2012 Top 5 Scorers in Each Position

[Super Hans]

There was this thread on the dream team board, prediction thread for who will be the top 5 scorers in each position by the end of the years.


Defenders

1.Goddard
2.Shaw
3.Newman
4.Deledio
5.Scotland

Mids
1.Ablett
2.Selwood
3.Swan
4.Murphy
5.Pendles

Rucks
1.Mumford
2.Sandilands
3.Goldstien
4.Cox
5.Jacobs

Forwards
1.Franklin
2.Chapman
3.Beams
4.Fyfe
5.Martin

 

[spudmaster]

My crystal ball appears to be a little dusty...ask again in September and I'm sure it'll be readable again.

 

[NT.Thunder]

Whilst people rubbish these threads, this is 1 of the most important exercises that you can do in selecting yr starting squad. I usually look at my guess of a top 10 each position, apart from rucks and only select premiums that are included. Of course value picks and injury will make up the rest in a guns-rookie team.

On iPhone so I'm not going to post my top picks

 

[longytap]

Also very important to factor in Durability when making these lists.
Players like Buddy are always at risk of missing games for various reasons, therefore making their ability to finish top five in their respective position on total points more difficult.

 

[SugarRayRichard]

Also very important to factor in Durability when making these lists.
Players like Buddy are always at risk of missing games for various reasons, therefore making their ability to finish top five in their respective position on total points more difficult.

Harvey last year scored 100 more total points than franklin

 

[longytap]

Harvey last year scored 100 more total points than franklin

Exactly my point

 

[GotTheGoodes]

Hey guyz....would love some feedback.

Defenders= Goddard, Deldido, H Shaw, Mackie, Grimes, Buntine, M Clarke
(Smedts, Morris)
Midfielders= J Selwood, Gibbs, Martin, Docherty, Mcdonald, Shiel
(Kavangnah, Crozier)
Rucks= Mummford, Macintosh
(Stepthenson, Giles)
Forwards= Franklin, Chapman, Rioli, Sylvia, Higgins, Dangerfired, Zorko
(Rowe, Walsh)


cheers in advance

How about you post this on the "rate my team" thread as opposed to the "2012 Top 5 scorers in each position (which isn't another thread for you spam your team on so other people can do research for you)" thread??

I thought the title of most threads here are pretty specific and clear. I've no time for any kind of multi-post &/or spam-like posts or posts which don't even relate to thread discussion. Sorry mate.

 

[MightyMark]

For what it’s worth, here are my 2 cents on the topic.

I also put my next 5 in bold (except for the rucks), most people will have a fairly similar top 5, but I think the next 5 could be interesting.

In no particular order:

Backs:

Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Broughton, Scotland (Fisher, Birchall, Yarran, Enright, Adcock)

Mids:

Pendlebury, Ablett, Swan, Murphy, Selwood, (Judd, Priddis, Hodge, Rockliff, Thompson)

Rucks:

Cox, Mumford, Sandilands, Luenberger, McEvoy

Forwards:

Franklin, Goodes, Martin, Pavlich, Chapman (O’Keefe, J. Brown, Zaharakis, Cloke, S. Johnson)

I’ve tried to be impartial with regards to injuries. Otherwise players like Brown, Broughton and Adcock would be out, and others like Chapman, Franklin and Ablett may be lower given they always miss a couple of games through-out the year.

 

[cheese#43]

How about you post this on the "rate my team" thread as opposed to the "2012 Top 5 scorers in each position (which isn't another thread for you spam your team on so other people can do research for you)" thread??

I thought the title of most threads here are pretty specific and clear. I've no time for any kind of multi-post &/or spam-like posts or posts which don't even relate to thread discussion. Sorry mate.

sorry i accidently posted in the wrong thread.
i've deleted the post
....keep your shirt on

 

[Deliverance]

Harvey last year scored 100 more total points than franklin

That's because he played 3 more games than buddy. Any SCer worth their salt would have had a bench player covering buddy's absences scoring 50-70 ppg, an additional 150-210 points which more than makes up the difference.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Defenders

Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Birchall, Grimes, Scotland

Mids

Selwood, Pendles, GAJ, Swan, Murphy

Rucks

Berger, Mummy, Sandi, Cox, Jacobs

Fwds

Goodes, Franklin, Chapman, Cloke, Martin