Remove this Banner Ad

Rumour GFC 2026 Player Trading, Drafting FA, Rumours and Wish lists Pt 1

  • Thread starter Thread starter cats_09
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Stanley looks done and Blicavs body got so battered during the finals he was cactus by the time the grand final came along. Pike is not the answer. SDK gets dominated by b-grade ruckmen. The rag tag brigade will see us lose a lot more games next year. Marshall would have been massive for Geelong.

You didn't mention Edwards in there.

Interesting.
 
Some draft experts are calling this the worst draft in history.

A pick 25 plus 40 odd next year is just not worth much.

We get to retain a bloke that has been one of our best players for the last 6 years on a very small salary the next 2 years.

It really shouldn't be staggering.

They say that pretty much ever 2nd year. In 2003 and 2012 they were right, every othertime they got it wrong. That's like a 20% strike rate
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Swans ended up trading 3x firsts plus Hayward - clearly more than our offer.
Carlton lost there cap space and 2 further picks in this deal
 
Some draft experts are calling this the worst draft in history.

A pick 25 plus 40 odd next year is just not worth much.

We get to retain a bloke that has been one of our best players for the last 6 years on a very small salary the next 2 years.

It really shouldn't be staggering.
Enjoy not making the finals again
 
Mackie re Marshall - "Bigger crack today than we thought we would have done"
Exactly we literally caved and payed the overs and St Kilda still turned it down for a redundant 30 year old backup ruckman, crazy list management.
 
Exactly we literally caved and payed the overs and St Kilda still turned it down for a redundant 30 year old backup ruckman, crazy list management.

Loser clubs (St K and Essendon) sell things like this as a win - when all it’s doing is holding them back while they’re miles away from contending.
 
Go and get the fat campaigner. Even just for comedic value.

You can invite up to two players for every rookie pick to train with you in the offseason. We have what could be up to three free spaces. Might as well invite six ruckmen down and see who can run the most.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Exactly we literally caved and payed the overs and St Kilda still turned it down for a redundant 30 year old backup ruckman, crazy list management.

They panicked about their forward line, thats where they will play him given King is a walking injury and they have bugger all after that. Piss poor from their list management team to bring in TDK who gives them nothing they didnt already have instead of trying to fix their glaring issue up forward. Marshall is a ruck, but he will be a square peg in a round hole next year.
 
This is a poor draft id rather trade 19 info the future if we can. I think next year will be too late for marshall age wise i think we will get someone else instead.
I doubt Rowan is happy though he basically cant play ruck anymore and is stuck there for the rest of his career.
I read that it's not necessarily a 'poor draft' but rather it evens out after the top 10. You get as good a player at 31 as 11, i guess is the implication.

Regardless, do I really worry about what's available with the picks we have given the history of Wells and Mackie? Not at all. I'm not saying there will be A+ grade players we can draft with those picks that Carlton and Stains have rejected... but good to very, very good players? If anyone can... Wells and Mackie can. #shrug
 
Exactly we literally caved and payed the overs and St Kilda still turned it down for a redundant 30 year old backup ruckman, crazy list management.

He isn’t a back up he will rotate forward and ruck as well, but the saints could be top top heavy playing both TDK and Marshall.
 
They panicked about their forward line, thats where they will play him given King is a walking injury and they have bugger all after that. Piss poor from their list management team to bring in TDK who gives them nothing they didnt already have instead of trying to fix their glaring issue up forward. Marshall is a ruck, but he will be a square peg in a round hole next year.
This has got Oliver written all over it, when it doesn't work next year he will be worth a 3rd and a bag of chips.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Where's jumping jack at?
Hide Hiding GIF
 
Exactly we literally caved and payed the overs and St Kilda still turned it down for a redundant 30 year old backup ruckman, crazy list management.
It’s funny that in a trade period where clubs seen the negative returns clubs holding onto players who want to leave(Oliver going from a trade worth of two firsts to being a 3rd rounder) teams still take this line
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom