2005 Mcleod/Roo Joint Brownlow Winners

[maccas_no1]

Imagine if it happened I'd have a hernia

 

[Damp Squarie]

Bring it on

It would mean we'd have a pretty good season if these two polled enough to win the medal.
I hope you're right

 

[maccas_no1]

I hope so it would be a fair effort

 

[macca23]

Imagine if it happened I'd have a hernia

So would I!! I'd only get $850 for my bet on Macca instead of $1700.

Go Macca!!

 

[maccas_no1]

So would I!! I'd only get $850 for my bet on Macca instead of $1700.

Go Macca!!

I reakon I might put a wager on macca, think he may just break the shackles this year

 

[LiaLovesRoo32]

I feel like I have had this conversation before Marty

Would be mighty cool though.....I will be happy with either one

 

[Stiffy_18]

So would I!! I'd only get $850 for my bet on Macca instead of $1700.

Go Macca!!

That makes 2 of us

Go Bunji

 

[maccas_no1]

I feel like I have had this conversation before Marty

Would be mighty cool though.....I will be happy with either one

Yes your right you gave me the thought of this great possibility

 

[portentous]

Tell 'em they're dreaming.....

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Tell 'em they're dreaming.....

I prefer to dream about premierships than Brownlows.

I can't recall 2 players from the side winning a Brownlow - would be rather difficult to do, given they would be taking votes from each other.

 

[tredders16]

I prefer to dream about premierships than Brownlows.

I can't recall 2 players from the side winning a Brownlow - would be rather difficult to do, given they would be taking votes from each other.

Hypothetically, what would have to happen for this to be possible?

When Roo won with Goodes and Figgy in 2003 did they poll 22 votes each?
Wangas, Crawf and Cousins missed out by one vote so there could have been six winners in one season.

For two to win from one club on the 2003 scale they would have to poll 44 votes between them. This means 7 BOG's each and a third preference as well. Meaning they would have to poll in 16 games in 22. The percentages are against you immediately for this to occur. Considering Adelaide are not tipped by the "Experts" to even make the eight in 2005, the possibility is laughable and extremely doubtful.

The Brisbane Lions couldn't do it in 2001-03 with their famed midfield so I cant see Adelaide being the first.

 

[jo172]

True but Sturt managed it in 2002? with Timmy Weathrald and Jade Sheedy, so it's possible although unlikely

 

[tredders16]

True but Sturt managed it in 2002? with Timmy Weathrald and Jade Sheedy, so it's possible although unlikely

So did the Magpies with Tony Brown and Ryan O'Connor in 01

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

The Magpies did it aswell with Ryan O'Connor and Tony Brown. From memory I dont think the Magpies had such a crash hot season either but I may be wrong.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

So did the Magpies with Tony Brown and Ryan O'Connor in 01

Bastard...got me by a nose haha

 

[Mong]

When Roo won with Goodes and Figgy in 2003 did they poll 22 votes each?
Wangas, Crawf and Cousins missed out by one vote so there could have been six winners in one season.

And McLeod wasn't far behind them. And he had a poor second half to the year.

It'll never happen (both winning together), but in 2003 it wasn't all that far off.


****