Remove this Banner Ad

Mega Thread #14 David Mackay - 14 possessions again

Can we piss off with these * is going next year and unsigned threads

  • Yes

    Votes: 4 66.7%
  • Jack Watts

    Votes: 2 33.3%

  • Total voters
    6

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I have no problem with Mackay being selected. Sure his 2018 was ordinary (no worse than others). and his pre season has been interuppted.
But his 2017 was quite good. looking at the emergencies named..........he would be ahead.

Lets see what he has to offer this season.
 
David is like the member of a group project that does **** all and rocks up at the end expecting the same grades as everyone else.

David is this team's 3rd wheel.

David would fail to give a don't argue to drying bed sheet on a clothes line.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I have no problem with Mackay being selected. Sure his 2018 was ordinary (no worse than others). and his pre season has been interuppted.
But his 2017 was quite good. looking at the emergencies named..........he would be ahead.

Lets see what he has to offer this season.

At 30 I think we have our answer, the same beige performance that he has offered up every season since 2009, only now, less effective due to age and fitness.
 
Even Rowey and Bicks were shocked with his selection and that’s saying something

We did select VB over Harto against a tall Roos forward outfit in VB’s last year where he played 3 games. This isn’t as bad as that because we’ve lost Seed and Brown, so Mackay’s selection is entirely expected to maintain running patterns, continuity and experience levels. If he’d been up and going, requiring 2 injuries wouldn’t bother me, but he’s off an interrupted preseason, so will almost certainly be a complete liability.
 
For the first time I was actually confident he would not get the Golden Pass into the side. I underestimated them.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

As soon as Seeds was out I knew he was coming back in. Hopefully short-lived but you can just see us pushing a kid out when Seed comes back after a 13 disposal, 4 tackle effort from Dmack.

The only question is will it be Jones or Murphy making way next week.
 
If i was Fog, Greenwood, Gooch or C.E.Y.....id be looking for another club to play for.
To see Dmack selected before any of the above is a complete joke.
Its not like he played BOG in JTL 2....he didnt even play.
Hawks will go through his man every chance they get.
AFC selection commitee are complete muppets that dont know the difference between natural footballers....and a wet cloth.
 
This isnt a trial game, the JLT is over. It's round one. We have a choice between a youngster and a 200 gamer. That's not even a contest.

That has served us so well over the last 15 years.

We are so conservative, you would think after our umpteenth rookie head coach does the same predictable thing at selection they would eventually learn.

But no, back to the same well that has failed repeatably.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom