Beerfish
Unscripted Hot Takes
- Jan 20, 2008
- 64,625
- 110,274
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Nic Martin
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
There you go. Hobbs and Caldwell more than up to it and far better defensively. Think it would honestly be the best thing if he left as it’d push those 2 back to flanks if he stayed
Nah just beat non finalists and lose to the teams above us and finish 7th and lose an elimination final interstate by ten goalsShouldn’t we be tanking then?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
There you go. Hobbs and Caldwell more than up to it and far better defensively. Think it would honestly be the best thing if he left as it’d push those 2 back to flanks if he stayed
The last 20 years finals winsWhich KPP has caught your eye in this years draft to be out injured 80% of the time while Parish racks up more All Australians?
Midfielder Darcy Parish is on track to return soon after mid-season bye.
McPherson says Parish is inching toward re-joining main training with the hope of being available for Essendon’s trip to Perth.
“Darcy’s continuing to build his speed work and footy integration as he nears a return to full training,” McPherson said.
“He’s progressing well and all things going to plan, he’ll be a chance to return for round 15."
I was guilty of that too, so go easy on the Brunesta over that. We all know that he's not much of a forward!
I didn't think you were so faint-hearted, dansin.
I still believe Laverde would be a good forward and that he'd have a similar impact to Stringer at stoppages.
Yeah, hopefully he stays. Absolute gun and hard to replace.He is STILL 18th for total clearances
he's played 3, if not 4 less games than the rest of the top 20. Clayton Oliver has the same amount with 2 more games
Gotta keep him me thinks
discussing at the moment but Hobbs, Caldwell even Parish himself have shown an ability in the forward half so all could play in the same side.If last night doesn’t prove we don’t need him then I don’t know what does. Are you going to sacrifice Hobbs, Caldwell or Martins midfield time for the next 6 years if you sign him?
This is the issue we try and stick midfielders in forward pockets and it’s dumb. Much more effective playing a small forward there. Hobbs and Caldwell far better defensively than Parish and Perkins can even play on ball. Tsatas to come in aswell.discussing at the moment but Hobbs, Caldwell even Parish himself have shown an ability in the forward half so all could play in the same side.
Parish is literally one of the best clearance players in the league, if you think the other guys can improve to a point it offsets what we lose from Parish departing then perhaps its an idea
I still think we should delist him.I didn't think you were so faint-hearted, dansin.
I still believe Laverde would be a good forward and that he'd have a similar impact to Stringer at stoppages.
What happens if we get 2 or 3 injuries?This is the issue we try and stick midfielders in forward pockets and it’s dumb. Much more effective playing a small forward there. Hobbs and Caldwell far better defensively than Parish and Perkins can even play on ball. Tsatas to come in aswell.
Mids next year: Merrett, Martin, Caldwell, Hobbs, Tsatas, Perkins. Good balance of height, inside, outside, defence and offence in there.
I’ve given you what 6 or 7 names there. Not even including Shiel and SetterfieldWhat happens if we get 2 or 3 injuries?
If last night doesn’t prove we don’t need him then I don’t know what does. Are you going to sacrifice Hobbs, Caldwell or Martins midfield time for the next 6 years if you sign him?
Yes and they all rotate through currently except for Tsatas. They're getting the time now because of injuries to 3 first choice mids. You move Parish on and that's 1 less in our depth, Shiels body is suspect so suddenly we're down 2.I’ve given you what 6 or 7 names there. Not even including Shiel and Setterfield
Nah, only need one good centre and two on-ballers. Not going to get any injuries and everyone has good endurance, so we don't even need an interchange, let alone depth. Might as well trade everyone outside the best 18 and get a bunch of whipping boys to play in the VFL. Every BigFooty board needs a good whipping boy after all.Yes and they all rotate through currently except for Tsatas. They're getting the time now because of injuries to 3 first choice mids. You move Parish on and that's 1 less in our depth, Shiels body is suspect so suddenly we're down 2.
It's not as simple as "move Parish on because all those guys can play mid."
We get multiple injuries, we need depth.
Perko not a midfield mainstay for at least another two seasons. Hobbs, Caldwell should be rotated in with Shiel.
Setters/parish/Merrett our midfield group for the next two seasons for sure. Hobbs probably replaces setters in a couple of years. Caldwell replaces Shiel permanently. Think they can all fit.
D'Ambrosio replaces heppell (though right now, they're big shoes to fill, crazy I'm saying that)
Our small forwards are the real problem. We should have been up by 3 goals in the first quarter.
North’s baby (albeit very talented) midfield nearly overran us last week..and for three quarters I’d say Blues mid was on top. Against better teams we need Parish