Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Izak Rankine Part II

Do you think the 4 week suspension handed to Rankine is reasonable?

  • Yes

  • No - too harsh

  • No - not harsh enough


Results are only viewable after voting.

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

After watching the first two games, I am not convinced having Rankine would have changed the results. We were never in it, we never matched the intensity or pressure. Our skills were shit all over the park and the coaching and game plan was so sub par. His loss didnt help but we had lost both games before the game started.
 
After watching the first two games, I am not convinced having Rankine would have changed the results. We were never in it, we never matched the intensity or pressure. Our skills were shit all over the park and the coaching and game plan was so sub par. His loss didnt help but we had lost both games before the game started.
Thats a fair assessment really, but it wouldn't have hurt
 
Not just missing izak but all the bullshit media pile on that followed killed our focus and we looked spooked no end from that point. Even having to have multiple people commenting on the booing of last week (and then having that critiqued ad nauseam) was just more distraction and forced repeantant defensive whackamole. Its been a shit show from the moment it was eluded to on the Sunday night after the original pies game.
 
Not just missing izak but all the bullshit media pile on that followed killed our focus and we looked spooked no end from that point. Even having to have multiple people commenting on the booing of last week (and then having that critiqued ad nauseam) was just more distraction and forced repeantant defensive whackamole. Its been a shit show from the moment it was eluded to on the Sunday night after the original pies game.

Talking to a Collingwood supporting work colleague just today - I said I don't think Rankine would have made much difference in either final but he said the whole thing was a complete deflater on finishing top - felt sorry for us and reckons it was a stitch up

Need to be more resilient though and need a top line mid - (Noah Anderson would be nice about now, eh?)
 
Talking to a Collingwood supporting work colleague just today - I said I don't think Rankine would have made much difference in either final but he said the whole thing was a complete deflater on finishing top - felt sorry for us and reckons it was a stitch up

Need to be more resilient though and need a top line mid - (Noah Anderson would be nice about now, eh?)
Dead set stitch up

McRae is campaigner. Everyone thinks he's warm and fuzzy, he's a ruthless campaigner

He will go to any length to get an advantage, as will many others in league
 

Remove this Banner Ad

The fact the Rankine suspension and subsequent "villains of the league" narrative derailed the playing group says more about how mentally weak we are than the on-field impact of Rankine.
I dont think it derailed us at all, we just simply didnt have the extra gear our opponents did..... or the coaching nous.
 
I dont think it derailed us at all, we just simply didnt have the extra gear our opponents did..... or the coaching nous.

0 - 4 with both teams (SANFL and AFL) going out in straight sets isn’t a great look.

It does ask the question about the right preparation during that period
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

0 - 4 with both teams (SANFL and AFL) going out in straight sets isn’t a great look.

It does ask the question about the right preparation during that period
Not really

The SANFL side played well against Glenelg and gone boned towards the end, didnt play well last week granted.

Squad goes down with flu, you'd imagine it affected some of the SANFL players as well.

To me it goes further back than the Rankine stuff. We cooked our players by not rotating and managing more players.
 
Not really

The SANFL side played well against Glenelg and gone boned towards the end, didnt play well last week granted.

Squad goes down with flu, you'd imagine it affected some of the SANFL players as well.

To me it goes further back than the Rankine stuff. We cooked our players by not rotating and managing more players.

Fair enough and happy with that explanation.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Izak Rankine Part II

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top