would probably end up as pick 5 plus some later swaps in our favour.

Pick 5 and a future 4th for Bergman and a future 3rd sort of stuff.

I would do the worse of our two first rounders for him straight up though.

 

[tiger_tough]

Ed Richards vibes from this bloke.

More Jordan Dawson IMO

 

[THE_GUN]

Pick 5 would be the starting point from Port.

Would probably end up as pick 5 plus some later swaps in our favour.

Pick 5 and a future 4th for Bergman and a future 3rd sort of stuff.

I would do the worse of our two first rounders for him straight up though.

If you get Bergman for pick #5 you take that

 

[HugeJohnson]

Say we were interested, would something like pick 5 for Bergman and Ports F1st be ballpark?

Hahahaha, our future 1st could easily be a top 5 pick, especially if we lose Bergman it doesn't exactly help our cause. You'd basically be getting him for free

 

[Revan11]

But ain't no Rankine who was traded for pick 5.

At the time Rankine was traded he didn’t have many runs on the board. Held his value on potential and being a top 3 pick originally

 

[ABAB]

At the time Rankine was traded he didn’t have many runs on the board. Held his value on potential and being a top 3 pick originally

I mean, his second half.......

 

[Young Gun #6]

I mean, his second half.......
View attachment 2353696

Is 10-14 touches, 1-3 goals, 2-3 tackles, 2-3 marks and zero signs of playing any midfield supposed to be top 5-10 pick worthy there? And that was his BEST patch of footy.

 

[ABAB]

Is 10-14 touches, 1-3 goals, 2-3 tackles, 2-3 marks and zero signs of playing any midfield supposed to be top 5-10 pick worthy there? And that was his BEST patch of footy.

Rankine was ranked the most influential small forward in the 2nd half before requesting a trade to us. Drew said he was training as a midfielder and the plan was to transition him but he got injured early in the year and now has shown he can play midfield at the elite level. I initially thought we did overpay for him and he was around pick 10.

 

[Milanista28]

Say we were interested, would something like pick 5 for Bergman and Ports F1st be ballpark?

Geez what an idiot lmao.

I need to watch him more, I assumed his trade value was later 1st round and I thought Port would bounce back in 26.

Seems we have fans that would offer one of our top 10s, so we'd be chance if he was to choose us.

 

[tigs2010]

Say we were interested, would something like pick 5 for Bergman and Ports F1st be ballpark?

 

[Traveling_Power]

If you get Bergman for pick #5 you take that

No, we wouldn't

because pick 5 using the new draft value index is equal to the 2024 pick 6
then take into account the blow out of FS & NGA and academies picks this could push that pick out a lot more.

with the new draft value index coming into play at the end of the year - all players are now worth more.

 

[Del216647]

This guy is a very good player. I'm not sure why people underrate him.

 

[Traveling_Power]

This guy is a very good player. I'm not sure why people underrate him.

As St Kilda's Leigh Montagna recently (Jun25) told Fox Footy’s First Crack.
“I think he’s showing more and more that he’s more than capable of being a midfielder.” Bergman has been compared to Adelaide captain Jordan Dawson in recent weeks.
Not only are they very similar players, both are on a similar career trajectory.
Dawson was at the Swans where he played primarily as a defender, before transitioning into a more midfield.
He is so much more than a talented half back flanker. He is a high talent.”



Since he has moved to the midfield Bergman has
beaten Jordan Dawson, keeping him to 14 disposals while having 23 disposals himself
ran with Christian Petracca keeping him to 17 disposals while having 22 disposals himself
ran with Patrick Cripps keeping him to 17 disposals while having 25 disposals himself

 

[Vic_Vinegar]

I mean, his second half.......
View attachment 2353696

Please, I’m begging you, stop stinking up every thread you post in.

 

[ABAB]

Please, I’m begging you, stop stinking up every thread you post in.

What are you talking about? I was replying to an incorrect post who replied to my post.

 

[ABAB]

No, we wouldn't

because pick 5 using the new draft value index is equal to the 2024 pick 6
then take into account the blow out of FS & NGA and academies picks this could push that pick out a lot more.

with the new draft value index coming into play at the end of the year - all players are now worth more.

Using draft value index as an argument when they only apply to bid points......

 

[THE_GUN]

No, we wouldn't

because pick 5 using the new draft value index is equal to the 2024 pick 6
then take into account the blow out of FS & NGA and academies picks this could push that pick out a lot more.

with the new draft value index coming into play at the end of the year - all players are now worth more.

This is the houston argument all over again
Port will take pick #5 and move on

 

[Traveling_Power]

This is the houston argument all over again
Port will take pick #5 and move on

No, it isn't ...

the extra year of draft picks and the draft picks being reduced makes it different