2013 Player X v Player Y

[CaptScott]

1.Nicholls vs Cox
2. roughead vs roo

Got to go roo, and cheap at the moment. As for Nichols v Cox who knows, Cox probably as he often pops up with monster scores when you least expect it, but... Nichols is cheaper and we have lots of trades so give it a shot.

 

[oddsok]

ROK + Grimes vs Enright + Malceski?

 

[kierez4ever]

who to trade in: Joel Selwood or Brent Stanton?

 

[meesy]

Stanton. Not sold on Selwood.

 

[SloppyJoe]

ROK + Grimes vs Enright + Malceski?

ROK + Grimes

I am bringing in Grimes this week, but who goes out: Terlich or Hartlett?

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

I'd get rid of Hartlett. He could very well get his be of 115 but he could also score 30. Terlich was on a role untill he played Geelong. I'm getting rid of Grimes for Terlich this round but I don't have anyone else but Staker to trade out. He's gone next week.

 

[06Premiers]

Enright vs Malceski vs Ibbotson vs Shaw?

Who to grab to finish my back line?

 

[SloppyJoe]

I'd get rid of Hartlett. He could very well get his be of 115 but he could also score 30. Terlich was on a role untill he played Geelong. I'm getting rid of Grimes for Terlich this round but I don't have anyone else but Staker to trade out. He's gone next week.

I am concerned that, with Grimes now fit and firing and Viney to come back this week, Terlich will not have as much opportunity to push up into the midfield and run/carry.

The reality is that it really only boils down to who will score most / lose least $ this week as I'll be moving the other on next week.

 

[CaptScott]

Enright vs Malceski vs Ibbotson vs Shaw?

Who to grab to finish my back line?

hmmmm... one of these is averaging 10+ points more than the others and is at a pretty good price...

or Enright for POD

 

[SloppyJoe]

Who to get rid of for Cloke? Macaffer or Lecras?

Whoever remains will play this week and then become F7 for the rest of the season.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Trading out Buddy and deciding on N Riewolt or Bartel.. also upgrading Vlaustin and deciding on H Shaw or T McKenzie.

 

[SloppyJoe]

Trading out Buddy and deciding on N Riewolt or Bartel.. also upgrading Vlaustin and deciding on H Shaw or T McKenzie.

Bartel/Roo a fifty-fifty I reckon. Similar scoring ability, but Roo is a bit more consistent. Bartel a strong chance to be rested. Roo's dodgy knee does tend to flare up a bit and, although he has had a rest already, I wouldn't rule out another before season's end, particularly with the Saints not pushing for finals.

I would take Shaw over McKenzie, Shaw has an easy run coming up.

 

[Quazza]

Enright or Grimes to finish a defense ?

 

[C_Turn]

tough decisions to be made

Forwards - Cloke v Riewoldt v Stokes
Defenders - Enright v Ibbotson v Malceski

One of each
Kgo

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

Riewoldt & Malceski

Still not sold on Stokes for some reason. I have Ibbo and since I got him in he has been average.

 

[tupperware]

Riewoldt & Malceski

Still not sold on Stokes for some reason. I have Ibbo and since I got him in he has been average.

Not sold on Stokes? Increased his average from 65-95 in one year. Picked him up at the beginning of the year and have not be disappointed once. (Even with one late withdrawal)

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

Jeez I think just about everyone C Turn listed sucked besides Riewoldt. Hopefully he just kept Staker

 

[frello02]

Have goddard heppell hanley gibbs shaw terlich goodes clisby. Trading goodes out. Question is for mckenzie or hibberd? Liked hibberd early but didnt get him because of the bye rounds but has sort of dropped off as late. Thoughts?

 

[HenrikLundqvist]

What to do with that little campaigner Bartel?

What do you guys reckon about fielding Kreuzer, Nicholls in the ruck with Cox taking over Bartel's spot in the forwardline? Giving me a starting six of:

JJK, Cloke, SJ, Rockliff, Martin, Cox

Weary about how Jimmy will go against the Saints where as Cox should dominate resting forward against the dogs.

 

[CaptScott]

What to do with that little silly Bartel?

What do you guys reckon about fielding Kreuzer, Nicholls in the ruck with Cox taking over Bartel's spot in the forwardline? Giving me a starting six of:

JJK, Cloke, SJ, Rockliff, Martin, Cox

Weary about how Jimmy will go against the Saints where as Cox should dominate resting forward against the dogs.

Do it. Hang on to Bartel, no reason to expect he won't get back to good DT scores after the enforced rest.

 

[lmach]

Enright v Malceski?

 

[Atley]

What to do with that little silly Bartel?

What do you guys reckon about fielding Kreuzer, Nicholls in the ruck with Cox taking over Bartel's spot in the forwardline? Giving me a starting six of:

JJK, Cloke, SJ, Rockliff, Martin, Cox

Weary about how Jimmy will go against the Saints where as Cox should dominate resting forward against the dogs.

NN shouldn't play this week, he is stuff. Cox will likely be head to head with Minson whom is a good ruckman so Cox wont be getting lots of points from hitouts. Will likely get lots of mark-kicks though.

SJ is captain material for mine this week.

 

[Fitzey]

Beams vs GWS in good form Vs SJ?

 

[BomberJosh]

Cox or Nicholls ? Weird question given cox is elite and can pump out a 140 randomly.

I ask because cox is only avg 60 odd over the last 3 and Nicholls is avg around the 80-90 or so mark.

Next week I will be down grading cox to gather over 250k and using Nicholls as my second ruck to Kruezer. Then I can start upgrading my premos to the elite premos.

My opponent this week has cox in the ruck, should I play it safe and go with cox this week that I have him? Or go head to head with my opponent?

Thanks.

 

[BomberJosh]

Or I could trade Nichols and keep cox, and use that cash to go more premos?