Beerfish
Unscripted Hot Takes
- Jan 20, 2008
- 64,665
- 110,369
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Nic Martin
- Moderator
- #2
Last edited by a moderator:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

1 year deal.
Straight to the LTI list for a free list spot. Make a decision around the MSD.
Are we keeping Lual?I'd be surprised if he didn't get cut
I expect all three to be cut for the draft, maybe Lual gets a train on spot or gets taken in the RDAre we keeping Lual?
That makes no sense.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Yeah except it doesn't work that way. To pick up an SSP, he has to be out for the yearSure it does. Setterfield is one of our more important players when healthy.
Keeping him on LTI means he can come back around the midseason bye and be fresh for half a season. It also means that we don’t have to compete with other teams to pick him at the MSD like if we didn’t offer him a contract.
He wouldn’t be on much money and neither would the rookie doubling up on that list spot.
Sure it does. Setterfield is one of our more important players when healthy.
Keeping him on LTI means he can come back around the midseason bye and be fresh for half a season. It also means that we don’t have to compete with other teams to pick him at the MSD like if we didn’t offer him a contract.
He wouldn’t be on much money and neither would the rookie doubling up on that list spot.
Unless another spot opens I think? Ie someone else goes LTINo.
Once someone is on the LTI they can't come back that season.
NopeUnless another spot opens I think? Ie someone else goes LTI
I doubt it. He may not be in the state or country.I wonder if Will is save since Hobbs and Lual have been announced?
Not really sure why you would bother myself. Yes he is handy but he has a history of getting injured in some way.Also think he could be placed on LTI instead of delisted, still opening up a list spot
What’s that got to do with it? If he hasn’t been offered a contract you can be told at anytime. The players are on leave.I doubt it. He may not be in the state or country.
Imagine you're overseas and get back on Saturday. You get a phone call from Matt Rosa on Monday saying "Sorry I interrupted your trip, but we're not offering you a contract".What’s that got to do with it? If he hasn’t been offered a contract you can be told at anytime. The players are on leave.
Leadership, experience, training standardsNot really sure why you would bother myself. Yes he is handy but he has a history of getting injured in some way.
And what about if he’s not back in Melbourne before October 31st?Imagine you're overseas and get back on Saturday. You get a phone call from Matt Rosa on Monday saying "Sorry I interrupted your trip, but we're not offering you a contract".
It can wait a week or however long he's away (if that is the case, I'm not sure if it is). There's a human element to it.
There are 3 list lodgement dates before the draft. If he's away they'll know when he gets back.And what about if he’s not back in Melbourne before October 31st?
We’re a better side with him in it but yeah, injuries.Setters survives for now. It's a pity he can't get consistency with his health. I think he's underrated.
Yes but when do you stop keeping players who can not stay on the park.Leadership, experience, training standards
i think by the third and final list lodgement date?Yes but when do you stop keeping players who can not stay on the park.
Third or final?i think by the third and final list lodgement date?