Carlton a flag chance in 2026.

[YeoShuey]

And making more shit up.

Actually quoting things that I never said, and ignoring the many accurate comments that have been made (Sidebottom > Acres, for example).

What a desperate, desperate lying individual.

But regardless...

E. Hollands really has been great this year, hasn't he?

And who's had a better season - Walsh or Long.

You are embarrassing yourself. But that's not unusual.

Do you still think Cox is a better player than Walsh?

 

[Fadge]

Perpetual January premiers. Been hearing the same crap year after year going back nearly a decade to every trade period SOS apparently won and Carlton were on the brink. Bar one season it never materialised.

We're getting closer and closer to October, qand we're already starting to hear the same deluded drivel we hear every off season.

Bless them.

 

[Fadge]

Do you still think Cox is a better player than Walsh?

Again, feel free to share where that comment was made.

Desperate liars.

 

[carlton_99]

Actually quoting things that I never said, and ignoring the many accurate comments that have been made (Sidebottom > Acres, for example).

Nobody argued Acres is a better player than Sidebottom based on overall careers. That would be ridiculous. It was a topic about their form in 2023 and 2024 alone.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

And making more shit up.

Actually quoting things that I never said, and ignoring the many accurate comments that have been made (Sidebottom > Acres, for example).

What a desperate, desperate lying individual.

But regardless...

E. Hollands really has been great this year, hasn't he?

And who's had a better season - Walsh or Long.

You are embarrassing yourself. But that's not unusual.

Which ones are false just for the record?

Also Walsh has been injured half the season if you weren't aware... But even still given just about every Pies fan on here has been begging him to get dropped the last month because he's reverted to being an absolute hack I'd still say have to say Walsh.

 

[Fadge]

Here you go

EXHIBIT A

Context, is important.

 

[Fadge]

Nobody argued Acres is a better player than Sidebottom based on overall careers. That would be ridiculous. It was a topic about their form in 2023 and 2024 alone.

The conversation was actually about who would be the better player in 2025, and you fools used your perception that Acres had been better in 2023/24 to influence that decision.

What absolute fools.

 

[hawkman]

Why do you have to spoil the fun with reality?

I did also forget about the total lack of depth.

If they fix some of those issues, sure they may be able to scrape into 10th spot

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Again, feel free to share where that comment was made.

Desperate liars.

 

[carlton_99]

The conversation was actually about who would be the better player in 2025, and you fools used your perception that Acres had been better in 2023/24 to influence that decision.

What absolute fools.

Ah yes how crazy to use the form of the players in the most recent seasons to make a decision about who was currently playing the better footy.

 

[Fadge]

I did also forget about the total lack of depth.

If they fix some of those issues, sure they may be able to scrape into 10th spot

Surely the fool when writing out his best team for 2026, realising at least two of them already have a foot out the door, and another half dozen wouldn't get a game in a finals team, would have had an 'Oh shit' moment?

But no....

 

[Fadge]

View attachment 2391882

Perfect.

So the comment was about 'Career Output'?

 

[Fadge]

Ah yes how crazy to use the form of the players in the most recent seasons to make a decision about who was currently playing the better footy.

Despite being told you were kidding yourselves with your view that Acres had in fact been better than Sidebottom.

 

[carlton_99]

Perfect.

So the comment was about 'Career Output'?

It was about better players. Walsh's first season was enough to go past Cox as a player.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Perfect.

So the comment was about 'Career Output'?

Were you referring to Cox and Walsh's 2024 output or something?

Walsh passed Cox on career output the second he stepped on a footy field

 

[Fadge]

It was about better players. Walsh's first season was enough to go past Cox as a player.

No, it was about Career Output, as per the screenshot.

And typical of you to think that a player's first season was enough to go past a player who had significantly influenced finals games, and also been a key component of a premiership squad...

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Hollands is ordinary. He shirks contests all too often.
Silvagni is an average footballer and always will be.

Moore v Weitering is a very good comparison. You would have to give the nod to Moore based on what he has achieved so far in his career with the finals performances and 2 x All Australians.

Please give me the contact of your acid dealer

 

[Fadge]

Hollands is ordinary. He shirks contests all too often.
Silvagni is an average footballer and always will be.

Moore v Weitering is a very good comparison. You would have to give the nod to Moore based on what he has achieved so far in his career with the finals performances and 2 x All Australians.

And just think....

They're the made up comments and comparisons they're flexing about...

 

[YeoShuey]

Despite being told you were kidding yourselves with your view that Acres had in fact been better than Sidebottom.

The claim is that Acres was a better player than Sidebottom in 2023 and 2024.

Go on Wheelo, have a look at the stats for those years (which you must because I have no doubt you didn't watch an Acres match in those years), do a player compare, and disprove the claim. You can't because it is true.

 

[Fadge]

The claim is that Acres was a better player than Sidebottom in 2023 and 2024.

Go on Wheelo, have a look at the stats for those years (which you must because I have no doubt you didn't watch an Acres match in those years), do a player compare, and disprove the claim. You can't because it is true.

Oh no.

PlAyEr RaTiNgZ

 

[carlton_99]

Care to elaborate on why you disagree with my opinion?



Here comes Walshy's mates to chirp in.

You watch them go silent in the years ahead when these posts are bumped.

"Silent" and yet here we all are despite the team performing poorly.

 

[YeoShuey]

Oh no.

PlAyEr RaTiNgZ

How about coaches votes? Acres wins there too.

You're not helping your cause.

 

[T2B_]

Thread is already wrecked by Collingwood trolls. If only there was a banter thread somewhere...

As for the OP, while I guess anything is possible, we'd need to see some more signs of improvement to even be confident of making finals in 2026.

Lot of water to go under that bridge. What we do in trade period, drafting, cleaning out and rejuvenating our assistant coaching staff etc will either make or break us.

 

[YeoShuey]

Hollands is ordinary. He shirks contests all too often.
Silvagni is an average footballer and always will be.

Moore v Weitering is a very good comparison. You would have to give the nod to Moore based on what he has achieved so far in his career with the finals performances and 2 x All Australians.

"average footballer" Silvagni getting interest from Collingwood, Essendon, and the Western Bulldogs as a free agent. Yeah nah.

 

[carlton_99]

Well if you only ever posted when your team was performing well, you'd never post....

So you disagree with the post I replied to? Cool we agree