St Kilda had a similar run of making top 4 five times and the top 8 another two times in eight years from 2004-2011, which is a similar record to Brisbane from 2019-2025. Brisbane have been able to convert that H&A success into two premierships.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Opinion Will Brisbane’s win finally spell the end of the Academies?
- Thread starter Philhawk
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
St Kilda had a similar run of making top 4 five times and the top 8 another two times in eight years from 2004-2011, which is a similar record to Brisbane from 2019-2025. Brisbane have been able to convert that H&A success into two premierships.
- Thread starter
- #177
Nobody is begrudging Brisbane from their deserved success. As has been stated widely, it’s so well deserved. They’re a terrifically run club.
The point is the role of the academy. If it was about growing the game, haven’t we accomplished that now?
There’s no other “equalized” competition in the world with a salary cap and draft that has this mechanism that allows some clubs to circumvent the draft.
Just interested to know out of Brisbane's premiership side yesterday. How many were Father/Sons and how many were academy picks?
Father/Sons:
W.Ashcroft pick #2
L.Ashcroft pick #5
Fletcher pick #12
Academy:
Gallop pick #42
Reville - Other
Marshall pick #25
Don't think academies is the issue if we are talking about the Lions.
Father/Sons:
W.Ashcroft pick #2
L.Ashcroft pick #5
Fletcher pick #12
Academy:
Gallop pick #42
Reville - Other
Marshall pick #25
Don't think academies is the issue if we are talking about the Lions.
There's plenty of inequities in this competition like I saw you post earlier.
You have teams where a large portion of their list are from interstate, whereas another team can draft almost exclusively from their home state and not have to compromise on talent.
Some teams travel five times a year, whereas other teams travel almost every second week, and if they want to get to a city a day earlier before the game, they need to factor those costs into the soft cap (the same soft cap the former team has as well).
Just a few (of many) examples of how the AFL is inherently an unequal completion.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Mynamesinuse
Senior List
- Sep 19, 2025
- 188
- 197
- AFL Club
- Essendon
With the assistance of academies and father sons. StKilda didn’t have that leg up.
I mean priority picks before the first round existed then, and St Kilda did benefit from that.
- Jul 13, 2015
- 41,846
- 48,502
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
AFL funds the academies. The kids there will play Aussie Rules rather than basketball or cricket or whatever.
Why do the clubs get 1st pick? The only supposed requirement is keeping the best talent in the AFL
- Thread starter
- #183
Every club had access to those picks? I’m not following the connection. If any club was terrible for two years, they got access to those picks.
What do other clubs need to do to get access to Annabel?
GoRoos2023
All Australian
- Mar 14, 2023
- 775
- 2,182
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
See Nick Blakey to Sydney.
Our grand final side had academy picks that were picks 25, 42 and 61. They weren't the multiple first round academy picks that seems to be the narrative coming out of this.
Benefitting from father sons, absolutely, we've been very lucky in that regard. But I don't remember the same uproar when Collingwood won a flag off the back of Moore and Daicos x 2, as well as Quaynor from their NGA academy.
Annable I'll give you is a big leg up, especially since we've just gone back to back.
CuttlefishMcfly
Debutant
- Jul 13, 2014
- 140
- 200
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Yeah definitely bid on him and make sure he develops into a great player in the next two years. He will be back in Brisbane for our 4th premiership.
Mynamesinuse
Senior List
- Sep 19, 2025
- 188
- 197
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Available to all clubs and that was when Brisbane and Sydney had extra cap.
Stan_Darsh72
Hall of Famer
- Jun 18, 2011
- 40,773
- 69,638
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Pay the fair cost for the nepo baby wank then champ.
Your club might win but hey at least no nepo baby picks for meme picks
Stan_Darsh72
Hall of Famer
- Jun 18, 2011
- 40,773
- 69,638
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Cool so you will give up first round picks for gun junior's.
Ie no first round picks til the new 30s
Stan_Darsh72
Hall of Famer
- Jun 18, 2011
- 40,773
- 69,638
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Why do lions fans seem so offended at the reality they got gun players for **** all even while being good and hate that the system must change?
Have to trade a player or 2? Have to give up picks to get nepo baby players?
If it was a big vic club in the same place you would agree with us.
Have to trade a player or 2? Have to give up picks to get nepo baby players?
If it was a big vic club in the same place you would agree with us.
CuttlefishMcfly
Debutant
- Jul 13, 2014
- 140
- 200
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Karma for raiding Longer from us… Your salty cries makes the grand final win even better. Enjoy failing for another decade
Stan_Darsh72
Hall of Famer
- Jun 18, 2011
- 40,773
- 69,638
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
And yet still living rent free.Karma for raiding Longer from us… Your salty cries makes the grand final win even better. Enjoy failing for another decade
2 cups but no shine
The past 3 seasons making grand finals brisbane has received the following draft picks:
W ashcroft- pick 2
Levi ashcroft- pick 5
Annable - heavily linked top 5 this year
Meanwhile, essendon and saints have received the following ( courtesy of chat gpt)
St Kilda
Talk about equity in action...
Not sure how anyone has a dislike of geelong for winning a flag in 22 and contending since with an entire team made up of rookies and late picks, yet overlook the massive handouts and concessions brisbane receives
W ashcroft- pick 2
Levi ashcroft- pick 5
Annable - heavily linked top 5 this year
Meanwhile, essendon and saints have received the following ( courtesy of chat gpt)
St Kilda
- 2023: Pick 18 — Darcy Wilson. saints.com.au
- 2024: First pick Pick 8 — Tobie Travaglia (also Pick 10 Alix Tauru later, but first was 8). afl.com.au
- 2025 (upcoming): First pick currently Pick 7 (indicative). afl.com.au
- 2023: Pick 10 — Nate Caddy. essendonfc.com.au
- 2024: First pick Pick 13 — Isaac Kako (matched bid). essendonfc.com.au
- 2025 (upcoming): First pick currently Pick 4 (indicative).
Talk about equity in action...
Not sure how anyone has a dislike of geelong for winning a flag in 22 and contending since with an entire team made up of rookies and late picks, yet overlook the massive handouts and concessions brisbane receives
Stan_Darsh72
Hall of Famer
- Jun 18, 2011
- 40,773
- 69,638
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Is will Ashcroft was properly paid for then there is no issue (aka no Levi no Annabel).
The cost for nepo babies has been too weak for too long.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Elixuh
See you on the 9th green at 9
You act as though we have these academy guns that won us a flag on Saturday, when you wouldn’t even want Bruce Reville on the Saints list!
Elixuh
See you on the 9th green at 9
Do you think this man ran around on all fours in front of the Commissioners yesterday wagging his tail so that he’d have a HILARIOUS story to tell whenever the Saints B&F is.
Whats wrong with picks 40,45, 60 for a pick 2 draftee
- Jun 27, 2010
- 2,138
- 5,137
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Sturt
Ah yes remember when Hawthorn won three in a row and we rushed to change the rules? And when Richmond won three in four and we changed the rules again??
Just like when we had two non-Victorian premiers between 2007 and 2022, and we made all those changes to ensure the game was fair, like booking the MCG for the next 40 grand finals.
Now we have the shock of a Queensland team winning not one two on the trot. So let’s get rid of the one thing that grows the game, grows the fan base, grows the talent pool, and provides northern clubs access to scarce talent.
This grievance just reminds us that the game is still at the mercy of resentments of VFL fans who want to take the game 40 years. We could file this entire topic under the VIC BIAS thread.
Just like when we had two non-Victorian premiers between 2007 and 2022, and we made all those changes to ensure the game was fair, like booking the MCG for the next 40 grand finals.
Now we have the shock of a Queensland team winning not one two on the trot. So let’s get rid of the one thing that grows the game, grows the fan base, grows the talent pool, and provides northern clubs access to scarce talent.
This grievance just reminds us that the game is still at the mercy of resentments of VFL fans who want to take the game 40 years. We could file this entire topic under the VIC BIAS thread.
The issue is that you get a player that the afl rates as pick 2 compo for free
The afl is cooked
The league is cooked
Every team should travel, not play 20 games at the g
And a player picked at 2 should be matched with a pick equivalent, not 3 picks in the 40s
Similar threads
- Poll
