Strategy Trade and List Management Thread Part 7 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[Bulldogs85]

Haven’t missed too much

Funny how they question the info you pass on but hasn’t Hill missed a few games though personal issues

 

[Smiley Boy]

Funny how they question the info you pass on but hasn’t Hill missed a few games though personal issues

I will go back there and remind them of my initial post when it all comes out to be true

 

[doggy_dog]

Edited to posts deleted.

I stand by the info i got and standby that Bobby Hill won't play another game this year and will ask to be traded

Can you share whether it’s club specific or location specific? I.e would he play for another Vic club or would it be an interstate move only

 

[VitalDread]

I was wrong about Busslinger leaving but at the time the eagles threw the kitchen sink at him and people at the eagles were saying it was done

People change theirs minds can’t get them all right!

There was a least three of us all saying Buss was going to Eagles for the coin

Generally shocked he stayed even though might be likely leaving this off season

 

[MaxiBont]

I was wrong about Busslinger leaving but at the time the eagles threw the kitchen sink at him and people at the eagles were saying it was done

People change theirs minds can’t get them all right!

Exactly, also things change all the time.

Something that seems likely in April may drastically change in September

 

[Philthy1]

I will go back there and remind them of my initial post when it all comes out to be true

It's funny how BF is a forum for discussion and rumours, but only if people want them to be true.

 

[Bulldogs85]

I will go back there and remind them of my initial post when it all comes out to be true

Kind of surprised that he wants out after he Re-Signed with them this year

 

[grassman75]

I was wrong about Busslinger leaving but at the time the eagles threw the kitchen sink at him and people at the eagles were saying it was done

People change theirs minds can’t get them all right!

It might still be right….just a few years late

 

[BillyElliott]

Funny how they question the info you pass on but hasn’t Hill missed a few games though personal issues

We know Bobby has missed games for personal reasons. They're personal for a reason.

 

[Philthy1]

We know Bobby has missed games for personal reasons. They're personal for a reason.

You can tell your mates Smiley Boy is no troll. His mail is almost always spot on.

 

[Bulldogs85]

We know Bobby has missed games for personal reasons. They're personal for a reason.

having a discussion on my own board don’t need your input

 

[BillyElliott]

You can talk about it over on your own board I don’t need your own input

We didn't appreciate the spreading of any rumours about one of our players on our board either.

 

[BillyElliott]

You can tell your mates Smiley Boy is no troll. His mail is almost always spot on.

'almost'

 

[Bulldogs85]

We didn't appreciate the spreading of any rumours about one of our players on our board either.

You can leave Smiley Boy is one of the best on our board and is always on the money you don’t have to believe it that’s on you

 

[X_box_X]

We didn't appreciate the spreading of any rumours about one of our players on our board either.

Would you prefer he didn't post?

Seems a bit strange.

If a credible opposition supporter with a trusted record came onto our board to alert us to some reliable information pertaining to one of our players, it would be welcomed and well received.

Next time Smiley Boy won't pass on information. Instead of being appreciative and welcoming, he has been treated unfairly.

Very harsh IMO.

 

[TiAn_]

We didn't appreciate the spreading of any rumours about one of our players on our board either.

No one cares, jog on.

 

[Bulldogs85]

Smiley Boy is not our club, so has no clue about the support Bobby is getting whilst he deals with his 'personal' issues.

He came onto our board claiming he wouldn't be at the club next year without providing any further details & wonders why it wasn't appreciated.

Run along and have a sook about it over on Collingwood’s board

 

[Bald]

Would you prefer he didn't post?

Seems a bit strange.

If a credible opposition supporter with a trusted record came onto our board to alert us to some reliable information pertaining to one of our players, it would be welcomed and well received.

Next time Smiley Boy won't pass on information. Instead of being appreciative and welcoming, he has been treated unfairly.

Very harsh IMO.

I didn’t see the initial post from Smiley but the replies to it afterwards suggested it came across a little bit speculative and not very informative. I can imagine we’d be pretty annoyed if an opposition supporter came in here and said things with little to no substance (outside of the obvious connection with Bobby missing games).

Not a shot at Smiley at all as I said I didn’t see the post, but we shouldn’t also pretend we’d be stand up citizens if somebody came in here and said something about one of our players.

With that being said, clearly something is going on with Bobby, and as we did with Jamarra, we’d prefer it all to just remain private.

 

[MaxiBont]

Smiley Boy is not our club, so has no clue about the support Bobby is getting whilst he deals with his 'personal' issues.

He came onto our board claiming he wouldn't be at the club next year without providing any further details & wonders why it wasn't appreciated.

He’s just passing on information which is relevant to Collingwood.

It’s your choice whether to believe it or not.

Not sure why it’s blown up into such a big deal.

 

[Thunderoad]

Smiley Boy is not our club, so has no clue about the support Bobby is getting whilst he deals with his 'personal' issues.

He came onto our board claiming he wouldn't be at the club next year without providing any further details & wonders why it wasn't appreciated.

You sound very upset by something that really doesn't warrant getting upset about.

 

[BillyElliott]

Would you prefer he didn't post?

Seems a bit strange.

If a credible opposition supporter with a trusted record came onto our board to alert us to some reliable information pertaining to one of our players, it would be welcomed and well received.

Next time Smiley Boy won't pass on information. Instead of being appreciative and welcoming, he has been treated unfairly.

Very harsh IMO.

Yes we would prefer he didn't post.

You want us to thank him for telling us he doesn't believe Bobby will play another game this year & will be traded to a WA club next year without any details to back that up? Despite the fact he's just extended to 2030.

It's personal. The club are looking after him. That's all we need to know.

 

[X_box_X]

Yes we would prefer he didn't post.

You want us to thank him for telling us he doesn't believe Bobby will play another game this year & will be traded to a WA club next year without any details to back that up? Despite the fact he's just extended to 2030.

It's personal. The club are looking after him. That's all we need to know.

OK,

Your loss.

Now move along, sonny boy.

 

[Bulldogs85]

I will go back there and remind them of my initial post when it all comes out to be true

I wouldn’t even waste my time personally

 

[Peters_Nuts]

I didn’t see the initial post from Smiley but the replies to it afterwards suggested it came across a little bit speculative and not very informative. I can imagine we’d be pretty annoyed if an opposition supporter came in here and said things with little to no substance (outside of the obvious connection with Bobby missing games).

Not a shot at Smiley at all as I said I didn’t see the post, but we shouldn’t also pretend we’d be stand up citizens if somebody came in here and said something about one of our players.

With that being said, clearly something is going on with Bobby, and as we did with Jamarra, we’d prefer it all to just remain private.

Just jumping in here to say this is pretty much it.

We have zero issues with opposition supporters posting on our board (unlike Carlton where just saying hello will get you banned), it's more that a statement was made that a loved player won't play another game for us and will request a trade without any additional context.

It would be the same as me coming on here and saying "I have it on good authority that Bont is going to request a trade but I can't say why". Naturally, that would rustle some feathers. There probably wasn't need to say "I'll just leave just like Bobby will" when posters questioned him but hopefully that's the end of it!

There's definitely something going on with Bobby as this could be his 4th week missed due to personal reasons. The club will likely have to address it soon though Fly said that it's personal so we try not to speculate.

 

[Smiley Boy]

Yes we would prefer he didn't post.

You want us to thank him for telling us he doesn't believe Bobby will play another game this year & will be traded to a WA club next year without any details to back that up? Despite the fact he's just extended to 2030.

It's personal. The club are looking after him. That's all we need to know.

Noted mate just don't be too shocked when it comes to fruition