Competitions Pieman Trade Period 2018

[businessfish]

Out: Libba, Dickson, Schache, Dunkley, Dahlhaus

In: Gowers, Lipinski, Macrae, Hunter, Boyd

 

[Fossie 32]

Edited - team needed more Toyyyyd!!!

 

[grassman75]

You are banned from pieman forever Fossie

 

[Vinegar Mess]

Edited - team needed more Toyyyyd!!!

Fossie, I should have asked you to repost as (strictly speaking) edited posts are not acceptable however given that the edit is clearly denoted as made the day before cut-off and because I don’t wish to appear a pedant, I’ll let your changes stick. Just referencing it here for when dogwatch audits me.

 

[Vinegar Mess]

Instead of bringing in Greene and Adams I'll take Crozier and JJ (T1) please.

Scrag, you get the Fossie treatment too (refer above). Given that you’re a chance to actually win this thing then the Pieman Committee reserves it’s right to overrule. Anyone wishing to protest this decision please lodge a formal protest by way of an angst-ridden tirade within 24 hours for consideration. Otherwise Scrag’s changes are accepted.

 

[X_box_X]

I don't actually see what Scrag did wrong. He didn't edit his post. He made changes in a separate post. My understanding of the rules deems this to be acceptable. Can't you make unlimited trades before the deadline?

 

[bontshow]

Scrag, you get the Fossie treatment too (refer above). Given that you’re a chance to actually win this thing then the Pieman Committee reserves it’s right to overrule. Anyone wishing to protest this decision please lodge a formal protest by way of an angst-ridden tirade within 24 hours for consideration. Otherwise Scrag’s changes are accepted.

 

[bontshow]

I don't actually see what Scrag did wrong. He didn't edit his post. He made changes in a separate post. My understanding of the rules deems this to be acceptable. Can't you make unlimited trades before the deadline?

It's edited, see "Last edited" near the reply button

 

[ScragCity]

Scrag, you get the Fossie treatment too (refer above). Given that you’re a chance to actually win this thing then the Pieman Committee reserves it’s right to overrule. Anyone wishing to protest this decision please lodge a formal protest by way of an angst-ridden tirade within 24 hours for consideration. Otherwise Scrag’s changes are accepted.

Sorry - I genuinely overlooked the rule about editing. As you mentioned, you can see that it was edited before the cut off. Thanks for letting it slide this time.

 

[Vinegar Mess]

I don't actually see what Scrag did wrong. He didn't edit his post. He made changes in a separate post. My understanding of the rules deems this to be acceptable. Can't you make unlimited trades before the deadline?

Both Scrag's posts were edited - the original and the amendment. Not supposed to edit either. Both posts were edited prior to gameday and so I'm allowing the changes. My reason for commenting at all is to avoid potential cries of protest by petulant misanthropes at the end of the season after Scrag wins. [Thanks for posting the screenprint to explain, boydshow].

 

[X_box_X]

I now understand.

Yeah, no issues from my end. There's no dishonesty or cheating. Fair game IMO.

 

[Fossie 32]

Fossie, I should have asked you to repost as (strictly speaking) edited posts are not acceptable however given that the edit is clearly denoted as made the day before cut-off and because I don’t wish to appear a pedant, I’ll let your changes stick. Just referencing it here for when dogwatch audits me.

ok, ask me to repost

 

[Fossie 32]

Thanks VM

 

[Vinegar Mess]

I'll trade in Redpath for Schache and Dickson for Gowers.

Floridog, I've swapped Redpath for Schache however the second part of that sentence doesn't make sense - you've never had Dickson in your team (it was Daniel who stays in). Full teams are listed in the post below.

 

[Vinegar Mess]

Just to tidy up this thread here are the post-trade teams. New additions are highlighted in this aqua colour (and are suffixed "T1").

 

[Dogs_R_Us]

Are you seriously telling me that no one picked Richards?

 

[grassman75]

Are you seriously telling me that no one picked Richards?

You don't know how close I was on Thursday arvo. He's been threatening and I thought with his handicap dropping by 30, it was a bit of a Gowers situation......went into panic mode when he kicked 3, but relaxed when I saw no one else had him

 

[Dogs_R_Us]

You don't know how close I was on Thursday arvo. He's been threatening and I thought with his handicap dropping by 30, it was a bit of a Gowers situation......went into panic mode when he kicked 3, but relaxed when I saw no one else had him

Me too!