Beerfish
Unscripted Hot Takes
- Jan 20, 2008
- 64,674
- 110,390
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Nic Martin
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Excuse me?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Did he play VFL when he came back last time?So does Parish have to earn his place back through the vfl or automatic inclusion when he's fit again?
Probs depends on how well we’re going.So does Parish have to earn his place back through the vfl or automatic inclusion when he's fit again?
???Frustrating considering an apparent excellent PS
Is a concern at this age

So does Parish have to earn his place back through the vfl or automatic inclusion when he's fit again?
Runs from November to round 1???
Now pre season is what happens before round 1 ?
Missed the first two rounds .
So he did not have a great pre season. He got injured before round 1. You do not win the Melbourne Cup if you get run down in the last 100 meters.Runs from November to round 1
My understanding is that Parish was having a great preseason until he got injured. He looked very good in one of the preseason games. But yeah, obviously it was marred by the injurySo he did not have a great pre season. He got injured before round 1. You do not win the Melbourne Cup if you get run down in the last 100 meters.
I know. I saw most of it in Jan / Feb match simMy understanding is that Parish was having a great preseason until he got injured. He looked very good in one of the preseason games. But yeah, obviously it was marred by the injury


Poor analogySo he did not have a great pre season. He got injured before round 1. You do not win the Melbourne Cup if you get run down in the last 100 meters.
Says you.Poor analogy
Just because you dont win doesnt mean you havnt had a great raceSays you.
He made it to the last 100 meters of pre season. That is what we are talking about.
If you lead until the 100 mark and fade out and finish in the back half it is not a great race. In fact it is pretty bad as a large percentage of horses do not fully recover after blowing up in the last 400 meters or so. Parish did not make it to round 1 so it does not matter how good he was in Jan or Feb. The idea is to set your season up. So far his season is a bust. Missed two. Took 3 to get going and is now out for 3 to 5 weeks. You do not think they will not be looking at his pre season now ?Just because you dont win doesnt mean you havnt had a great race
They look at everyones PS at the end of each yearIf you lead until the 100 mark and fade out and finish in the back half it is not a great race. In fact it is pretty bad as a large percentage of horses do not fully recover after blowing up in the last 400 meters or so. Parish did not make it to round 1 so it does not matter how good he was in Jan or Feb. The idea is to set your season up. So far his season is a bust. Missed two. Took 3 to get going and is now out for 3 to 5 weeks. You do not think they will not be looking at his pre season now ?
They look at everyones PS at the end of each year
Obviously if injuries could be avoided the week of the season starting then we wouldnt have any injuries during that timeAnd they'll all agree that having an injury at the end of his preseason was problematic.
But he did return and did get injured again and he now has a history of calf issues so obviously 95% of his pre season was an issue . Maybe he needed a Jake Stringer pre season where he was eased into the program a bit more. You can spin it any way you want but his season is now in trouble.Obviously if injuries could be avoided the week of the season starting then we wouldnt have any injuries during that time
I dont think missing 5% of PS even towards the end equates to a poor PS
Guthrie missed longer and Scott said hed had a great PS, this is said many times
We can't always predict when soft tissue injuries will occur, there are plenty of variables
The issue may more so be whats happened since initial injury to now
If hed missed 2 games and then returned and no reinjured it wouldnt be an issue
there are plenty of variables