List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft - Top 10 Candidates

[Calcium Man]

Pretty farkin good floor

Yeah he’s great. Just the question is do we need another to add to brown/banks/trainor.

He’s not my first choice behind Robey but it’s close.

 

[Calcium Man]

Also all you campaigners wowing my Twomey draft ranking post

Turmoil
Stylo
tiger_tough
Infamy
Mr Unbelievable

I’ve been telling you campaigners for weeks he’s a top 3 pick so stopping being surprised!!

 

[RobsJourney]

Do we know if we're keen on Robey? Man I'd hope so.

 

[DontArgue4]

I dont know what it is but Duursma just screams bust to me

Just the way he looks

Also he is a Duursma

 

[Cherki]

Think we would be ok. He has him at 3 because he thinks Richmond is the keen one.

Seen a few on here the last month or so say we are very keen on XT.

If WC don't go CDT you'd think it will be Sharp who I've said for months I think Richmond would pass on.

Dees

 

[Morro]

If GC get Uwland, Patterson and Robey I’m going to belt Morro

 

[Aido97]

what is a better outcome for Richmond one of Grlj/Cumming/XTaylor/Greaves or Oskar Taylor and NHH?

*we have already selected Robey

Surely all of Sharp, Duursma and CDT are clearly ahead of O Taylor and NHH

 

[RichoLedio]

The way things are going this will be you after draft day

 

[Morro]

The way things are going this will be you after draft day


View attachment 2436115

Yeah the enthusiasm to punch me in the ring is quite concerning.

 

[DontArgue4]

Morro disliking my post about duursma because he is a duursma

has anyone seen him in the same room as Xavier?

Didnt think so

 

[Morro]

Morro disliking my post about duursma because he is a duursma

has anyone seen him in the same room as Xavier?

Didnt think so

Haha it was the opinion he will/could be a bust. He can literally play anywhere to a super high level, even if he fails as a mid, could end up a very good HB or HF. He cant fail to make it.

 

[SumTingWong]

Who is the player we think we'll miss out on that would then cause us to split the pick?

No idea

 

[captain cotch 9]

Morro disliking my post about duursma because he is a duursma

has anyone seen him in the same room as Xavier?

Didnt think so

I can confirm i've seen him practicing at the archery range.

 

[Morro]

I can confirm i've seen him practicing at the archery range.

 

[DontArgue4]

Haha it was the opinion he will/could be a bust. He can literally play anywhere to a super high level, even if he fails as a mid, could end up a very good HB or HF. He cant fail to make it.

a bloke who looks like this aint becoming elite, i dont know what it is but im never wrong on this

 

[SumTingWong]

Who is the player we think we'll miss out on that would then cause us to split the pick?

But sounds like we have a definite top 3

 

[ShereKhan]

Couldn't agree more we have clearly the worst midfield in the comp and only Lalor and Hotton in behind, that we could have any confidence in becoming decent players, and they both look like they might be more value forward. Mids and Mids please. I think they club will go this way as Yze mentioned in recent interview we were stocked for KP players and were looking to draft this year to compliment the players we took last year.

I'd go Sharp and Robey if we get that option we can try and trade in outside run like Hawks did.

Prestia will retire end of next year and we need to shift Hopper off for whatever we can get. Taranto is good and plays multiple positions.

Did you not watch 20yo McCauliffe this year? He was fantastic for a second year, 10-game player. And we have Smillie....he was top-6 in the strongest draft we've ever seen, so why not have any confidence in him? Why would you have more confidence in mids we will get in the 2025 draft over Smillie?

If we get Robey then I think Sharp simply gives us too many 'hulking' mids, given TT and Hopper have at least 4-years left each. TT, Hopper, McCauliffe, Smillie, Lalor, Robey and Sharp feels like at least 1 x 'big-bodied' mid too many, and probably two. We saw how that can badly affect team balance with Port having to play Ollie Wines and Willem Drew out of position.

For this reason I'd take Robey as I feel he has the tools to play wing which is a list need, ala Jarrod Berry / Hugh McLuggage. Obviously Lalor and Hotton can play mid/fwd. But if we take Robey I'd then take X Taylor as with Broad, Vlastiun and Short near the end he fills a list need beautifully and seems like 'next best' anyway.

 

[captain cotch 9]

Did you not watch 20yo McCauliffe this year? He was fantastic for a second year, 10-game player. And we have Smillie....he was top-6 in the strongest draft we've ever seen, so why not have any confidence in him? Why would you have more confidence in mids we will get in the 2025 draft over Smillie?

If we get Robey then I think Sharp simply gives us too many 'hulking' mids, given TT and Hopper have at least 4-years left each. TT, Hopper, McCauliffe, Smillie, Lalor, Robey and Sharp feels like at least 1 x 'big-bodied' mid too many, and probably two. We saw how that can badly affect team balance with Port having to play Ollie Wines and Willem Drew out of position.

For this reason I'd take Robey as I feel he has the tools to play wing which is a list need, ala Jarrod Berry / Hugh McLuggage. Obviously Lalor and Hotton can play mid/fwd. But if we take Robey I'd then take X Taylor as with Broad, Vlastiun and Short near the end he fills a list need beautifully and seems like 'next best' anyway.

Agree
I think the we need a combo on Sharp/Robey with Grijl/Taylor.

 

[tigs2010]

Twomey saying we've told clubs we are open to split one of the 2 picks.

 

[Dr Tigris]

Did you not watch 20yo McCauliffe this year? He was fantastic for a second year, 10-game player. And we have Smillie....he was top-6 in the strongest draft we've ever seen, so why not have any confidence in him? Why would you have more confidence in mids we will get in the 2025 draft over Smillie?

If we get Robey then I think Sharp simply gives us too many 'hulking' mids, given TT and Hopper have at least 4-years left each. TT, Hopper, McCauliffe, Smillie, Lalor, Robey and Sharp feels like at least 1 x 'big-bodied' mid too many, and probably two. We saw how that can badly affect team balance with Port having to play Ollie Wines and Willem Drew out of position.

For this reason I'd take Robey as I feel he has the tools to play wing which is a list need, ala Jarrod Berry / Hugh McLuggage. Obviously Lalor and Hotton can play mid/fwd. But if we take Robey I'd then take X Taylor as with Broad, Vlastiun and Short near the end he fills a list need beautifully and seems like 'next best' anyway.

yeah Robey is causing my Sharp dedication to wear a bit.

getting to 2 of them seems a bit OTT. Very different players. But we'd have a such a huge midfield with Lalor, Smillie, KMac, Sharp and Robey. Although they play very different styles, so it might be possible. Interesting problem to have.

 

[Cherki]

Twomey saying we've told clubs we are open to split one of the 2 picks.

Getting too cute. Don’t like it.

 

[copthat]

How is Greeves ranked below Lindsay

 

[tigs2010]

Getting too cute. Don’t like it.

He said for a pick around 12 & F1.

Also said another option was slide back and get a pick for Kellaway.

 

[captain cotch 9]

Twomey saying we've told clubs we are open to split one of the 2 picks.

Of course we'd be open to it. But it would have to be a win or why would we do it?
If we end up with still a top 10 pick and an extra pick inside 20 i think we'd do it.

 

[tigs2010]

Of course we'd be open to it. But it would have to be a win or why would we do it?
If we end up with still a top 10 pick and an extra pick inside 20 i think we'd do it.

I think we'd be more inclined for a future pick. Don't think we want to be adding 3 more first year kids on top of last years group and needing to play them all. I don't mind the idea of it if we can get that elite speed in Oscar Taylor added to half back and then also a pick around 10 next year.