Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion AFL 2025 Round 19 - Weekend Wrap & Liked, Learnt, Hated

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Let’s call Round 19 Statement Round. Hard to remember a round where so many contenders put their claims forward! Let’s wrap it up…

Bombers v Giants, Thursday night: What on earth is the point of a floating fixture if THIS is the best they can come up with for a Thursday night? Meanwhile genuine top 8 encounters get shunted off to the Sunday twilight timeslots. What a marvelous administration we have. Anyway, the Bombers cost themselves any remote chance of an upset by starting this one with 8 consecutive behinds. The Giants on the other hand have hit the ground running after their bye with three straight wins. Massive derby in Sydney next week against a resurgent Swans outfit.

Lions v Dogs, Friday night: All the discussion out of this will be that the Doggies failed to beat a top 8 opponent again. I’m going to take a slightly different angle and declare that the Lions are the best team going round. If I had to pick one side I don’t want to play in September it ain’t Collingwood, it’s Brisbane (although the Crows are closing quickly). Their midfield is crazy good and bats deeper than anybody. They can win games in a withering burst or they can win in a slog like they did in this one. Fair play to the Bulldogs for nearly pinching it from them late.

1753003024978.jpeg

Hawks v Port, Saturday arvo: In pristine Tassie conditions with no roof in sight, the Hawks brushed Port aside and put forward their own claims to be in the premiership discussion. Port were actually hanging with them until three quarter time but Hawthorn had an extra gear and a howling gale in the final term which saw them boot clear. Nice goal late in the game from the aeroplane Jack Ginnivan, and to be fair it was a classy chuckling response from Ken too.

Isaac Heeney v North, Saturday twilight: North were actually the better team all day against 21 Sydney players plus the sub. The trouble was the 22nd player turned up in runaway freight train mode and simply couldn’t be stopped. Seriously what on earth was that?? You only rack up 13 clearances, five goals and a million possessions if you’re playing in the under 9s and you’re the only kid who’s lucky enough to have had a growth spurt. But in the AFL? Does not happen.

Blues v Demons, Saturday night: Finally some respite for long suffering Blues fans. Yes it was close, yes it was ugly, but I reckon the folks that braved a miserable winter’s night would have been glad just to sing the song and see some positive signs from a few of the kids. Pretty ordinary stuff from the Dees all night but Kozzy Pickett’s game was a highlight.

Eagles v Tigers, Saturday night: Not much to be said about the turnover merchants in West Coast, so how about we raise a glass to the victors who weren’t supposed to win a game all year? They’ve now won five. Still got a chance to win one or two more in the run home too. Their youngsters have really shown something, and their veterans have done very well to hold the show together. Oh and Maurice Rioli? Rundown tackle of the century!

1753003123820.jpeg

Cats v Saints, Sunday arvo: Bear in mind that the Saints usually beat the Cats for fun, so this wasn’t the lay-down misere that it looked on paper. Geelong led all afternoon though, and even though the Saints drew close here and there, they never really looked likely to threaten.

Pies v Dockers, Sunday arvo: WOW. These two played out a Sunday afternoon gem! Just as the Pies looked like they were starting to run away with it early in the final term, the Dockers found something and pulled off a famous win!! This is a much steelier Fremantle outfit than some of their teams of the past. That win puts them equal fourth with a world of possibility in front of them now.

Crows v Suns, Sunday twilight: That is a big time statement from the Crows. The Suns turned up having claimed a big scalp last week, but the home side casually (yet brutally) cast them aside. There were eleven Adelaide goals on the board before Gold Coast kicked one of their own… and that wasn’t until the third quarter! Crazy. Form team of the comp alongside the Lions.


Don’t forget to post your Liked, Learnt, Hated below… along with any other thoughts you had about Round 19!
 
Liked : Upset - Freo away from home

Learnt - …

Hated - continuance of the need to call a review every time the ball crosses the point line
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Liked:

Facing a tough opponent and the cyclonic conditions of the weather.... the Hawks stood tall and won by a huge margin. The march to the 2025 premiership cup continues

Learnt & hated:

Watching the VFL coverage on Saturday night I saw the Geelong VFL team frequently AGGRESSIVELY appeal for free kicks whenever the ball fell out of bounds. It's seriously at epidemic levels right now - far worse than the Bulldogs throwing the ball like they're playing rugby. The AFL should grow some balls and stamp it out. Wouldn't be surprised if the Geelong VFLW/AFLW teams do it as well.


Also hated: Wayne Carey - what a dispicible campaigner.
 
Liked: Freo when they decided to try and win the game and not try and stay in the game..there's a premiership to be won...go and win it. Jack Gunstan...he and Calsher Dear work very well together.

Learnt: Umpiring is getting worse every week...can just see the GF decided by a "50 for dissent". Melbourne should've paid anything to keep luke Jackson.

Hated: Essendon on prime time...seriously..
 
Liked: Beating one of our "bogey" teams and the Dockers winning.

Learnt: The Crows could play off, they are definitely good enough

Hated: No home strip for a home game and 50 metres for pointing the finger at the scoreboard...what madness is this?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Learnt & hated:

Watching the VFL coverage on Saturday night I saw the Geelong VFL team frequently AGGRESSIVELY appeal for free kicks whenever the ball fell out of bounds. It's seriously at epidemic levels right now - far worse than the Bulldogs throwing the ball like they're playing rugby. The AFL should grow some balls and stamp it out. Wouldn't be surprised if the Geelong VFLW/AFLW teams do it as well.

Geelong and Collingwood, maybe most teams by now. Keep asking the question, we know the brain capacity of the rainbow grubs.
Liked. Commentators, u can turn the volume down.

Learnt. Commentators, just go with the flow of the shite decisions the umpires dish up. lets not upset anyone, well let's not have commentators.

Hated. The draw for certain teams.
 
liked: Tigers 3rd quarter, Freo getting up, Swann in the Lions song, Heeney, Liam Ryan goal, McClug milestone win (+ NRL had a couple exciting finishes)

learned: Saints play Melb-Norf-Rich-Ess in the next few weeks, if they fumble a few of those they risk 17th. none of the bottom teams are winning final round, but penultimate round also has North v Rich. All before and behind them for the Saints, will shape the bottom six, but no grinching this year

hated: Eagles third quarter, that endless behind review in the Lions game
 
Last edited:
Liked: Geelong back on the winners list, though it was a pretty underwhelming performance. Top four and even top two within reach, with a favourable run home, compared to relatively brutal home stretches for Collingwood and Brisbane.

Similar story for the Crows: in their hands now. If they can take care of business at home against Hawthorn and Collingwood, they're a chance for top 2.

Learnt: Turning into another very even season. Minor premier could end up with six losses, 16-7 should be fine for top four.

Hated: I don't normally care about this stuff, but THREE more Friday night games for Essendon after last Thursday's snore fest? Could even be four, with the make-up game against Gold Coast, depending on what the AFL plans to do there?

And yes Maynard deserves to be cited for the dangerous shove on Reid and Moore deserves a holiday for his dirty knee drop into Treacy's back in the closing seconds. Doubt either will happen though.
 
Liked: the crows getting the job done.
The top 2 being wide open with Collingwood v Brisbane and crows v Collingwood games to come.

Learnt: tassie definitely needs a roof.

Hated: the 50s in the crows suns game, just get rid of the stand and sub rule.
 
Hated - That throwing is so poorly policed

Been slipping for years

Ball is "handballed" over your head, should be automatically called as a throw.

Sick to death of players appealing for kicks, waving their arms around like a flock of seagulls. Alot are appealing whilst the play is still going on, arms should be down hunting the ball.
 
Liked: Freo holding on against the odds

Learnt: Crows are serious contenders for the flag

Hated: Umpiring is deplorable and obviously getting worse by the round; these clowns are ruining the sport!

Your like is back to front, should be "Collingwood fold against the odds".
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Ball is "handballed" over your head, should be automatically called as a throw.

Sick to death of players appealing for kicks, waving their arms around like a flock of seagulls. Alot are appealing whilst the play is still going on, arms should be down hunting the ball.
Why, it’s easy to handball over your head?
 
liked- * Richmond putting on a great display for its fans.
  • freo and the 1 point win
  • jnr Rioli and the chase down tackle- awesome

learnt- Adelaide are primed for a big charge for the flag

hated- umpiring in the coll v freo - some crazy calls
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion AFL 2025 Round 19 - Weekend Wrap & Liked, Learnt, Hated

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top