Anyone else think the 1990 Collingwood premiership team was/is highly overrated? I mean come on, Hawthorn was a far superior outfit that year, just decimated by injuries. The Pies were a team of honest battlers - nothing more, nothing less
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
1990...overrated
- Thread starter Hawks88bestever
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Status
- Sep 14, 2005
- 18,419
- 18,685
no, biggest load of bull********!! we're talking about a whole year of football.. a premiership isn't just a fluke so dont talk ********.. Collingwood was the best team that year.. check the history books and see who won the 1990 premiership and tell me what it saysHawks88bestever said:
..by the way, essendons team S.H.I.T all over hawthorns in those days
- Thread starter
- #3
PieLebo87 said:no, biggest load of bull********!! we're talking about a whole year of football.. a premiership isn't just a fluke so dont talk ********.. Collingwood was the best team that year.. check the history books and see who won the 1990 premiership and tell me what it says
..by the way, essendons team S.H.I.T all over hawthorns in those days
If Hawthorn had both Dunstall & Brereton fit all year they would have coasted to the premiership, yet again.
With a record 6 All Australian selections.Hawks88bestever said:
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
- Thread starter
- #5
Obviously a weak year for football if that is the case.bucksisbest said:
Hawks88bestever said:
I just checked your profile and you were ten in 1990. Care to tell us all what you remember about that season and why you think the Pies were lucky? By 1990 the Hawks were in serious decline and pinched the flag the following year from an Eagles outfit that had won 19 games in 1991 and would go onto win the flag in 1992.
Collingwood benefitted from having a draw with the Eagles during the finals but proved themselves the best team on the day that matters the most, Grand Final Day. The way Collingwood played on the first Saturday in October, no team would have beaten them.
- Thread starter
- #8
If Sumich could kick straight it never would have come to that. Clearly, as I said earlier, it was a poor year for football...Libba wins the Brownlow, Longmire the Coleman and Tony Shaw, of all people, was adjudged BOG in the Grand Final. Worst Norm Smith medallist in history and that includes the following year's recipient.Hotel 6 said:
Hawks88bestever said:
Most Premiers need a bit of luck during the year. Had Nick Davis not kicked a goal against Geelong with seconds to go the Swans would have been eliminated this year. Libba's Brownlow was a bit of a shock but when you lay as many tackles a game as he did you are bound to be noticed by the Umpires. Lonmire kicked 98 goals that year and in the final round booted 2 goals 8 behinds as North tried to get him to the ton that day. John Longmire was a very good Full Forward until he did his knee in 1996. Tony Shaw was clearly the best player on the ground in 1990 and thus deserved his Norm Smith. Not too many duds get to play 300 games, win a Norm Smith and captain a Premiership side.
- Thread starter
- #10
Scott Russell was BOG that day in my opinion...as for Longmire, Lockett & Dunstall (2 greatest full-forwards in history) missed a lot of games - enough said. Longmire was mediocre at best. Hawthorn deserved to win that year which would have made it four on the trot.
Drivel. Hawthorn did not "deserve" to do any such thing. You lost your last two matches (Round 22 and the Elimination Final) to Melbourne IIRC.Hawks88bestever said:
I'm not sure why you feel the need to denigrate the premiership team of 1990. I certainly don't think they were the greatest team of all time by any stretch of the imagination, but they were the best team that year and were the premiers. Nothing else matters.
This thread is funny
- Oct 8, 2004
- 13,088
- 5,909
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Collingwood VFL
Darren Millane won the AFLPA MVP that year, and Graham Wright should've won the Brownlow over Tony Liberatore.
Guys like McGuane, Francis, Russell, Brown and Daicos were all brilliant at what they do that year.
The fact that you call Tony Shaw the worst Norm Smith medallist in history just shows that you're a straight up idiot.
Guys like McGuane, Francis, Russell, Brown and Daicos were all brilliant at what they do that year.
The fact that you call Tony Shaw the worst Norm Smith medallist in history just shows that you're a straight up idiot.
jefffff34
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 20, 2001
- 17,832
- 4,290
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Who were the AA's?
Shaw, Millane, Brown, Daicos...?
Shaw, Millane, Brown, Daicos...?
That's about the only thing you've said which I agree with.Hawks88bestever said:
Other than that, she was a two horse race between the Bummers and the Mighty Magpies, and we timed our run to perfection.
In 1991, we could argue we gifted you a flag by being too hungover!
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
pocketrocket#24
Team Captain
Hawks88bestever said:
hmmm, so ur saying a fully fit lockett and dunstall would have reduced the number of goals kicked by longmire that year?? im assuming so coz thats wthe only way they may have beaten him... 98 goals is massive son, get a clue
Art Corvelay
Super Chief_
- Oct 4, 2004
- 13,686
- 26,812
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Victory, Pats, Celtics, Ricciardo
pocketrocket#24 said:
Didn't you know? There is a limit to how many goals can be kicked in a season, if Dunstall and Lockett had played then they would have used up some of Longmire's quota
Some Nong said:
Geez that is compelling arguement.
*Sending email to the AFL to give the Hawks the 1990 Premiership, as they clearly deserved it!*
Millane , Shaw (c) , Wright , Daicos , Russel ,McGuane.Hoggy said:
- Oct 5, 2004
- 14,145
- 7,088
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Rochester FC, Waroona FC, Pacers
Hawks88bestever said:
You honestly expect to come onto the Collingwood board and expect our supporters to say that we are overrated and didn't deserve it?
Hawthorn had injuries that year. So what? We could go through every year and make excuses for every team. Collingwood had its fair amount of misfortune over the years (Carmen's suspension, that contentious out of bounds), so it was about time the football Gods smiled on us. We had a very good year to finis 2nd, had a good top range of players and decent hardworking back-ups. The way we played in the last 3 finals, no one was going to beat us.
feck me collingwood pretty much had the entire AA midfieldbucksisbest said:
C: wright, shaw(c), millane
Foll : xxxx, mcguane, russell
yeah what an over-rated team!
Hawks88bestever said:
How do you know that? We had the double chance, and a loss against West Coast woudl not have ended our season.
We went in to the finals with the best form of any team , and played four outstanding finals games including three huge wins. The West Coast draw was of a very high standard. Sumich's miss was a dose of luck that evaded us for the previous thirty two years, but even if we lost that game we still would have been a big chance to win the flag.
- Status