MattDoggies
Rookie
- May 3, 2009
- 21
- 0
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Option 1 with Mackie. Swan's a gun player and won't be too far behind Ablett's average and I think Mackie can only improve from here on in with Harley back in the Geelong team.
2009 Trade Discussion - Part 4
- Thread starter spence
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Jeremias
Moderator
- Sep 26, 2004
- 46,219
- 62,619
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #853
Have been hit by injuries and players being dropped, like a lot of others.
Ablett, Beams, Hartlett and Robinson all in my midfield meaning that if I don't trade I'll be 2 down in the middle.
Houlihan in the backs so I'll be copping another 0 if Petrenko is dropped.
I really do not want to trade Ablett, so I won't be going down that path. I've toyed with the idea of not trading at all but that will see me plummet down the rankings and quite possibly lose my eliminator match-up as I'm not facing the worst of teams.
So I'm thinking of trading Beams to Coughlan. Bit of a sideways trade, I know, and Beams has a fair bit more cash to make but Coughlan is set to rocket up in price and should be able to reach 300k, injuries permitting. That means I'll only have to play with the 1 down for this week (Ablett) and quite possibly noone down next week with hopefully 1 or all of Beams, Hartlett, Robinson to play.
What are people's thoughts about trading Beams to Coughlan?
Note: This could all turn to s**t if Petrenko is dropped as it will most probably require me to use another trade which ideally I would want to avoid. I ****ing hope he plays, and I think he will.....
Ablett, Beams, Hartlett and Robinson all in my midfield meaning that if I don't trade I'll be 2 down in the middle.
Houlihan in the backs so I'll be copping another 0 if Petrenko is dropped.
I really do not want to trade Ablett, so I won't be going down that path. I've toyed with the idea of not trading at all but that will see me plummet down the rankings and quite possibly lose my eliminator match-up as I'm not facing the worst of teams.
So I'm thinking of trading Beams to Coughlan. Bit of a sideways trade, I know, and Beams has a fair bit more cash to make but Coughlan is set to rocket up in price and should be able to reach 300k, injuries permitting. That means I'll only have to play with the 1 down for this week (Ablett) and quite possibly noone down next week with hopefully 1 or all of Beams, Hartlett, Robinson to play.
What are people's thoughts about trading Beams to Coughlan?
Note: This could all turn to s**t if Petrenko is dropped as it will most probably require me to use another trade which ideally I would want to avoid. I ****ing hope he plays, and I think he will.....
iluvparis
Import Whisperer
- Apr 1, 2005
- 50,055
- 40,651
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Calgary Flames, Man Utd
If they are both on your bench I would go with Walker. More likely to drop than rise in price this week where as obviously Lucas price will remain constant.
nevergunalerners
Draftee
Is anyone trading walker this week?
And who too other than mcaffer?
Ballentyne?
And who too other than mcaffer?
Ballentyne?
I did it last week for warren but if you must do it this week then you should get MCAFFER not ballentyn because you dont know when he is coming or if he'll keep his spot but Mcaffer has put on some good dt scores
Ok, what should I do?
Trade Dayne Beams out to Cockie or Deboer in order to cover for Ablett.
Then trade Andrew Raines up to Jarryn Geary in order to cover for Houlihan.
Or
Trade Beams out for Coughlan to cover for Ablett and hoepfully become a keeper and cop a zero with Houlihan?
How do you think Jarryn Geary will go from now on?
Personally, I'm leaning towards the latter. I think Coughlan could be good this season provided he stays injury free, whilst Geary doesn't seem like a keeper. Although, I wish I didn't have to cop a zero.
Trade Dayne Beams out to Cockie or Deboer in order to cover for Ablett.
Then trade Andrew Raines up to Jarryn Geary in order to cover for Houlihan.
Or
Trade Beams out for Coughlan to cover for Ablett and hoepfully become a keeper and cop a zero with Houlihan?
How do you think Jarryn Geary will go from now on?
Personally, I'm leaning towards the latter. I think Coughlan could be good this season provided he stays injury free, whilst Geary doesn't seem like a keeper. Although, I wish I didn't have to cop a zero.
Hey guys got a few options for trades this week, just like to know what you guys would do
A:Rich/Otten out for Hayes then Porp up to Gia
B:Rich/Otten out for Mitchell then Porp up to Franklin
C:Otten out for M.Murphy then Porp to Franklin
D: Porp to Pavlich and hold onto rich and Otten for a little longer
Thanks
A:Rich/Otten out for Hayes then Porp up to Gia
B:Rich/Otten out for Mitchell then Porp up to Franklin
C:Otten out for M.Murphy then Porp to Franklin
D: Porp to Pavlich and hold onto rich and Otten for a little longer
Thanks
Option B
I dont rate mcaffers job security. About 30% of teams on the pies board for this round had him as an out, and with didak, anthony and beams to come back int he following weeks, I cant see him lasting more than 3 weeks.
D for mine. Get Kornes next week for Rich/Otten.
D is for dylan123...
option d because rich and otten has more growth in them
ok so.
I wana trade out Houlhan and have 50k in the bank
I miss out on mackie and fisher by like 1k which is devistating and i dont want to trade beams to cockie until i get a better look at him so..
Should i trade houlihan to drummond? I have adcock in the bakcs already
or
Gilbee/gram etc
I wana trade out Houlhan and have 50k in the bank
I miss out on mackie and fisher by like 1k which is devistating and i dont want to trade beams to cockie until i get a better look at him so..
Should i trade houlihan to drummond? I have adcock in the bakcs already
or
Gilbee/gram etc
Got Kornes, but from the people that i have asked they think Pav is the best so i think i will go for D.
Thanks for the reply's guys
According to FF Genie Fishers breakeven is 90 and it expects him to go down $1,800 so maybe wait 1 week and with any luck get him?
If not i dont think its worth trading houlihan for drummond because he will be back in the side next week or the week after according to everyone.
wait a week and get fisher got settle for people you dont want
First of all i would change ur captain
I think you should hold onto ablett because when his back he will just dominate again so maybe downgrade petrenko to maybe Pratt then upgrade beams to coughlan?
It is risky and you do lose an extra trade to keep Ablett.
13_Stitches
Senior List
just went to trade beams to couglin and accidently selected andrew collins :-(.
yeah still leaves me with a zero, better to hav it in the back than the mid?First of all i would change ur captain
I think you should hold onto ablett because when his back he will just dominate again so maybe downgrade petrenko to maybe Pratt then upgrade beams to coughlan?
It is risky and you do lose an extra trade to keep Ablett.
and the side;
any other ideas? 29k in the bank
sossy19
Debutant
DeBoer or Cockie?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
hahahahaha that's hilarious.
how is that possible? you even get a confirm screen.
are you drunk?
Similar threads
