Our Best 23 2026 Cannot change once selected

[tigs2010]

Given we can't change it I wonder how we get the Poo into the fwd pocket. Loan deal?

 

[rfctigerarmy]

The thread title doesn’t specify whether it’s the team you think will play or the team you want to play…. It says the best 23. I believe this is the best 23

You said it's the team worth investing in

Read the title

 

[Truetiger]

It’s funny how rfctigerarmy is expecting everyone else to do the work instead of himself. Where’s your best 23?

 

[Wrenny]

It’s funny how rfctigerarmy is expecting everyone else to do the work instead of himself. Where’s your best 23?

tigs2010 alt acc confirmed

 

[rfctigerarmy]

It’s funny how rfctigerarmy is expecting everyone else to do the work instead of himself. Where’s your best 23?

Cant be bothered

 

[The_Kraken]

Vlastuin Miller Broad
Trainor Gibcus Brown
Grlj Lalor Retschko
Hotton Faull Cummy
Phillipou Lynch Balta
Nankervis Taranto Hopper
McAuliffe Banks Campbell Prestia Alger

Cummy?!!! **** you, tigs2010

 

[Delorean]

Smillie at full forward for mine

 

[tropicaltiger]

B: Gibcus Miller Vlastuin
HB: Brown Balta Banks
C: Sonsie Hopper Broad
HF: Taranto Faull Campbell
F: MRJ Lynch Hotton
Foll: Ryan Lalor Prestia
I/C: Trainor Nankervis Ross Prestia Hugo

 

[Ralll]

B: Vlastuin Balta Broad
HB: Banks Gibcus Short
C: Cummings Hopper Retschko
HF: Hotton Armstrong Lalor
F: Campbell Lynch Faull
Foll: Nank Taranto McAuliffe
Int: Sims Smillie Trainor Grlj Peucker

 

[tiger_tough]

Bloody hard to pick a best 23 now.

This would be my ideal r1 side, but I expect Ralphsmith and probably Prestia play, maybe Ross also.

fb- Broad, Miller, Brown
hb- Vlastuin, Balta, Banks
c- Grlj, Hopper, Trainor
hf- Lalor, Faull, Campbell
ff- Mansell, Lynch, Armstrong
c- Nank, Taranto, McAuliffe

i/c- Gibcus, Short, MRJ, Cumming, Hotton
emg (from) - Ralphsmith, Alger, Sonsie, Ross, Prestia, Smillie, Gray, Retschko

 

[tropicaltiger]

winding the clock back 12mths. replay of round one 2025 observations

1. credit to ooze gave the newbies a go bauer & blight, macca and dow overlooked for 2026. steely, sonsie, tresize given a crack with the jury still out on them.

2. cripps scragged at stoppage, free kick carlton....taranto mauled and play on

3. 3 or 4 shocking decisions against us main culprit o'gormam

4. lalor touches considering his tender age similar to dusty, every touch worth 2 of everyone else.

5. lynch = vital cog

6. momentum and confidence in young team = 6 goals

7. accurate kicking is vital inaccurate kicking saps energy.

 

[Chunky09]

Vlastuin Balta Trainor
Brown Miller Banks
Grlj Taranto Short
Alger Faull Campbell
Armstrong Lynch Rioli Jnr

Nank Lalor Hotton

Cumming Hopper Broad Sims Gibcus

 

[mctiger33]

Vlaustin Miller Gibcus
Banks Balta Brown
Grlj Hopper Short
Campbell Faull Hotton
Armstrong Lynch Mansell

Nankervis Taranto Lalor

Sims Broad Cumming Trainor Rioli

 

[partycorolla]

B: Nick Vlastuin Josh Gibcus Luke Trainor

HB: Sam Banks Noah Balta Sam Grlj

C: Judson Clarke Taj Hotton Tom Brown

HF: Sam Cumming Jonty Faull Seth Campbell

F: Jasper Alger Tom Lynch Harry Armstrong

Foll: Toby Nankervis Sam Lalor Josh Smillie

I/C: Hopper Taranto Prestia Mansell MRJ


Unlucky (Emergency): Ben Miller (You dont drop a ferrari for him so where does he fit in), Nathan Broad, Kane McAuliffe,


Depth: Short, Steely Green

Doubt that's the round 1 team but could be more like it by end of the year.

 

[partycorolla]

Bloody hard to pick a best 23 now.

This would be my ideal r1 side, but I expect Ralphsmith and probably Prestia play, maybe Ross also.

fb- Broad, Miller, Brown
hb- Vlastuin, Balta, Banks
c- Grlj, Hopper, Trainor
hf- Lalor, Faull, Campbell
ff- Mansell, Lynch, Armstrong
c- Nank, Taranto, McAuliffe

i/c- Gibcus, Short, MRJ, Cumming, Hotton
emg (from) - Ralphsmith, Alger, Sonsie, Ross, Prestia, Smillie, Gray, Retschko

Who will be second ruck or will Balta do it out of CHB?

 

[tiger_tough]

Who will be second ruck or will Balta do it out of CHB?

 

[THE_GUN]

Round 1 team

B: Gibcus - Miller - Vlastuin
H: Brown - Balta - Broad
C: Ross - Hopper - Ralphsmith
H : Hotton - Faull - Campbell
F : Rioli - Lynch - Armstrong
F : Nankervis - Lalor - Taranto - Prestia
Int : Trainor - McAuliffe - Banks -Mansell - Short
Emerg: Retschko - Grlj - Ryan - Cumming

Hoping we actually debut Cumming against Carlton 1st game of the year

 

[of unsound mind]

Best 23, not R1

B. Vlas. Miller. Brown
HB. Banks. Balta. Broad
C. Grlj. Taranto. Trainor
HF. Campbell. Faull. Hotton
F. Lalor. Lynch. Mansell
Foll. Nank. Smillie. Cumming
I. MRJ. Hopper. Sims. KMac2. Gray

E. Armstrong. Sonsie. Short. Alger. Gibcus. Prestia.

Armstrong stiff
Gray or Gibcus whichever body holds up
Prestia is best 23 but will be limited games

 

[4tune8]

Round 1 team

B: Gibcus - Miller - Vlastuin
H: Brown - Balta - Broad
C: Ross - Hopper - Ralphsmith
H : Hotton - Faull - Campbell
F : Rioli - Lynch - Armstrong
F : Nankervis - Lalor - Taranto - Prestia
Int : Trainor - McAuliffe - Banks -Mansell - Short
Emerg: Retschko - Grlj - Ryan - Cumming

Hoping we actually debut Cumming against Carlton 1st game of the year

This is pretty close to what I expect the team to look like in round 1 (but it's best 23 not 24 ), although I wouldn't have 3 defenders on the bench. The 5 man bench gives the opportunity to name a 2nd ruck who I'd reckon would be Sims, possibly Ryan given the new ruck rules, so Banks or Trainor out and McAuliffe to the VFL (depth)

B: Gibcus - Miller - Vlastuin
H: Brown - Balta - Broad
C: Ross - Hopper - Ralphsmith
H : Hotton - Faull - Campbell
F : Rioli - Lynch - Armstrong
F : Nankervis - Lalor - Taranto
Int : Trainor - Prestia - Sims -Mansell - Short

It's interesting to have a look at the magoos with AFL listed players.

B: Tresize - Gray - Smith
H: Smillie - Banks - Grlj
C: Retschko - Cumming - NRT
H : Clarke - Fawcett - Alger
F : Peucker - LeFau - Ryan
F : OHB - McAuliffe - Sonsie - Green

This highlights why Tylar Young was a required player with only Gray as KPD depth.

 

[Madtiger2006]

Oh ok
Here it is
The best 23
Everyone waiting for madtigers team
Well here we go
I’ll do a 2027 team
It’s coming
It’s coming
It’s here

Grlj Miller Smith
Brown Gibcus Banks
Hotton Lalor Roberts Thompson
Alger Faull Peucker
Armstrong Fawcett Campbell
Ryan Smilie Cumming
Ross Mcauliff Green Balta Trainor

 

[Danog]

Best 23 (not including Smillie and Clarke, who would be in due to injury) with a look to the future (so no Prestia or Short).

B: Gibcus Miller Vlastuin
HB: Brown Balta Banks
C: Ross Hopper Trainor
HF: Hotton Faull Campbell
F: Armstrong Lynch Lalor
Foll: Nankervis Taranto McAuliffe
I/C: Broad Mansell Cumming Grlj Sims

Emg: Gray Alger OHB Retschko

Really highlights how badly we need another good ruck and wing

 

[tiger_tough]

Our list in 2026 is the 3rd youngest and 2nd least experienced.

AFL Club Lists for 2026 - Draftguru

www.draftguru.com.au

On another note - Dees are ****ed. Equal 2nd oldest list. Going to be full rebuild through the tassie drafts.

Scary how young GC are.

 

[THE_GUN]

Our list in 2026 is the 3rd youngest and 2nd least experienced.

AFL Club Lists for 2026 - Draftguru

www.draftguru.com.au

On another note - Dees are ****ed. Equal 2nd oldest list. Going to be full rebuild through the tassie drafts.

Scary how young GC are.

Thats why i think we will go back a step for a year or 2 before we go foward and 5 win season would be extremely hard to replicate. Which is fine as we are building from ground up and a rebuild never seen like what we have done.

I would say we are probably 7-8 players away from finishing this rebuild and will come to fruition after the retirements of
Lynch , Prestia , Broad , Nank , Short & Vlastuin in the next 2-3 years but the kids would have been developed and guided well by the experienced players on their last years.

 

[Danog]

Thats why i think we will go back a step for a year or 2 before we go foward and 5 win season would be extremely hard to replicate. Which is fine as we are building from ground up and a rebuild never seen like what we have done.

I would say we are probably 7-8 players away from finishing this rebuild and will come to fruition after the retirements of
Lynch , Prestia , Broad , Nank , Short & Vlastuin in the next 2-3 years but the kids would have been developed and guided well by the experienced players on their last years.

Youre underestimating how shit West Coast, Melbourne and Essendon also are.

 

[tiger_tough]

Thats why i think we will go back a step for a year or 2 before we go foward and 5 win season would be extremely hard to replicate. Which is fine as we are building from ground up and a rebuild never seen like what we have done.

I would say we are probably 7-8 players away from finishing this rebuild and will come to fruition after the retirements of
Lynch , Prestia , Broad , Nank , Short & Vlastuin in the next 2-3 years but the kids would have been developed and guided well by the experienced players on their last years.

The development of the kids will offset the drop off from a few of the veterans IMO. Plus the gameplan should be more refined.

I think we'll end up with a similar amount of wins but hopefully a far better percentage.