Josh Carr's Ruthless Port Adelaide

[Scodges]

Melbourne sacked Choco Williams

Come home choco

 

[gbear]

Choco's no Matthew Lobbe, Cam Sutcliffe or Jason Williams.

Even better. Sign him up by Friday!

 

[gbear]

Could only imagine how good a player like JHF could be with some Choco coaching.

He's as good as he is so far with being coached from South Adelaide, North Melbourne and Daddy Donuts - its a serious credit to Flash he even gets a game with that line up.

Butters would thrive under him also. Would love to see what he could do with Whitlock, Ramm, Lorenz, Jackson and others. Him coaching the next generation of Burgoyne's, Rodan's and Salopek's would be great too!

 

[Scholz Supremacy]

His time may have been up after 119, but enough water has gone under the bridge after 15 years.

You’d definitely take his attitude over that of a hillbilly, handbagger blow-in from Geelong’s.

 

[Chewy316]

I would love to have Choco back in a developmental role helping develop the young players' foot and hand skills.

Pretty damn certain though that Carr doesn't want him back.

 

[the_inknkwn]

Chocco has been given the arse by Melbourne. Do we dare approach him?

No way will Koch want this....Chocco isn't a yes man

 

[Rigs]

I would love to have Choco back in a developmental role helping develop the young players' foot and hand skills.

Pretty damn certain though that Carr doesn't want him back.

Oh?

 

[gbear]

His time may have been up after 119, but enough water has gone under the bridge after 15 years.

You’d definitely take his attitude over that of a hillbilly, handbagger blow-in from Geelong’s.

He would definitely be able to change the culture around quickly and he also understands the importance of the club's members.

 

[malcheski]

I would love to have Choco back in a developmental role helping develop the young players' foot and hand skills.

Pretty damn certain though that Carr doesn't want him back.

Why do you have to ruin everything?

 

[gbear]

I would love to have Choco back in a developmental role helping develop the young players' foot and hand skills.

Pretty damn certain though that Carr doesn't want him back.

Really? I was under the impression they have a pretty good relationship.

 

[Portwrld]

His time may have been up after 119, but enough water has gone under the bridge after 15 years.

You’d definitely take his attitude over that of a hillbilly, handbagger blow-in from Geelong’s.

He needs to come in and disinfect the joint, so it gives more time for Josh to focus on the gameplan.

 

[Chewy316]

Why do you have to ruin everything?

Don't shoot me I'm just the messenger.

Really? I was under the impression they have a pretty good relationship.

I don't think their relationship is the problem. Just don't think he's what Carr wants in the footy program right now.

 

[gbear]

No way will Koch want this....Chocco isn't a yes man

I am hoping for the life of merme that Josh isn't a yes man either :-(

 

[It Just Is]

Chocco has been given the arse by Melbourne. Do we dare approach him?

Even if it’s just to run a skills session or two he would definitely have something to add to a coaching group that includes Lobbe, Hartlett, Sutcliffe and Atkins.

 

[gbear]

Don't shoot me I'm just the messenger.



I don't think their relationship is the problem. Just don't think he's what Carr wants in the footy program right now.

Fair enough, however I am hoping he has a coach in mind that will help change the culture and help develop our younger players, as the current system has failed at both.

 

[Powerade 08]

Chocos price tag is 400k.

 

[Portwrld]

I would love to have Choco back in a developmental role helping develop the young players' foot and hand skills.

Pretty damn certain though that Carr doesn't want him back.

Why Chewy? Do you have any intel on that?

I think Choc would be perfect for our list development, as you’ve also mentioned. When we go back in two years for NWM, he can give him the same treatment he did with Dusty.

 

[Chewy316]

Fair enough, however I am hoping he has a coach in mind that will help change the culture and help develop our younger players, as the current system has failed at both.

Well the first thing they'll be doing under Carr is getting rid of Holly Ransom running the men's leadership program.

Unless they replace her with another corporate with zero real life experience rainbow flag waiving wannabe, it'll be a huge upgrade irrespective of who gets that job.

 

[PearLover5]

This year feels like such a going through the motions year already. We all hope that next year Josh remodels the club in his own (and the club traditional) image.

If he does who will need to go, who will need to lift and who do we think will thrive.

For mine.

GO

Burton
Finlayson
Atkins

C Cornes
Sutcliffe
Hartlett
Hinkley


LIFT

Rozee (needs to lift to remain captain)
Sinn
Soldo
BZT
Lukoscious (harsh as he hasn't even played a proper game yet)

THRIVE

JHF (could be captain next year)
Butters
Lord
SPP
Burgoyne
Evans
Sweet
Jones
Visintini
Walsh

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

On a different topic, looking back on this list from Feb is quite depressing.
Nobody in the LIFT category lifted this year (I’d make a case Rozee was pretty good pre-injury, however).
Almost everyone in the THRIVE category took a step backwards, bar our rucks and Butters.
And the GO category delistings should have happened at the start of the year.

 

[Chewy316]

Why Chewy? Do you have any intel on that?

I think Choc would be perfect for our list development, as you’ve also mentioned. When we go back in two years for NWM, he can give him the same treatment he did with Dusty.

Just don't think he's the fit Carr is looking for.

 

[gbear]

Well the first thing they'll be doing under Carr is getting rid of Holly Ransom running the men's leadership program.

Unless they replace her with another corporate with zero real life experience rainbow flag waiving wannabe, it'll be a huge upgrade irrespective of who gets that job.

Any chance they get rid of Ransom all together? Her appointment to the board never made any sense, when there are far more qualified female candidates available even within Adelaide. I was also dumbfounded by Nagel's appointment tbh, as Adelaide health circles are very small and well I had some dealings with her in the covid period.

 

[RossFC]

Chocos price tag is 400k.

Is that all? We paid Hinkley 900k.

 

[SonOfKek]

Chocos price tag is 400k.

Still a good deal

 

[Chewy316]

Any chance they get rid of Ransom all together? Her appointment to the board never made any sense, when there are far more qualified female candidates available even within Adelaide. I was also dumbfounded by Nagel's appointment tbh, as Adelaide health circles are very small and well I had some dealings with her in the covid period.

Whilst Holly has her long nose stuck up Koch's arse, she will be going no where (unfortunately).

Her passion in terms of Board stuff is in women's footy. Probably connects well with the players there too given her background .

She should not be involved in any part of the men's program going forward.

 

[gbear]

Whilst Holly has her long nose stuck up Koch's arse, she will be going no where (unfortunately).

Her passion in terms of Board stuff is in women's footy. Probably connects well with the players there too given her background .

She should not be involved in any part of the men's program going forward.

Shame we can't get rid of Koch, as a lot of current problems stem from his ineptitude.