2007 Player Review

[Drummond]

2007 Player Review:

Nathan Bassett:

2007 Games: 13
2007 Totals/Averages: 201 possessions (15.46), 93 marks (7.15).

No one really knew just how important he was to our team until he went down with what turned out to be a season ending ankle injury. Bassett will be 31 next season so there’s a chance he could call it quits at the end of 2008, especially if injuries restrict him again. An extremely important part of our team who we need to be healthy in order to achieve success.

Verdict: Crucial member of the team but getting on in age and must stay fit next season.


Rhett Biglands:

2007 Games: 0
2007 Totals/Averages: N/A

Rhett missed the entire 2007 season after suffering an ACL injury in last year’s preliminary final. While he was out the young ruckman of the club all showed impressed signs which should spell the end of his time with the club. Unfortunately considering he is still under contract for a further 12 months he is unlikely to be cut despite the fact he offers very little.

Verdict: Should be delisted as we have enough ruck stocks, but he’ll stay on next year and continue to play mediocre football.


Nathan Bock:

2007 Games: 22
2007 Totals/Averages: 316 possessions (14.36), 93 marks (6.18), 29 goals.

Still only 24, Bock continued his development this season but perhaps not at the rate some expected. He played up forward and in defence and appears to be more suited to CHB. However he kicked 29 goals and kicked multiple goals on 9 occasions. Bock is one of the few first 22 middle aged players on our list so he is a key component of the team and will be for many years to come.

Verdict: Perhaps more was expected but had a solid season and he looks set to be our CHB in 2008.


Matthew Bode:

2007 Games: 1
2007 Totals/Averages: 12 possessions (12), 3 marks (3), 1 goal.

After arguably a career best year in 2006 as a small forward, Bode had a year to forget in 2007. He had an injury interrupted start to the season but managed to play in Round 2. However it was his lone appearance of the season and he missed the remainder of the year due to a knee injury. When Bode is patrolling the forward line we look a lot more potent up forward but unfortunately injuries are starting to mount. When he’s fit and firing there are few more important players to the team, but the trouble is getting on the park.

Verdict: Will need to stay fit in 2008 because he’s already had 4 seasons with fewer than 10 appearances.


Brett Burton:

2007 Games: 17
2007 Totals/Averages: 223 possessions (13.11), 99 marks (5.82), 24 goals.

At his best Burton is a damaging forward, capable of kicking a bag but unfortunately he was well below his best this season. In the first half of the season Burton struggled with a knee injury that eventually required surgery. I’m not sure what the benefit was in him playing the first 8 weeks but nonetheless it contributed to a substandard year. He is one of the most frustrating players in the team because while he contributes, his brain fades are all too costly.

Verdict: Should be trade bait as despite the fact he can still be a key player, at 29 and with dodgy knees his best days are well and truly behind him.


Bryce Campbell:

2007 Games: 1
2007 Totals/Averages: 8 possessions (8), 4 marks (4).

Campbell endured a nightmare first pre-season with the Crows. He had shoulder surgery, back troubles and injured an ankle which kept him out of action for 10 weeks. Campbell is a fierce tackler and big ball winner with good skills and will provide more midfield options. Due to his limited pre-season he struggled to run out games and as a result his form at times was indifferent. In a season where not a lot went his way he did well to make his AFL debut.

Verdict: With a big pre-season he will be looking to cement a spot in Adelaide’s 22 in 2008.


Michael Doughty:

2007 Games: 19
2007 Totals/Averages: 353 possessions (18.57), 89 marks (4.68).

Doughty had a poor season and as a result many have gone past him on the pecking order. After a very slow start to the season he gradually picked up his play but fell away towards the latter stages and found himself out of the team when it really mattered. There’s no disputing the fact that he can find the ball but his disposal isn’t overly damaging and he kicked just the 2 goals for the season. If retained Doughty will need to secure a place early in the season or else he’ll find himself in trouble.

Verdict: Should be traded/delisted but due to the fact he can still contribute unfortunately he’ll more than likely be retained.


Richard Douglas:

2007 Games: 13
2007 Totals/Averages: 140 possessions (10.76), 28 marks (2.15), 36 tackles (2.76)

With exceptional form in the trial matches, Douglas was expected to take the next step this season. Unfortunately he didn’t and found himself in and out of the side all year. In over half of his 13 outings he failed to have 10+ possessions and on the whole he struggled to adapt to the pace of the game. He has the tendency to put his teammate under pressure but with time this should be eradicated. Still only very slight he must put on at least 5kg’s which would benefit him enormously. He did show his potential with some good performances in the SANFL, including a 7 goal haul.

Verdict: Douglas needs to have more of an impact in 2008 and once and for all consolidate his spot in the side.


Tyson Edwards:

2007 Games: 23
2007 Totals/Averages: 580 possessions (25.21), 132 marks (5.73), 93 tackles (4.04)

At 30 years of age Edwards is approaching the latter stages of his career but he managed to play all 23 games in 2007. He still found a heap of the ball and was one of our most dominant midfielders but his ball usage and decision making was at times well below what we’ve come to expect. His performance in the QF was brilliant so there’s no doubt he’s still got another year or two left, but there’s little doubt his role will start to decline as more youngsters make their mark.

Verdict: The decline has begun but he’s still got a lot to offer.


Nick Gill:

2007 Games: 7
2007 Totals/Averages: 89 possessions (12.71), 45 marks (6.42), 9 goals.

Gill was perhaps the surprise packet of the year. Few expected him to make much of an impact but to his credit he played the final 7 games and had an impact. He kicked at least 1 goal in every outing and at times proved to be a good option up forward. With good athleticism and a great pair of hands, there’s a lot to work with but he must work extensively on his kicking.

Verdict: Good debut season but must build on the platform next season.


Simon Goodwin:

2007 Games: 21
2007 Totals/Averages: 516 possessions (24.57), 91 marks (4.33), 10 goals.

Goodwin had yet another outstanding season. He had 7 games with 30+ possessions including a career high 39 against Port. He missed 2 games with a knee injury and without the two games where he combined for 5 possessions he would’ve averaged 27 possessions per game. Doesn’t get the recognition he deserves but had another fine season and why he was overlooked for AA status is beyond me.

Verdict: Soon to be 31 but he continues to find the ball and should be captain in 2008.


Jonathon Griffin:

2007 Games: 16
2007 Totals/Averages: 96 possessions (6), 42 marks (2.62), 142 hit-outs (8.87).

Few expected Griffin to even make his debut in 2007 and yet he played the most games of all our ruckman bar Hudson. He started the season very well and endured a great 3 week stretch where he averaged 10 possessions, 10 hit-outs and a goal a game. Unfortunately as the season wore on his impact declined, and he found himself back in the SANFL for over a month. While there his impact was minimal, and yet for some reason he was recalled and was our back-up ruckman for R22 and in the final. Overall he achieved more than was to be expected but after a good opening 2 months he was ineffective thereafter.

Verdict: Still needs another 10kg but it’s clear he has the potential to be a solid AFL ruckman.


Trent Hentschel:

2007 Games: 0
2007 Totals/Averages: N/A

Trent suffered a horrific knee injury late in 2006 and as a result missed the entire season. He is still on the mend and hopes to be available for Adelaide’s NAB Cup campaign. Prior to the injury he was finally developing into the key forward many had expected and at 24 he still has time on his side.

Verdict: Recently signed a new 2 year deal so the club obviously has faith that he can make a successful recovery.


John Hinge:

2007 Games: 1
2007 Totals/Averages: 11 possessions (11), 1 mark (1).

After some solid form with Glenelg in the SANFL, Hinge finally got the call up to make his AFL debut against Collingwood. He looked comfortable with the pace of the game however he suffered a hamstring injury and never really got his season back on track. He failed to play another game and his form with the Bays was indifferent. However he’s one thing we have very few of, a midfielder with height so despite the fact he’s been on the list for 3 years and only played a solitary game, he could develop into a solid player. Hinge is prone to making awful skill errors, especially by foot, and for him to survive this must improve.

Verdict: A tall utility, Hinge should be retained and if so has the chance to become a solid member of the Adelaide side.


Ben Hudson:

2007 Games: 22
2007 Totals/Averages: 293 possessions (13.31), 81 marks (3.68), 366 hit-outs (16.63).

Hudson made a successful return to the AFL following a year out with a knee injury. Hudson ranked high in the league amongst contested possession and hard-ball gets. His ruckwork was good and he contributed around the ground. He only kicked the one goal all year which must improve and he had his lowest possession count for the season in the final of his career. But on the whole he had a great year and there aren’t too many ruckman who offer more than Hudson does.

Verdict: 2007 was a very good year and will be looking to improve further next season.


Luke Jericho:

2007 Games: 6
2007 Totals/Averages: 79 possessions (13.16), 37 marks (6.16), 4 goals

Jericho had another average season and should be delisted or traded at seasons end. Other than his game against the Blues he never stood out and looked as though he should be a first choice player. Unfortunately he still lacks the commitment and desperation to force himself into the team and it appears unlikely this will ever improve. He played some good football for Norwood but he didn’t do enough to warrant another year on the list.

Verdict: Time is up and it’s best we moved on. Simply lacks the hunger and commitment to be a consistent AFL performer.


Graham Johncock:

2007 Games: 17
2007 Totals/Averages: 295 possessions (17.35), 84 marks (4.94).

Johncock suffered a severe ankle injury in Round 2 which kept him out for 6 weeks. As a result his form throughout the year was up and down and he struggled to gain much momentum. Looked like the damaging player we’ve come to expect in some games (career high 31 possessions v Geelong) but unfortunately on the whole it wasn’t his best year. Soon to be 25 and with 126 games under his belt, Johncock should be entering his prime in the next year or two.

Verdict: Somewhat disappointing season but will bounce back better next year.


Chris Knights:

2007 Games: 22
2007 Totals/Averages: 515 possessions (23.40), 123 marks (5.59), 60 tackles (2.72)

Knights had a fantastic third year at AFL level. After only playing 12 games in his first two years combined, Knights finally cemented his spot in the side and became an important part of the midfield mix. Very few 20 year-old’s gather over 500 possessions but Knights did just that. His disposal continues to let him down at times, but on the whole he improved in this area a great deal. His conversion rate in front of goal was 29% which is a worry and if he could inflict more damage on the scoreboard as well as tidy up his disposal he could become a great midfielder. His tackle count was also well up on the past reflecting more defensive awareness.

Verdict: Terrific third season, and with more attention to his disposal he could be a great midfielder for the AFC.


David Mackay:

2007 Games: 0
2007 Totals/Averages: N/A

Mackay played only 2 games all year, one for South Adelaide reserves and the other a league game. In the reserves he gathered 25 possessions and in his league debut he managed 21 possessions and was high amongst the best. He has good skills, great poise and the vision to be a good wingman for the club. Constant hamstring injuries ruined his first year with the Crows and if he had of remained fit, chances are he would’ve made his debut at the top level.

Verdict: A highly skilled player who just needs time in the SANFL and to add some weight.


Ivan Maric:

2007 Games: 6
2007 Totals/Averages: 43 possessions (7.16), 18 marks (3), 48 hit-outs (8), 5 goals.

Maric suffered a hip injury prior to the start of the season and was out of action for about 6 weeks. He had a late start and his first 5 weeks in the SANFL were underwhelming. He gradually improved and managed to break into the Crows team in Round 14. He held his place for 6 weeks before he was dropped. Maric had a reasonably poor year considering the progress he made in 2006, and he has still yet to gain 10 possessions in a match. His ruckwork is sound and he proved to be a handy option up forward, but he needs to stamp himself on games more in order to take the next step.

Verdict: Still yet to cement his spot in the side, 2008 looms as a big year for Maric who needs to make the back-up ruck position his.


Kris Massie:

2007 Games: 12
2007 Totals/Averages: 178 possessions (14.83), 71 marks (5.91).

First and foremost Massie is a midfielder. His form with Norwood as a midfielder was outstanding and his first game of the year for the Crows he had 21 possessions and 8 marks in limited game time highlighted his worth. But unfortunately the club sees him mainly as a defender and while he can play a role down there, he’s suited to the midfield. Massie is a great clubman and he gives 100% every time he steps out onto the field, it’s too bad some crucify him whenever he makes a mistake.

Verdict: A solid player who once coming into the side was a good contributor. I would like to see him in more of a midfield role in 2008.


Martin Mattner:

2007 Games:
2007 Totals/Averages: 291 possessions (15.31), 83 marks (4.36), 44 tackles (2.31)

Mattner has officially been ruined as a player thanks to Craig and co. At his best Mattner is a damaging wingman capable of breaking the lines and his long raking left foot is a danger to opposition teams. Unfortunately he’s been forced to play in defence which is clearly not a position Mattner has taken a liking to. If he remains a Crow in 2008, it will be in the best interests of both Mattner and the club for him to return to the wing.

Verdict: Had a shocking year thanks to the stubbornness of the coaching staff and their refusal to play him in his natural position.


Ken McGregor:

2007 Games: 19
2007 Totals/Averages: 86 possessions (9.55), 38 marks (4.22), 18 goals.

McGregor has fallen out of favour at West Lakes and it’s a shame because he offers this team something we have very little of, a forward capable of taking a mark and kicking straight. From 20 shots on goal his conversion rate of 90% was outstanding and in 6 of his 9 games he kicked multiple goals. Might not be a great athlete or have the longest kick, but he is a versatile player who receives too much criticism.

Verdict: When he played he was good, it’s just that he played a mere 9 games and looks likely to be on the trade table.


Andrew McIntyre:

2007 Games: 0
2007 Totals/Averages: N/A

McIntyre started the year on the rookie list, but was elevated after a month and was close to an AFL debut. However he suffered an ankle/leg injury which forced him out for 6 weeks. When he returned he struggled to regain form and other than a few games here and there, his form has been well below what initially got him upgraded. He will be looking to gain some form for North Adelaide in the SANFL finals.

Verdict: Fell away after the serious injury which halted his season. Good chance to be on the senior list in 2008, but needs to work on his intensity.


Andrew McLeod:

2007 Games: 23
2007 Totals/Averages: 550 possessions (23.91), 81 marks (3.52).

McLeod had another outstanding year playing mainly in defence and providing great rebound. Averaged close to 24 possessions and had over 30 touches on 4 occasions, including a career high 39. He was the lone Crow to make the AA squad of 40 and he is also a big chance to the lead the Crows in the Brownlow count.

Verdict: 31 years of age but still playing some of his best football and will be around for another 2 years.


John Meesen:

2007 Games: 2
2007 Totals/Averages: 8 possessions (4), 2 marks (1), 12 hit-outs (6).

Expected to make his mark early in the season, Meesen injured his knee in the NAB Cup which kept him out for 10 weeks. He returned through the SANFL reserves and was there for 4-5 weeks. He struggled to overcome his knee injury but finally made his return to senior level. He played a few great games for Norwood and he kicked 6 goals in 2 games to put his name up for selection. Not long after he made his long awaited AFL debut, and despite very little game time he showed some signs to indicate he will be a good ruckman at the top level.

Verdict: On the whole had an ordinary year mainly due to injury. Likely to seek a trade back home, a terrible result for the Crows who could be hurt by his departure in the future.


Ian Perrie:

2007 Games: 14
2007 Totals/Averages: 150 possessions (10.71), 86 marks (6.14), 17 goals.

A much maligned player, Perrie had a nightmare season and it could spell the end of his career with Adelaide. In 10 of his 14 games he kicked 1 goal or less and for a key forward that’s a very poor return. He’s done well to manage over 100 AFL games but Gill seems to have taken his place and youngsters Tippett and Sellar will be given an opportunity.

Verdict: At 28 years of age, and considering he was in and out of the side, it’s hard to see him being around next year.


Darren Pfeiffer:

2007 Games: 0
2007 Totals/Averages: N/A

After a good pre-season and a solid string of trial matches, Pfeiffer appeared set for a good season. But a broken jaw, glandular fever and breaking the curfew all stopped him from ever really gaining the momentum required to make his AFL debut. He hit back late in the season with a superb month of footy playing on the HBF. An extremely versatile player who likes to back himself and take the opposition on, Pfeiffer is something the Crows currently lack.

Verdict: Still only a teenager, Pfeiffer has huge potential and with a bit of luck will break into the team either as a running defender or a wingman.


Jason Porplyzia:

2007 Games: 15
2007 Totals/Averages: 205 possessions (13.66), 56 marks (3.73), 15 goals.

Porplyzia continues to develop and is now a first choice player at the Crows. His marking ability is his major strength but the only worry is his inability to stay fit for long periods. Put together 6 consecutive games to finish the season and in the process kicked 8 goals and provided a valuable target up forward. Needs to work hard on his fitness over the pre-season so he can spend some time in the midfield.

Verdict: Had a reasonably good year but just needs to get fitter and work on his kicking in front of goal.


Brent Reilly:

2007 Games: 17
2007 Totals/Averages: 321 possessions (18.88), 81 marks (4.76), 41 tackles (2.41).

Reilly put together a great first month however he suffered an ankle injury which hampered him for 8 weeks. Taking out the two games where he was injured early, he averaged 21 possessions and had a career high 39 against the Lions. Now firmly established in the midfield group, Reilly took the next step in 2007 and is one of the future leaders of the club.

Verdict: When fit Reilly played great football and on the whole he had a very good year. Has the finest skills in the team and is entering the prime of his career.


Mark Ricciuto:

2007 Games: 9
2007 Totals/Averages: 101 possessions (11.22), 30 marks (3.33), 12 goals.

In what was to be his last season Riccituo had an awful season. Only played the 9 games and in very few of them was he actually fit. Gave it his all but his body couldn’t take much more. Kicked multiple goals in 4 games, including 4 against the Hawks in Round 14. He bowed out in the QF after playing only 30% of the game with stats of 4 possessions and 2 behinds. A sad way to end what was a remarkable career.

Verdict: An injury interrupted final season for the greatest player in AFC history.


Ben Rutten:

2007 Games: 20
2007 Totals/Averages: 259 possessions (12.95), 113 marks (5.65).

Rutten had another great year at FB and was unlucky to miss AA selection as many overlooked his brilliant start to the season. Barely had a goal kicked on him for the first 7 rounds and his opponents averaged 1.6 goals per game for the season. Solid as a rock in defence, he was also only kept below 10 possessions on two occasions.

Verdict: Perhaps a future captain, Rutten continues to shut down the opposition’s best forward week in, week out.


James Sellar:

2007 Games: 0
2007 Totals/Averages: N/A

In his first season with the Crows, Sellar had a very disappointing season. He suffered from OP for the majority of the season and he struggled to overcome the debilitating injury. Played 7 league games for Glenelg and kicked 11 goals but he never really had much of an impact. Missed 6 weeks with the groin injury but after his stint with the league team he played out the season in the reserves. Sellar will be hoping for a big pre-season to build up a fitness base that is required to play at the top level.

Verdict: Disappointing first season for the talented KPP, but being only 18 years of age he has plenty of time on his side.


Robert Shirley:

2007 Games: 20
2007 Totals/Averages: 363 possessions (18.15), 64 marks (3.20), 81 tackles (4.05).

Shirley had a solid start to the season and did some great tagging jobs however his form declined and he was dropped for a week. He hit back with some terrific performances and not only did he find a lot of the ball (77 possessions in 3 weeks) but he shut down some big name midfielders. Shirley is vital at getting first possession at the clearances and his tackle count of 81 was very impressive.

Verdict: Great form late but must continue the form in 2008 to continue demanding a spot in the side.


Scott Stevens:

2007 Games: 23
2007 Totals/Averages: 334 possessions (14.52), 141 marks (6.13), 15 goals.

Stevens has a very solid year and managed to play all 23 games. Despite spending the majority of the year in defence he still managed to kick 15 goals. Receives a lot of scrutiny but he gets the job done each week and his ability to lend a hand to other defenders can’t be overlooked.

Verdict: Only 25 and is starting to play the best football of his career.


Scott Thompson:

2007 Games: 23
2007 Totals/Averages: 580 possessions (25.21), 132 marks (5.73), 101 tackles (4.39), 16 goals.

Played all 23 games and led the Crows in possessions and tackles. 6 games with 30+ touches and only had 4 games with fewer than 20. Doesn’t have the greatest skills and isn’t the best decision maker but his work around the stoppages and his ball winning ability is second to none. Only 24 years of age and was unlucky to miss AA selection but should win the Crows B&F. Cops a lot of flack for his clanger count but Thompson is one of the superior players at the AFC.

Verdict: Fantastic year, great consistency and would be my choice for the next long term captain of the club.


Kurt Tippett:

2007 Games: 0
2007 Totals/Averages: N/A

Tippett was forced to wear a neck brace for a few weeks in the pre-season after a training mishap. Unfortunately his luck didn’t get much better as he injured a shoulder which required surgery about halfway though the season. His form for West Adelaide wasn’t too bad but Tippett, recruited as a forward, was played mainly in the ruck. A great athlete with terrific speed and a great contested mark, Tippett could be the one to watch in 2008.

Verdict: Had a season to forget mainly due to injury, but he will be one youngster expected to make a mark in 2008.


Jason Torney:

2007 Games: 23
2007 Totals/Averages: 354 possessions (15.39), 127 marks (5.52), 59 tackles (2.56)

Perhaps the most underrated player on the Crows squad, Torney had another extremely solid year. Shut down some forwards while averaging over 15 possessions per game and providing great rebound. Also kicked 7 goals and towards the latter stages of the season he started playing a more attacking role.

Verdict: Another solid season for Torney who at 30, still has at least another year or two left in the game.


Nathan van Berlo:

2007 Games: 23
2007 Totals/Averages: 434 possessions (18.86), 98 marks (4.26), 75 tackles (3.26).

van Berlo played all 23 games in 2007 and has become a very valuable midfielder. Started to become a more attacking player and he averaged close to 20 possessions per game. His tackling and 1%’s were a feature of his game and he looks set to be a 200+ gamer and a potential captain of the club. One of the fittest players at the club, VB needs to work on his finishing in front of goal to take the next step.

Verdict: At 21 and with 53 games in the bank, van Berlo is a potential captain and on the back of a great season he looks set to become a key player for the future.


Bernie Vince:

2007 Games: 6
2007 Totals/Averages: 59 possessions (9.83), 15 marks (2.50).

Vince had a disappointing second season with the Crows. He played just the 6 games and struggled to have much of an impact. Couldn’t find much of the ball and for someone who’s played mostly as a small forward, he’s kicked just the 2 goals in 10 games. Vince is another who needs to have a big pre-season so he can work his way into the midfield mix which is clearly his best position where his hands and knack of weaving through traffic are beneficial.

Verdict: A quieter year than was to be expected, but he played some great SANFL football which will leave him with a lot of confidence.


Scott Welsh:

2007 Games: 21
2007 Totals/Averages: 208 possessions (9.90), 91 marks (4.33), 49 goals.

Entering the year with a performance based contract, Welsh needed to deliver or else he was done. He responded in fine fashion with 49 goals which led the club and it was the second highest tally of his career. His conversion rate of 71% was elite and on 7 occasions he kicked 4 or more goals. His body will always be a concern but as long as he remains fit he will continue to be our #1 forward.

Verdict: Despite what some critics may say Welsh had a good season and was one shy of the 50 goal barrier. Unlike many of his teammates he is extremely reliable in front of goal and will receive another contract in 2008.

 

[out of order]

**** me did u write that drummond?

 

[earlsta]

Drummond returns with a BANG

lol

WB Drummond now I'm gonna start reading

 

[Southerntakeover]

Not a bad review.

Im interested though, what did you expect for Vinces season? Im not sure i expected him to play 6 games personally, so i think it was a fairly productive year for him, considering where hes at with his development.

 

[out of order]

Not a bad review.

Im interested though, what did you expect for Vinces season? Im not sure i expected him to play 6 games personally, so i think it was a fairly productive year for him, considering where hes at with his development.

dont know about that he didnt really earn those games, he only got them cause of injuries he just needs a full preseason.

 

[Southerntakeover]

dont know about that he didnt really earn those games, he only got them cause of injuries he just needs a full preseason.

No, he probably didnt at the start of the year, though id suggest hed earned games towards the end of the year that he didnt recieve, so maybe it balanced out.

That wasnt really my point though. I didnt really expect Vince to play much this year, and he got 6 games in the side, which he'll be the better for in the long run, even if his performances showed his inexperience. In terms of his development, it probably wasnt a bad year for him.

 

[Mego Red]

I don't think I could possibly read something that long -






But I think it is AWESOME that you spent your whole time away from the board drafting these long posts, Drumm.

 

[Asgardian]

Nathan Bock:

2007 Games: 22
2007 Totals/Averages: 316 possessions (14.36), 93 marks (6.18), 29 goals.

Still only 24, Bock continued his development this season but perhaps not at the rate some expected. He played up forward and in defence and appears to be more suited to CHB. However he kicked 29 goals and kicked multiple goals on 9 occasions. Bock is one of the few first 22 middle aged players on our list so he is a key component of the team and will be for many years to come.

Verdict: Perhaps more was expected but had a solid season and he looks set to be our CHB in 2008.

I reckon Bock would benefit from being settled into just one position, let him grow into the position without the worry of going all over the shop.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Thanks Drummond ....id you don't mind I'll use your template to post my thoughts:

Nathan Bassett:
Has been great since freeing up from FB ......but as Drummond said he's 31 and subject to more frequent injuries. COULD have 2 seasons remaining but it must be a priority to get some QUALITY youth into the back half ....what with Hart gone, Bassett and Torney on the wrong side of 30.
Most importantly he is a "general" in that back half ....that's hard to replace.
Verdict: Crucial member of the team but getting on in age and must stay fit next season.

Rhett Biglands:
Introduction of circle took away his advantage of charging in and jumping into the opposing ruckman. Knees affect your leaping so a big ? next season. More likely to be a forward option .....yes he was getting a bit better there, never will be fantastic ....but more likely a backup.
Verdict: Big unknown until all delistings and trades are completed. If we lose Perrie and McGregor ....his importnace may rise ....but only in short term

Nathan Bock:
Still only 24, Bock Promises to be a genuine star ....but regularly fails to deliver. Has flexibility at both ends but prefers straight ahead style associated with CHB. Is mentally fragile .....that is he can be really switched on OR he can have "back in 5 minutes" on his brain.
At times has made idiotic decisions and nees to really work on his mental toughness .....at 24 if he can toughen up he'll be an absolute star
Verdict: Has failed to take that next step to controlling a game

Matthew Bode:
1 season out of 3 is not good enough and at 28 years of age all does not look good for him. Will be a calculated risk by Crows to keep him ....we desperately need to cull some of the older players rather than all go at once ....on that basis and the fact we're not a realistic falg chance next season I think we'll let him go
Verdict: To be delisted

Brett Burton:
Great player ...had an average season mainly with injuries to an athlete who is getting older. We may have now seen the best of Brett. His game is built on athleticism and he has shown this year if that is impaired he has no other tricks as he's a lightly built 182cm player?
Is he of value to a developing team because of his leadership?
OR does he have some trade value?
Verdict: Should be trade bait as despite the fact he can still be a key player, at 29 and with dodgy knees his best days are well and truly behind him.

Bryce Campbell:
Bryce is a dime a dozen mid size vanilla type player who was drafted for depth. That makes him very vulnerable at delisting time.
Is there anything super special about him .....no!
Verdict: Delist

Michael Doughty:
Had a poor pre-season due to injury. I have been a huge fan due to his solid skills and the fact you know what you were going to get each week with Michael.
However he has had MANY games where he has disappeared from games and as a depth player that puts him at risk.
Vince & Pfieffer likely to take his role so his future likely to be decided by list management.
Verdict: 50/50 to be retained.

Richard Douglas:
Poor first half of season and very average output in his Crows games. However towards seasons end started to get to right positions at foot of packs and started to show some class in the midfield ...albeit at SANFL level.
Verdict: Natural maturation and another PS will see Richard have a good 2008

Tyson Edwards:
Very important player and whilst I agree there is some falloff in performance ....generally he's as safe as houses. On this seasons form you'd say barring injury he has another 2 seasons left in him. He doesn't get injured much at all and that will prolong his career.
Verdict: The decline has begun but he’s still got a lot to offer.

Nick Gill:
No PS at all ....Gill has been a revelation ....not because of his marking and shocking kicking but his work ethic ....which may not be good for Bode.
A good PS and getting used to the pace of AFL will see his marking skills come more into play. A real X - Factor who will replace Perrie OR is he more a replacement for Burtons forwrd role? .....this will be discussed in any potential trades particularly on Burton's future.
Don't really see him as a premiership KP player ...more the third tall. Also can see him as a backup CHB to Bock if injured ....all plus's and a good draft selection by the Crows.
Verdict: Good debut season but must build on the platform next season.

Simon Goodwin:
Is great when injury free ...but Goody has a career where he has had serious injury on a semi regular basis. IF he remians injury free he has another 2 seasons but if he gets injured we may see a Roo type decline.
Definately has slowed down and may be getting to a point where he goes back to his original position of HBF to play out his career.
Will probably be captain BUT I'm not sure he needs that at this stage of his career?????
Verdict: We'll know more early next season about his longevity

Jonathon Griffin:
Started the first half of the season as a revelation ....maybe on us supporters side our expectations of him was low ....so was he that good?
Certainly Luenbergers first season stamped him as a star ruckman and if you compare Griffins performances to his you'd say ....it was an average season and a LONG way to go.
Has a great leap ....I agree needs another 10 kgs and there has always been a ? on his ability to put that on.
Needs to use his athleticism around the ground more ...be more involved.

Will say watching the Hawthorn Final .....Griffin was largely ingnored as a go to option. The Crows just do not play thru their ruckman in ground play wheras Eagles use Cox as a linkman.
Not sure if this is Craigs rules or players just do not have confidence in Griffin BUT it was very very noticable as he was open many times having made great position.
Verdict: Still needs another 10kg but it’s clear he has the potential to be a solid AFL ruckman.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

John Hinge:
Jury is out .... he looks to have some good skills ... is a good mark and quite quick for a tallish player.
But he won't be a dominating player at SANFL or AFL level as he seems to play the support role doing all the sheperding and knock ons ect.
Can see him as a stenglein type player at AFL level and maybe that's OK as long as our expectations are not too great with the kid.
Verdict: A tall utility, Hinge should be retained and if so has the chance to become a solid member of the Adelaide side.

Ben Hudson:
Had a reasonable year ....not a dominating ruckman but nullified well and given our inexperience in the ruck division it was critical he stood up ....and he did.
Not as strong on clearances as b4 his knee but better than most other AFL ruckman ....he has great leadership skills and is an integral member of the fabric of the team
Verdict: 2007 was a very good year and will be looking to improve further next season.

Luke Jericho:
Hard year for Luke .....I started off PS as a supporter believing he would have a change of attitude to the game ......I jumped off when he clearly showed he had learned nothing even though his AFL career was at the crossroads.
Then strangley enough the last handful of games for Norwood he showed some full bodied, two handed attacks on the ball that had been missing.
Maybe too late for Luke though and I'd say I'm struggling to see a fulltime role in the rows side either at HB, Wing or forward
Verdict: Trade or Delist

Graham Johncock:
Not a good year and has stagnated. Has he lost some of his hunger for the game .....will that manifest itself even more in 2008?
Certainly does not committ himself to recovery from injuries as others and when you look at the bodyshape comparison of himself and Macleod it reflects his attitude to the game and self improvement.
Would you trade him for Didak ......you'd think about it
Verdict: Capable of so much more ....could be a great of the Crows with the right attitude

Chris Knights:
Has a great attitude to his footy and is quick, tallish and has some tricks to his game.
Needs to tackle better and get the disposal under pressure much better .....it's a technique issue and that's always hard to change but a midfielder with poor disposal is an increasing liability in todays game.
Played the full season and that shows what the Crows management think of him ....remember his still only has played just on 30 games so his best is well in front of him.
Verdict: An even better 2008

David Mackay:
Has to be the longest Hamstring injury in history?
I know he re-injured a couple of times but it wasn't torn off the bone was it?
Saw some training photos and his photo showed no weight gain ....would have thought with a hamstring of that duration it would have been a perfect opportunity to hit the gym rooms
Could be an excleent surprise next season as he's highly skilled.
Verdict: Wasted year ....essentially first year next season

Ivan Maric:
Has me puzzled ......his second half games at Port and Crows ...he was leaping well, taking good marks and I was very very surprised Griffin got the nod over him for the last few games.
Believe he doesn't have a huge tank and maybe that was a consideration going into the finals?
Still genuinely excited by Maric and he's getting better and better
Verdict: Looking forward to 2008

Kris Massie:
Less injuries in recent seasons and some good PS campaigns have dramtically changed Massies body shape and his speed over the ground.
Is making less gaffs on the field and has become a valuable contributor.
Dead cert for retention in 2008 and playing the best footy of his career.
Verdict: At the top of his game

Martin Mattner:
Could be trade bait ....which is disappointing but the nature of AFL.
Was an average season and Marty has to lay blame at his own feet for that.
Whatever was being asked of him by the coaching panel ....he wasn't delivering and Massie overtook him.
Gone is the great bone shaking tackles ???...why?
Yes IMO he's a better attacking player off the wing and even as a HFF where his sidestepping moves could produce gaols and his defensive action inside our forward 50 could be invaluable?
Verdict: An important year in 2008 for his future

Ken McGregor:
Players who you have to sit the ball on their head so they can mark are dinasuers. No leap ....the hands in the back rule has worked against him as your gong to see more early leaps to compensate.
Has been increasingly injury prone and that reduces his athleticism even more.
Now simply a depth player and more than likely will be traded.
Verdict: Important trade component for 2007 if we are to boost our list.

Andrew McIntyre:
Amazing what confidence can do.
At the seasons start this kid looked a million dollars ....after injury you looked at him and said ....Meh!
So which is the real Andrew McIntyre .....the first half season player or the second half?
Has very good hands, good mark and disposal ......could be a Hart type player and valuable to an aging backline.
Verdict: Jury out

Andrew McLeod:
On this years for and his committment to looking after his body .....you'd say he has maybe another 3 seasons of footy.
Would not surprise me one bit to see him win the Brownlow given his consistency
Verdict: A great year ....probably one of his best

 

[21knights]

Thanks Drummond. Great post.

 

[CaptainDangerfield]

Good summaries lads. Just on Griffen. In the main I was actually disappointed with his year overall. He looked really good in a few games but his second half of the year, in both the SANFL and then the AFL, was pretty average. He really needs to pick it up a cog next year. IMO he is too thin to play mainly as a ruckman but could be a damaging player if played predominately up forward.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

John Meesen:
Will be very disappointed if we lose him .....in 3 years time this kid will be a very very good player.
He needs more strength and 10 kgs to go on that athletic frame PLUS a more agreesive attitude that comes with the extra strength.
But do we wait the 3 years or trade him knowing we have two fine ruckman plus hudson who has another 3 years in him .....and recruit another project ruckman and put 3 years into him?
Club has said a bird in the hand .....so the decision is Meesens
Verdict: Has come back well from injury and made improvements

Ian Perrie:
17 goals from 14 games as a key forward is not a good return.
If as reported his knees are shot then that can explain his performances.
Been a great workhorse but we've seen his poor attitude come out in the times he has gone back to North Adelaide and been less than satisfactory as a player.
With Tippett, Sellar, Maric, Biglands, and Gill likely to get games in the forward line next season ......maybe the will and body has waned to the point of saying "enough is enough"
Verdict: Has been a valuable servant of the club and should be acknowledged as such

Darren Pfeiffer:
Has all the skills and ability to be a top AFL footballer.
But I question his attitude to working hard enough to get there.

His Norwood games have been spasmodic .....periods of brillaince, periods of obscurity.
Verdict: Still only a teenager ...yes he's 19...but next season will be all defining and probably his last chance.

Jason Porplyzia:
Porplyzia continues to develop and is now a first choice player at the Crows.
Great footy brain, great hands ....a natural inside midfielder.
He cannot think his carrer will be as a small forward .....why are we then looking at Didak?
No his career will be defined by his ability to go into the midfield and that requires losing 5 kgs and getting super fit......and that's going to be real tough for him.
Worries me that he has had so much knee problems so early in his carrer.
Verdict: A critical midfield option to where we'll finish in 2008

Brent Reilly:
Has copied the moves of Edwards to compensate for just average pace.
At 24 years we'll see the best of him now .....getting more possessions and critical ones at that.
Is in the game now for longer periods and his disposal is the best in the Crows side.
Verdict: A defining year which sets up a great second half to his career

Mark Ricciuto:
Thanks for the memories

Ben Rutten:
IMO he was on his way to AA selection again .....had the injury and wasn't quite as good BUT had a great seaon none the less.
Suffered a bit when his assistant in Bassett got injured.
Verdict: A very very good season

James Sellar:
Despite comments about a poor season ...IMO it has been a career defining season.
Craig said that he would prefer some players play full reserves SANFL games rather than spasmodic feild time in the SANFL league side.
He's 17 .....has not got the work ethic ....which is a little surprising of an Aust Volleyball rep ....but not of a typical 17 year old

He still plays like a ruckman and has had to learn to play as a KPP with a greater intensity ......full games in the SANFL is the ideal training ground.
Next PS hopefully we see a better commitment to hardening up and changing his current body shape ......a hardef running more intense James Sellar.
A full season in SANFL next season and AFL in his 3rd season ....still at the ripe old age of 19.
Verdict: Club is making all the right decisions to give him the right grounding and attitudes & application for AFL.

Robert Shirley:
Yes been a critic ....and his first half of the season was forgettable after an injury ridden PS.
However he has won me over with a superb last third of the season ....mixing fence and offence in the perfect blend to be one of our most important players going into the finals.
Verdict: two versions of Shirley ....which one will we see in 2008

Scott Stevens:
Always had the atributes we're seeing ....just Sydney and adelaide were trying to make him into a forward KPP which he isn't best suited to.
Nor is he a Defensive KPP as his weight is what has always held him back.
But as a third tall defensive player he is superb .....uses his great footy brain to choose the right option more often than not.
Verdict: Only 25 and is starting to play the best football of his career.

Scott Thompson:
An Enigma .....has played some great game winning footy this year ....has reduced his giving up 50mtr penalties ....but then seems to lose the plot and just give stupid free kicks away time and time again.
Reminds me a lot of Welshes sloppy tackling.
Can't see him as captain but he'll be a valuable contributor for many years.
Most damaging when played up forward ....is a natural forward.
Verdict: Much better year than 2007

Kurt Tippett:
Has skills and athleticism to burn. I can see why the view of him is more as a forward than ruck .....his agility and movement at ground level is superb.
He takes a great contested mark and he knows how to use that body (basketball background)
Verdict: Exciting prospect and looking forward to 2008

Jason Torney:
Excellent player and excellent year .....relatively injury free.
However very noticable that he was slowing up in the finals game and struggling to keep up ....coaches will have noted that.
Verdict: Maybe one more season

Nathan van Berlo:
Future captian .....it's written all over his face.
Just getting better and better .....he's running harder, he's taking the hard bumps ....his disposal under pressure is better as he has adjusted to the games tempo
Verdict: At 21 and with 53 games in the bank, van Berlo is a potential captain and on the back of a great season he looks set to become a key player for the future.

Bernie Vince:
Is a class act at SANFL level, great hands, awreness and disposal.
However his body strength is below average for an AFL player ....his pace is average which could be compensated for with a stronger body ......so there are some question marks.

He hasn't really done PS yet ....but the club has signed him for a further 2 years which is a sign of confidence.
Verdict: Jury Out

Scott Welsh:
Much better as a HFF .....if Tippett can take on FF next season and release Welsh then we'll be well placed.
Has been fairly consistent due to relative injury free run ....not good enough as a KPP but as I said as a HFF could be real damaging ....and that was always his natural position, NOT FF.
Verdict: Despite what some critics may say Welsh had a good season and was one shy of the 50 goal barrier. Unlike many of his teammates he is extremely reliable in front of goal and will receive another contract in 2008.

 

[CaptainDangerfield]

Do you think Pfeiffer is a chance ot be delisted Wayne? I hope not.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Do you think Pfeiffer is a chance ot be delisted Wayne? I hope not.

Yes he's a chance ....more based on attitude rather than whether he's capable of playing AFL.

But given we don't have a plethora of midfielders on our list coming through you'd say he would be retained.

Vince, Douglas, and Mackay are the only developing midfielders coming thru and IMO that's not enough.

 

[Vader]

What follows is an assessment of every player on Adelaide's senior list. I don't know enough about the two remaining rookies (Rhys Archard retired a month ago) to pass a valid judgement. I will be going in increasing order of age.

James Sellar
Sellar was Adelaide's first selection at the 2007 ND, #14 overall. He had an interrupted pre-season (osteitis pubis) and an injury prone year. He played a handfull of games for the Glenelg seniors, but spent most of the second half of the season playing in the Magoos. Crows fans would be disappointed with his lack of development - we would have been expecting him to have become Glenelg's regular CHF in the seniors by now. However, given his injury and lack of a pre-season we're a forgiving lot. Greater things will be expected in 2007, hopefully resulting in a handful (2-3) of AFL games in 2008

David MacKay
Drafted #48 in the 2006 ND. Played one game for South Adelaide reserves and was voted BOG. Played the next week for the South Adelaide seniors and blew his hammie late in the game - but still managed to get listed high in South's best players. Sadly, that was the last we saw of him all year. He re-injured his hamstring twice when attempting to prove his fitness, and the club packed him away in cotton wool for the remainder of the season. He looked exciting when playing in the pre-season NAB challenge games, but that's about all I can say. Will be hoping he returns to full fitness in 2008, forcing his way into the senior side for 5-10 AFL games.

Darren Pfeiffer
Drafted #17 in the 2005 ND. Had an outstanding pre-season, then had his jaw broken when kinghit from behind as he left a nightclub. This ruled him out for the first part of the season, with later games missed due to a bout of glandular fever. Eventually he did return and at times strung together some very good games for the Norwood seniors. He was one of three players handed a club suspension for staying out after curfew (20 minutes). Clearly out of favour with the coaching staff for some reason, as his form was good enough to warrant a debut at times, but no AFL games were forthcoming (indeed he was rarely even named as an emergency). 2008 will be a year of destiny for him - he will either break into the AFL side, or will probably be gone at the end of the year if he fails to do so.

Kurt Tippett
Adelaide's second selection at the 2007 ND, #32 overall. Tippett was drafted as a giant, but mobile, full forward who can ruck a bit. Unfortunately, he was sent to West Adelaide where forwards are not required, as the ball is never in their half of the ground. Reports indicate that he looked good when rucking (the guy is 202cm tall and would be the best ruckman at Westies - though Adelaide need him to be developed as a KPP forward), not so great when playing as a forward. Could have something to do with the quality of delivery down Richmond (suburb of Adelaide) way though. Unfortunately, he missed 2/3 of the season with a shoulder injury. Has been specifically mentioned by AFC management as one of the players who will be fast-tracked in 2008, due to his bigger & stronger physique than most young draftees. Should be aiming for 10-15 AFL games next year.

Andrew McIntyre
McIntyre was promoted from the rookie list, replacing Biglands who was placed on the LTI list. When Biglands was removed from the LTI list, McIntyre was re-elevated again, replacing Hentschel. Showed excellent form in the pre-season matches and when playing at full back for North Adelaide in the SANFL. Was promoted when it appeared Rutten may miss through injury (Rutten recovered and gave Captain Ego his traditional bitch slapping). Was injured shortly after his promotion and wasn't the same player after he returned. Played well in his last couple of games. Would be hoping for a permanent promotion to the senior list, with a debut sometime in 2008. There will be two positions opening up soon in defence, when McLeod and Bassett retire, with McIntyre looking well positioned to replace Bassett in the longer term.

Richard Douglas
After breaking into the side late in 2006, much was expected of Douglas in 2007. He hasn't really delivered, but neither has he been disappointing. He managed to play 13 senior games, which is about what would have been expected of him. He hasn't really shown himself to be a class above the SANFL to date, though he has had a couple of outstanding games. Will need to spend some time in the weights room over summer and will be looking for another 15-20 games next year.

Chris Knights
2007 has been Knights' break-out year. His development has been outstanding. Missed one game through injury, but played the remaining 22 games in the seniors. Regularly picked up 20+ disposals. Has significantly improved his disposal efficiency and "hurt factor" as well. Looks like being a VERY good player in Adelaide's midfield for years to come.

John Meesen
With Clarke gone to St Kilda and Biglands out for the season, it looked like 2007 was going to be Meesen's year. Then he injured his knee playing his first game for the tri-colours, in the mickey mouse cup game against The Evil Empire. He spent the next 5 months watching on from the sidelines as first Griffin, then Maric waltzed further ahead of him. Spent a while in Norwood's magoos upon his return to action, before graduating back to the Norwood seniors where he generally performed well (without being a class above the SANFL rucks). Eventually made his debut in R20 and was given a second game in R21. For some unknown reason he was dropped in favour of Griffin - who had done nothing of note for Centrals in the interval, and who provided even less in the AFL arena in either of Adelaide's last two games for the year. Odds are that Meesen will ask to be traded back to a Victorian team at the end of the year, due to a perception that he lacks opportunity at Adelaide - and I can't say that I blame him. Yet another top-10 draft pick pissed up against the wall.

John Hinge
Hinge is not exactly a fan favourite. Many fans can't see why he's been retained on the list, or why the AFC will retain him again in 2008. He was elevated from the rookie list at the end of 2005. He achieved little for Glenelg in 2006, but with plenty of dead wood to cull ahead of him he was retained. He did have a good pre-season and was performing well enough in the SANFL to justify his AFL debut in R6. Did surprisingly well, before blowing a hammie. To date it remains his only AFL game. His form upon returning to the SANFL was nothing to write home about, though it did improve late in the season when he was moved out of defence and into the midfield. With considerable trade movement and dead wood delistings, Hinge's position is probably safe - though he would want to have an impressive 2008 if he expects to be retained any longer.

Nathan Van Berlo
Van Berlo stands a good chance of becoming Captain of the Adelaide Crows upon Goodwin's retirement in 2 years time. He had a breakout year in 2007, when he became a regular member of Adelaide's midfield - and not just a bench warming replacement. Regularly racked up 20+ disposals, and has a pretty good disposal. Love the courage he continually displays - not even fearing to back into the path of Rocca Bros Jnr in full flight. Outstanding.

Jonathon Griffin
Griffin went into the season ranked #4 - behind Hudson, Maric & Meesen (Biglands MIA through injury). By the end of the pre-season M&M had fallen over and he was #2 - a ranking he retained to the end of the year. Griffin played the first 13 consecutive games of the season, before being rested in the SANFL. He returned to the big league after Hudson got himself a club suspension in R19, and again for the last two matches of the season (R22 and the EF). He played well in the first half dozen games, but really offered very little in the second 2/3 of the season as his body failed to cope with the rigours of playing senior footy - note that he spent most of 2006 playing for the Central Districts magoos. Griffin DOES have a bright future, but he will need to spend a 3rd consecutive summer making love to the weights in the gym if he is to have a significant impact next year. Will probably be tried as a semi-permanent forward next year, as Adelaide attempt to move on from the bunch of mediocre forwards which have sustained them for the past decade.

Ivan Maric
With Biglands MIA through injury, Maric was expected to be The Man - Hudson's #2. Having played 8 games in 2006, he was expected to build significantly on his tally in 2007. Then he went and got injured in the pre-season competition. By the time he returned from injury, 1/3 of the season was gone and Griffin was entrenched in the Adelaide line-up. Maric took a while to recover his mojo playing for the Port Adelaide Magpies, but eventually returned to AFL action in R14 and played the next 6 games. He and Griffin were both dropped after R19 so that Meesen could be tried for a couple of games. During this time, Maric's form was better than Griffin's - yet Griffin was the player called up ahead of the finals. Crows fans are still scratching their heads over that decision. With Meesen likely to be gone in 2008, Maric and Griffin will probably split the games 50-50, so expect him to play around 10-11 games next year.

Bernie Vince
Bernie is now a player caught firmly in no-mans land. He has reached the point where he is now too good for the SANFL, but has not yet managed to consolidate a position in the AFL side. In 2005, Vince was playing country footy. Seemingly drafted from nowhere, he played 4 AFL games in 2006 (debuting in R1). He started 2007 in the side, playing 6 games from R3-8. He was played mainly as a medium sized forward, but didn't really impress much - his best game was his first in which he had 14 disposals (3 of his 6 games had less than 10). Sent back to the SANFL, he got himself injured and missed a few games. However, his form in the latter part of the season was excellent. He has been rewarded with a 2-year contract, so someone at the club obviously rates him. Many fans however have doubts about his pace - and whether he will be able to improve it sufficiently to become an AFL level midfielder.

Jason Porplyzia
Needles was taken in the 2006 PSD, and proceeded to play 11 games in 2006 - announcing himself with an outstanding performance in the semi final win over Fremantle. He continued his good form in 2007, playing 15 games - with most of his absences being caused by injury rather than a lack of form. He has taken the mantle of Adelaide's first choice medium-forward, has sticky hands and is a regular goal scorer (averaging 1 goal per game this year). Crows fans would like to see him increase his pace, with the idea of moving him into the midfield - where he was a superstar for West Adelaide in 2005.

Luke Jericho
With most of the dead wood gone by the end of 2006, Jericho became the Crows' fans' favourite whipping boy. Told that 2007 was going to be make or break, he put in a big pre-season and gave those witches hats a fearful hiding. He did manage to rack up 6 games this year, 6 more than he did in 2006, and was probably unlucky to be dropped after his best game (kicking 4 goals against Carlton) - though he was making way for a club legend in Ricciuto. Jericho is highly skilled, talented and athletic. The problem is that he's soft as butter. He wouldn't know what a contested possession looks like. Most Crows fans formed their opinions of him as a result of the 2006 Mickey Mouse Cup Grand Final - when he was BOG for Geelong. Nothing they've seen since then has caused them to change their minds. I have little doubt that he could have a moderately successful career in the AFL, but he needs to be somewhere else to achieve it - because it's never going to happen under a Neil Craig regime which worships hardness and defensive actions off the ball. There's speculation that Brett Ratten may be interested in acquiring him for Carlton - if so, then I wish him well. If not, then I'm hoping he's one of the first Crows delisted at the end of the year.

Bryce Campbell
Campbell was a surprise selection at the 2007 ND. Norwood's B&F winner, he was a mature aged player - already 22 by the time he was drafted. He missed the early part of the season through injury, before returning to Norwood and re-establishing himself as one of the Redlegs' best players. Eventually his form was rewarded with an AFL debut in R17, but he was immediately dropped without explanation - most fans thought he had done well enough to at least warrant a second game. Apparently NC doesn't think he works hard enough defensively. Unlikely to be delisted at the end of 2007, he would want to have a decent 2008 or he may be on the chopping block this time next year - mature age players have less leniency than teenagers.

Brent Reilly
Reilly had an injury interrupted year, missing a total of six games (and sitting out large parts of two more when injured during the game). However, he was outstanding in many of the games he DID play. He is finally showing why Adelaide rated him so highly as to draft him ahead of Nick Dal Santo way back in 2001. Injuries aside, it was an excellent year for young Radar.

Ben Rutten
For the last three years Rutten has held down the position of FB and done it with aplomb. Did an outstanding job on many of the higher rated gorilla forwards - Pavlich, Brown, Tredrea, BBBBH and Lloyd. Struggles at times on hard leading forwards, due to a lack of pace. Averaged only 1.6 goals against and was probably unlucky not to make the AA squad of 40. Should be happy with what he has achieved this year.

Nathan Bock
Bock started the year in the forward line, where he proved that he makes a great defender. He can pinch hit up there, but isn't mobile enough to do the job full-time. Spent much of the second half of the year at CHB, where he appeared far more comfortable and performed far better. Did a very good job in the EF, eliminating any influence Tim Boyle may have had on the contest. Adelaide may well be looking to restructure their forward line in 2008, hopefully Bock will NOT be part of those plans - he is an outstanding CHB and that is where he needs to remain.

Scott Thompson
In 2005, Thompson was one of the trades of the year. However, he suffered from major disciplinary issues - regularly giving away 50m penalties. In 2006 he calmed down, eliminating many of the indiscretions, but in the process lost a lot of his agression which thus reduced his effectiveness as a player. In many senses, 2007 has been a year where he found a balance - agression without indiscretion. He's a genuine ball-magnet who is capable of winning the hard contested ball. Unfortunately his delivery isn't all that could be hoped for (high clanger count), but this can be worked on and is not entirely unexpected of a player disposing of it where the action is hottest anyway.

Trent Hentschel
Hentschel destroyed his knee on Black Sunday 2006 and didn't play a game all year. Crows fans will be hoping that 2008 brings a return to the form he showed in 2006, though most expect a slow start while he regains confidence in the damaged joint.

Graham Johncock
Stiffy was another to have an injury disrupted year, missing 6 games from R3-8. His form after returning was disappointing, though it did get better as he regained fitness. His form towards the end of the season was outstanding, particularly his game against Geelong in R19. Every pre-season there is talk that he's working on his motor with the aim of moving into the midfield - but this will never happens until he gives up the cancer sticks. Unless that happens, he will remain an outstanding BP or FP player who can be relied upon to do his bit consistently.

Nick Gill
Emu was the Crows' last selection at the 2007 ND, a mature aged "ready made" player to provide cover for Hentschel in the forward line. He missed most of the pre-season and early season with a series of hamstring injuries - big questions were raised over whether his body would hold up to the rigours of an AFL training regime. Not to mention whether he had what it takes to play with the big boys. Eventually he regained fitness and played well for North Adelaide, justifying a debut in R17. He immediately impressed, making the most of his opportunity, going on to play every game from that point on. Gill is best described as Perrie++ - he struggles with his kicking (as does Perrie), but unlike Perrie he can actually take a mark (Perrie has hands of concrete) and is excellent at ground level with the way he harrasses the opposition defenders when not in possession of the ball. Gill's emergence has been one of the main reasons for the ultimate demise of Ian Perrie. I don't see Gill as a long term option - the younger players (Sellar, Tippett and Walker) will hopefully force him out in 2-3 years time, but in the meantime he's definitely an exciting player to have running around in the forward line.

Martin Mattner
In 2005 Mattner was very close to selection as an AA wingman. Then, for some unfathomable reason, Neil Craig decided to turn him into a back pocket player (apparently he wanted him to work on his defensive skills). The move has been a disaster for Mattner, whose confidence is now completely shattered. Mattner is inherently unsuited to playing in defence, having some of the worst decision making skills I've seen in an AFL player. Mattner played 19 of 23 games this season, dropped at one stage for poor form, he starred for Sturt when played in his natural (wing) position in the SANFL. It is in the best interests of both club and player for Mattner to be traded this year. He still has good trade value, with other clubs knowing what he is capable of when played on the wing. His confidence has been shattered by Neil Craig and he needs to seek a new environment in which he can play his best footy once again. I wish him well.

Scott Stevens
After a surprisingly good 2006, 2007 was a season of consolidation for Scott Stevens. He's been asked to play both forward and in defence and has done a pretty good job at both ends of the ground. Considering how I used to berate him for being completely useless, he has turned my opinion of him on its ear. I still don't see him as a great long-term prospect, but for now he's a reasonably good 3rd tall KPP. Would expect a similar 2008 to 2007.

Ken McGregor
Crows fans hoped that McGregor's immobility in 2007 was caused by injury and that his mobility would return in 2008. It didn't - and as a result he fell out of favour with Craig and the coaching hierarchy. Grug remains Adelaide's best contested mark, and he IS an excellent kick for goal (18.2 for the season), but once the ball hits the ground he's out of the contest. As a result, McGregor played only 9 games this year. Reports are that McGregor will ask to be traded to another club where he will receive more opportunities. As the only established KPP forward up for trade at this stage, he will probably command reasonable value - one prospective trade is McGregor + pick #10 to Footscray, in exchange for their pick #5 (to be used on Brad Ebert).

Robert Shirley
Shirley started well, but faded in the middle of the season. Dropped in R17, he responded in the best possible manner with some outstanding football in the latter part of the year - particularly the Brisbane game. Shirley has been around long enough that we know what we're going to get from him. He's Adelaide's #1 tagger and wins a lot of the hard ball in the middle. His position on the list is safe, though he may be reduced to a fringe player depending upon the development of the younger midfielders in 2008.

Kris Massie
Massie started the season on the sidelines, courtesy of an injury. He then returned via Norwood, where he played well (as expected). In R12 he was called back to the senior team and remained there for the remainder of the season. His best performance of the year was the shutdown job he did on Lance Franklin in the first encounter (R14) in wet and slippery conditions. His worst performance was the following week, when asked to stand GHB under the roof at the phone booth. Massie is a solid and dependable HBF type player - but he'll never be anything more than solid. His position is probably safe (certainly he has done nothing wrong), but may come under scrutiny when examining just how many of the lesser "backbone" players the Crows can justify retaining.

Michael Doughty
Doughty is probably one player who will be elsewhere (probably South Adelaide) in 2008. He had a disappointing year, with only a handfull of decent games. Eventually he was dropped in R19 and played only one more game (R21) when injuries limited Adelaide's options. The "young one" is already 28 and his best is well and truly behind him. I expect his name to be one of those announced as a delisting in the days after trade week.

Matthew Bode
Bode missed most of 2005 with injury. Played 23 games in 2006, but only 1 in 2007. Missed R1 with an injury, then injured his knee in R2 - and that was the last we saw of him. Will apparently undergo a medical assessment in 6 weeks time, which will likely determine his fate. When fit, he is an important part of Adelaide's forward line - their best crumber, providing outstanding defensive pressure (leading the league in tackles inside the F50 in 2006). However, his whole career has been punctuated by one injury after another - retaining him would definitely be a calculated risk. May well be a candidate for delisting.

Ian Perrie
Sarge has had a disappointing 2007 season and is by all reports contemplating retirement. Apparently his knees are completely shot and his motivation has gone - to the extent that he will be spending this weekend surfing rather than playing for North Adelaide in the SANFL finals. Sarge has always been a very limited talent - but he got the most out of his career by never giving less than 100%. Perrie will never die wondering, what if…. Considering his lack of talent, he has done remarkably well to last as long as he has (drafted in 1997), outlasting a long list of more highly credentialed forwards. I wish him well in his retirement.

Benjamin Hudson
Had a great year in 2005, but missed most of 2006 with a knee injury. He bounced back well in 2007. Hudson is not the world's greatest ruckmen, but he is a great competitor - at one stage (late in the season) he was 3rd in the league for "hard ball gets" (winning the ball at the centre clearance). Expect him to continue leading Adelaide's ruck division in 2008.

Scott Welsh
Placed on a performance based contract in 2007, having missed too many games through injury in 2006, Welsh responded in the best possible manner. He finished the season as Adelaide's leading goal scorer with 49, the second best season tally of his career. More accurate than many of the other forwards (49.19 for the season), he did a good job. He played enough games this year to trigger a clause in his contract forcing the Crows to renew his contract for 2008, however he turns 29 just before Christmas and probably has only 1 or 2 years left in him.

Brett Burton
This year was not one of Burton's best. He injured his knee early in the season, but played with the injury for another 8 weeks - during which time he contributed absolutely nothing. Eventually he had surgery and returned a considerably better player. He did have his moments, with 4 goal bags against Freo & Essendon and a 24 disposal game in the second Showdown, but overall it was not a great year. At 29 years of age, he is starting to lose the athleticism which made him a star - without the athleticism he is a very ordinary player indeed whose brainfarts become less forgivable. May possibly be trade bait, though I would expect him to be on Adelaide's list in 2008 - for possibly the last time.

Rhett Biglands
The Dirty Dancer injured his knee in the 2006 PF loss to the Weagles and didn't play a game in 2007 as a result. He IS contracted for 2008 and will probably be retained as an insurance policy in case anything should happen to Hudson. He has reportedly lost quite a bit of weight, in an effort to increase his mobility and leap - with the intention of spending more time in the forward line. I see him spending most of 2008 in the SANFL, with Griffin & Maric sharing the backup ruck duties, with 2008 being his last year in Crows colours.

Jason Torney
Torney is one of only 6 players to have played every game this year. He has been his usual, dependable self, providing run out of the back line. However, he has already celebrated his 30th birthday and the Crows announced earlier this year that non-tier-one players would not be carried beyond this mark. He's done nothing wrong to warrant delisting and with plenty of other options ahead of him, I would not expect to see him gone - though the possibility does exist. I would expect 2008 to be the last season for JT.

Simon Goodwin
Goody missed 2 games in the middle of the year to injury, but otherwise played every game. He wasn't quite up to the AA standard he set in 2007, but he wasn't far short of it. However, the signs are there that he is starting to slow down. Will almost certainly be appointed Captain for 2008, having filled that position in Roo's absence for most of 2007. I would anticipate 2008 being his last year.

Nathan Bassett
Bassett missed the last 10 rounds with a broken ankle, but was in excellent form before the injury. He won AA selection in 2006 and his form in the first 13 rounds was no different to what he showed last year. However, Bassett turns 31 before Christmas and time waits for no man - he may have 2 years left on the clock, but I wouldn't be betting on him playing in 2009.

Tyson Edwards
Edwards didn't miss a game in 2007 and there were some rippers amongst them - most notably the EF against Hawthorn where he was arguably Adelaide's best player. However, the signs are there that Edwards is well and truly on the downward slide - his pace is going and with it his decision making (as he has less time to work with due to the opposition closing quicker). I would be VERY surprised to see Edwards playing in 2009.

Andrew McLeod
Macca is the only Adelaide player to be selected in the 40-man AA squad, and is an outside chance of taking home the Brownlow (if Soggy1 and Bartel steal enough votes from each other). Had a great year all round, though he was well covered in the EF loss. Not showing any signs of slowing down, or suffering injury at this stage, so I see him having 2 more years at the top level.

Mark Ricciuto
For Roo, it was one year too many. First there were back problems, then he damaged an ankle, by the end his knees were shot. His body just packed up on him. He did manage 9 games, enough to take the club record, but he really wasn't fit for many of them and probably wouldn't have been selected if he didn't have his name & reputation. Will always be remembered as a champion though, the greatest Crow of all. Thanks for the memories.

 

[CaptainDangerfield]

Brilliant work Vader.

 

[macca23]

Always love your work Vader.

Great read, thorough and right on the money.

 

[conVINCEd]

Great stuff from everyone.

Good to have you back on board, Drummond.

I think '08 could be the final season for a number of players, Edwards and Torney in particular.

 

[Southerntakeover]

I reckon Bock would benefit from being settled into just one position, let him grow into the position without the worry of going all over the shop.

Thanks for stating the bleeding obvious.

 

[crowsarethebest]

Very good reads boys .

 

[AndrewJo]

Great Post Drummond. I don't always agree with your posts re Neil Craig but I appreciate your effort in this review. Plenty of time on your hands now the Legs A team is in mothballs. What about Meese? Any first hand whispers from the parade ..does he really want to leave?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I reckon Bock would benefit from being settled into just one position, let him grow into the position without the worry of going all over the shop.

That position would be CHB, not forward. I think the selectors have finally worked this out.

If only they worked out where Mattner plays his best footy too.

 

[FAST_AS_RFL]

I hope to see the crows go to youth next year and really build for a massive future.
With such a great abundance of the young parade I am hoping that they look to ship a few of the older (and over rated) players like mcgregor out, thats to name only one - instead of getting a similar age and type of player, invest in youth -- quality young players who have played around the 20 game mark and if given the chance will do everything they are told.
Next year im prediciting Nick Gill and Bryce Campbell to really stand out.
Gill has all the makings of one of the best CHF to ever play & Campbell is likely to turn into one of the toughest on ballers about - he will fill the Roo's spot - but in his own style.
With the young talent they have the crows should invest in more and let a young confident group loose on the competition - i know i'd love to see it

 

[CaptainDangerfield]

^^^Mushie season must have started earlier than usual.